Jump to content

Denied entry (TR) at Suvarnabhumi - no stamp - options?


Recommended Posts

Just now, Dan5 said:

"In the morning I realize the dude is Lao Airlines ground employee, not an immigration officer. " Are you saying you were not detained by immigration, but an airline employee?? It seems that the answer to that question would mean a lot in determining your next move.

And if so, a more interesting and indeed bizarre story.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find the 'take your g/f/future wife to your home country, you're not welcome here' awful.

 

That was an opportunity for a camera phone vid to let social media jump on pure IO xenophobia.

Or should have gotten this rough female  IOs ID and put in a formal complaint.

 

What happens if he refused to sign the bullshido paperwork ? Stuck in detention ?

 

Do Laos/Thailand land border crossings have this detention nonsense - or do they just bounce you back to Laos ?

I'm currently on tourist visas to actually see Laos on each new tourist visa run (about a week to 2 weeks in most instances touring Lao) so would like to know what can happen on a land border crossing potentially on a string of tourist visas/visa-exempt just under 1 year in a new passport...is this 270 days of tourist visas/visa-exempts causing an alert just here-say as I'll be going over 270 days of tourist visas/visa-exempts soon.

 

I guess having 20k in-hand, a flight out within 60 days, a travel itenerary for the 60-day period , accommodation booking/rental agreement information and proof of substantial funds coming in monthly from outside the country helps a person who is questioned ? Would they let you pull up your life savings abroad online etc ?

 

I plan on getting off tourist visas completely after this report later in the year, but don't want a forced repatriation to my country suddenly.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, moe666 said:

He has been living in Thailand for 3 years he is not a tourist

And I wouldn't hang my hat on the idea that getting a new passport will paper over one's record of entries and resolve everything.  The OP is traveling with a pair of dice in his pocket...

Edited by hawker9000
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, hawker9000 said:

And I wouldn't hang my hat on the idea that getting a new passport will paper over one's record of entries and resolve everything.  The OP is traveling with a pair of dice in his pocket...

He just needs to get on a non-tourista type visa after new passport and a few weeks break back home I'd guess.....

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 13/04/2017 at 3:05 PM, stoicccc said:

-I've been in Thailand for 3-4 years 36-yrs old Finnish guy, first on ED-visa, then TRs and visa exempts mixed, mostly TRs from Laos with 2-3 visa exempts in between.

I stopped reading after  "  -I've been in Thailand for 3-4 years 36-yrs old Finnish guy, first on ED-visa, " ......  

 

maybe cambodia will be ok ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, steven100 said:

I stopped reading after  "  -I've been in Thailand for 3-4 years 36-yrs old Finnish guy, first on ED-visa, " ......  

 

maybe cambodia will be ok ...

You've got a point there.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, steven100 said:

I stopped reading after  "  -I've been in Thailand for 3-4 years 36-yrs old Finnish guy, first on ED-visa, " ......  

 

maybe cambodia will be ok ...

Agreed that Cambodia, Vietnam, the Philippines, and others would welcome his foreign-sourced capital.  That said, many continue to stay in Thailand on Tourist Visas much longer than the OP. 

 

Staggering the entries more, etc could work, but he's getting married, which will solve the "permission of stay" problem (though could create new ones :-0 - just kidding OP - best of luck with your new family.)
 

33 minutes ago, hawker9000 said:

And I wouldn't hang my hat on the idea that getting a new passport will paper over one's record of entries and resolve everything.  The OP is traveling with a pair of dice in his pocket...

Yes, a new passport would help - note how the IO was going through it all "tsk tsk" - and had an ED Visa in it, which is the Worst Red Flag.  He might have been OK with a new passport -  probably just "stamp / stamp / next..." at the desk - certainly with the 20K Baht Cash + a clean passport.

 

Edit:  To anyone with a used ED visa in your passport - my advice is to get a new passport from your embassy ASAP if you plan to travel to or stay in Thailand.

Edited by JackThompson
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, JackThompson said:

You would have your exit from Laos canceled if refused entry to Thailand, and your original permission-to-stay given on your initial entry would continue to run. 

Right, just to clarify above. If I had a 30-day Laos tourist visa and had only used 10 days and got bounced back from Thai side...the 20 remaining days on the Laos tourist visa would still be valid ? I always thought you'd need to buy a fresh 30 days in Laos again...

Edited by freedomnow
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, freedomnow said:

Right, just to clarify above. If I had a 30-day Laos tourist visa and had only used 10 days and got bounced back from Thai side...the 20 remaining days on the Laos tourist visa would still be valid ? I always thought you'd need to buy a fresh 30 days in Laos again...

I do not think so, because you don't have an "exit" from another country, you never "really left" Laos.  Air vs Land might differ in how it is handled, but it would seem that the OP re-entered without a new visa (pls correct me if wrong).  I would not be surprised if some sort of "fee" was requested in some cases.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Where does a tourist visit or multiple visits end and living fulltime in the Kingdom begin (using temporary stay tourist visas)? Many countries including Thailand don't allow the latter. Seems past practice of lax enforcement of this is fading In Thailand. 'We don't want you here?' Indeed as an fake tourist you are not wanted, despite having money or gf or any other personal reason. You can visit but cannot live full time...same as a hundred other countries. This clamp down has been happening for several years now.

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 13/04/2017 at 3:38 PM, stoicccc said:

I decided to book the Finnair flight to Helsinki tomorrow morning and roll with it. Stay back home for a while, get a fresh passport, new TR visa and come to Thailand again and get married finally, should have done a while ago already. Hopefully that'll work out. 

While you're away why not re-evaluate you life, look for a nice Finnish girl and realise that staying in Thailand in not the only path to happiness. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, jerojero said:

Where does a tourist visit or multiple visits end and living fulltime in the Kingdom begin (using temporary stay tourist visas)? Many countries including Thailand don't allow the latter. Seems past practice of lax enforcement of this is fading In Thailand. 'We don't want you here?' Indeed as an fake tourist you are not wanted, despite having money or gf or any other personal reason. You can visit but cannot live full time...same as a hundred other countries. This clamp down has been happening for several years now.

 

 

Someone using multiple back-to-back tourist visas to stay may technically be classified as a 'tourist', but I do not believe that is the 'Spirit of the law' (or the original intent of the tourist visas).  More than likely this is a 'loophole' that has never been fully closed.

 

Just because you can do something doesn't mean you were meant to do it.

 

Also, just because you wish to be a tourist in one country 100% of the year, does not mean the country has to accommodate that wish.

 

Technically, you are a non-immigrant alien, and quite possibly a non-immigrant resident alien (due to being here more than 180 days/year which usually results in a classification of residency and tax obligations).  One's status has nothing to do with whether or not they work.

 

He could also be classified as a 'retiree' (if he's not working) but they don't offer visas for retirees.  So I guess another classification would be: Unwanted mis-classified long-stay alien.

 

Irregard, he should definitely consider a more appropriate classification (Thailand Elite, Business, Marriage, etc.) if he wishes to avoid future angst.  Also, TE may be cheaper than marriage in the long run :)

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, freedomnow said:

Right, just to clarify above. If I had a 30-day Laos tourist visa and had only used 10 days and got bounced back from Thai side...the 20 remaining days on the Laos tourist visa would still be valid ? I always thought you'd need to buy a fresh 30 days in Laos again...

When I fly back to Lao, they did cancel the last exit stamp and the "USED" stamp on the visa. Had I tried Nong Khai border, I would have been stamped out again and if denied entry to Thailand again, it probably would have been a tricky situation unless they just allow me to get a new visa to Lao. But no idea, since I didn't try. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, freedomnow said:

I find the 'take your g/f/future wife to your home country, you're not welcome here' awful.

 

That was an opportunity for a camera phone vid to let social media jump on pure IO xenophobia.

Or should have gotten this rough female  IOs ID and put in a formal complaint.

 

It almost felt that they tried to get me angry and to piss me off, it seemed a bit unreal the things they were saying. 

Edited by stoicccc
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, stoicccc said:

I just hope I will get in the country with the new PP,  new TR visa from Finland Thai Embassy, 20k cash, flight out and hotel reservation...and get married, as has been the plan for a while now.

Thanks for the very complete report.  Yes, they can pull up your whole history, though this is not shown on the initial screen by the first IO you deal with. 

 

It is so sick and twisted that you were taken by an ATM, where you had the money, but they refused your entry and did not let you go to an ATM to prove you had the money.  Airport Immigration is like living through a freaking Kafka novel.

 

I would suggest flying to Penang via KL, then train into Thailand.  I would not try to enter by Air, because who knows what they put in the computer in your file.  Everything else in your plan sounds good.  As soon as you are married, you can go to Savanahket, Laos, and get a 1-year Multi-Entry Non-O based on marriage.  After that, just use friendly land-borders.  See this thread where a fellow with a marriage-visa was hassled at the airport (airport = trap):

https://www.thaivisa.com/forum/topic/978488-being-denied-entry-with-marriage-visa

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Many Thai consulates are requiring a pre booked exit ticket from Thailand before they  will issue a 60 day tourist visa.

Ho Chi Minh City in Vietnam is one of them.

There are signs in Penang Malaysia that warn backpackers that they may be required to show the sum of 20,000 baht per person when crossing the Thai land border with Malaysia.

I have seen them myself.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, JackThompson said:

Thanks for the very complete report.  Yes, they can pull up your whole history, though this is not shown on the initial screen by the first IO you deal with. 

 

It is so sick and twisted that you were taken by an ATM, where you had the money, but they refused your entry and did not let you go to an ATM to prove you had the money.  Airport Immigration is like living through a freaking Kafka novel.

 

I would suggest flying to Penang via KL, then train into Thailand.  I would not try to enter by Air, because who knows what they put in the computer in your file.  Everything else in your plan sounds good.  As soon as you are married, you can go to Savanahket, Laos, and get a 1-year Multi-Entry Non-O based on marriage.  After that, just use friendly land-borders.  See this thread where a fellow with a marriage-visa was hassled at the airport (airport = trap):

https://www.thaivisa.com/forum/topic/978488-being-denied-entry-with-marriage-visa

 

thanks for the help buddy.

 

I'm a bit confused about the NON-O visas based on marriage.

 

It seems to me that there are 2 options when it comes to a marriage visa:

 

1) Obtain a NON-O marriage visa from Savannakhet/Finland with multiple entries, and then I  just leave the country every 90 days for 12 months, and go to apply for a visa again? (or possibly for an extension at some point?)


2) Obtain a NON-O marriage visa from Savannakhet/Finland for 90 days, go to an immigration office in Thailand, apply for a 12 month extension with the requirements fulfilled and no need to leave the country as I can apply for another extension in 12 months?

 

Are these 2 alternative options for a marriage visa? Please correct me where I'm wrong.

 

Million thanks for all the comments, both negative and positive. I'm learning a lot here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Time to go home and work! I suggest getting a visa for your GF to join you in Finland. It's very cold there and you'll need someone to keep you warm in bed. Good Luck & visit us in Thailand sometime in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, stoicccc said:

thanks for the help buddy.

 

I'm a bit confused about the NON-O visas based on marriage.

 

It seems to me that there are 2 options when it comes to a marriage visa:

 

1) Obtain a NON-O marriage visa from Savannakhet/Finland with multiple entries, and then I  just leave the country every 90 days for 12 months, and go to apply for a visa again? (or possibly for an extension at some point?)


2) Obtain a NON-O marriage visa from Savannakhet/Finland for 90 days, go to an immigration office in Thailand, apply for a 12 month extension with the requirements fulfilled and no need to leave the country as I can apply for another extension in 12 months?

 

Are these 2 alternative options for a marriage visa? Please correct me where I'm wrong.

 

Million thanks for all the comments, both negative and positive. I'm learning a lot here.

Yes - exactly those 2 options.  But you cannot get this now in your home-country, because you are not married yet.  The reason Savanahket is recommended, is that they do not require financial-proof for the 1-Year Multiple Entry Non-O based on marriage. 

 

If you can transfer 400K Baht into a Thai bank account, or prove an income of 40K Baht / mo, plus jump through several more hoops (show pictures, get declarations from neighbors that you live together, etc), you can apply for a 1-year extension from your local immigration office.  The enforced requirements vary by the office.  Note that if you wish to leave and return to Thailand during this extension period, you need to purchase a re-entry permit, or your extension is voided on exit.

 

Also, when applying for the 1-year extension, you first need to be on a Non-O entry.  Some offices can do conversions from Tourist entries to a 90-day Non-O, but most can not.  This is another reason for going to Laos - even if just to get the initial 90-Day Non-O based on marriage, which you then extend for a year by showing financial proof.

 

Which way you go depends, to a great extent, on how "friendly" your local immigration office is.  If they are happy you are there supporting your wife, go for the 1-year extension.  If they act like you are an "unwanted" farang - go for the 1-year Multi-Entry and avoid them entirely.  Someone who deals with your office may be able to chime-in and give you a heads-up on their attitudes - which vary wildly from office to office, and checkpoint to checkpoint.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

All this talk of airports being traps is worrying me. I'm a long stayer in Thailand but mostly with a non-b and work permit. However, I've been on 2 tourist visas and one visa exempt for the past 6 months. My plan is to fly to HCMC for my next tourist visa. Is that a risk or do  I have a while yet before I get flagged?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, JackThompson said:

Yes - exactly those 2 options.  But you cannot get this now in your home-country, because you are not married yet.  The reason Savanahket is recommended, is that they do not require financial-proof for the 1-Year Multiple Entry Non-O based on marriage. 

 

If you can transfer 400K Baht into a Thai bank account, or prove an income of 40K Baht / mo, plus jump through several more hoops (show pictures, get declarations from neighbors that you live together, etc), you can apply for a 1-year extension from your local immigration office.  The enforced requirements vary by the office.  Note that if you wish to leave and return to Thailand during this extension period, you need to purchase a re-entry permit, or your extension is voided on exit.

 

Also, when applying for the 1-year extension, you first need to be on a Non-O entry.  Some offices can do conversions from Tourist entries to a 90-day Non-O, but most can not.  This is another reason for going to Laos - even if just to get the initial 90-Day Non-O based on marriage, which you then extend for a year by showing financial proof.

 

Which way you go depends, to a great extent, on how "friendly" your local immigration office is.  If they are happy you are there supporting your wife, go for the 1-year extension.  If they act like you are an "unwanted" farang - go for the 1-year Multi-Entry and avoid them entirely.  Someone who deals with your office may be able to chime-in and give you a heads-up on their attitudes - which vary wildly from office to office, and checkpoint to checkpoint.

 

19 minutes ago, thaitero said:

Many Finnish with thai wifes do annual visits to homeland. No financial proof  needed for the 1-Year Multiple Entry Non-O based on marriage there either.

Once again, many thanks :) 

 

Will I get hassled for 20k, tickets etc with the option  1)  (below) at the immigration or is that a problem related to TR only?

 

1) Obtain a NON-O marriage visa from Savannakhet/Finland with multiple entries, and then I  just leave the country every 90 days for 12 months, and go to apply for a visa again? (or possibly for an extension at some point?)

 

I will very likely go through the hoops with the 400k and the pictures but just wanna make sure I understand the other option clearly as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/13/2017 at 9:41 PM, HiSoLowSoNoSo said:

"if you have Thai GF and you love her, take her to your home country and stay there, you are not wanted here" from another elderly female officer

 

 

This immigration lady should be reported to the TAT, the immigration department of Thailand are scaring tourists away from Thailand now.

AGREED--would LOVE to see her face if i had to go back and identify here..name n shame her..

and then be headed back home before she comes after u!..Such a welcoming thai woman --ugh

 

My response to her-WHY would i want to TAKE my GF AWAY from such a WONDERFUL place..:saai:

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, stoicccc said:

Once again, many thanks :) 

Will I get hassled for 20k, tickets etc with the option  1)  (below) at the immigration or is that a problem related to TR only?

1) Obtain a NON-O marriage visa from Savannakhet/Finland with multiple entries, and then I  just leave the country every 90 days for 12 months, and go to apply for a visa again? (or possibly for an extension at some point?)

I will very likely go through the hoops with the 400k and the pictures but just wanna make sure I understand the other option clearly as well.

You should have 20K Baht upon entry with a Non-O - same as a TR.  This is the case with a re-entry on a Non-O extension - same as a Multi-Entry Non-O.  Bottom line, every time you enter Thailand they can ask to see the money. 

 

But, based on reports, the extent and frequency of being hassled is greatly reduced on a Non-O vs a TR.  Most people on those visas are never questioned.  Just put 20K Baht in travelers checks, keep it with you, and you are set.  If they get lost or stolen, the money is refunded - you only lose the fee to purchase them. 

Edited by JackThompson
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, JackThompson said:

You should have 20K Baht upon entry with a Non-O - same as a TR.  This is the case with a re-entry on a Non-O extension - same as a Multi-Entry Non-O.  Bottom line, every time you enter Thailand they can ask to see the money. 

 

The 20k baht should never be asked for when entering on re-entry permit issued for an extension of stay based upon marriage. The 20k baht requirement really only applies to visa and visa exempt entries.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.











×
×
  • Create New...