Jump to content

Reason for anti-falang rules?


Recommended Posts

On 5/22/2019 at 5:26 AM, Bang Bang said:

Your second sentence not only contradicts the first, it's likely flat wrong. A long-stayer by definition is not a tourist. Moreover, a retiree on a budget (=typical long-stayer) almost certainly puts less into the economy than 4 1-week tourists.

 

A previous poster hit the nail on the head: Thais are not anti-farang, they are pro-rich. Case in point, million-baht Elite visa holders are VIPed through airports and have zero immigration hassles to deal with. Another: see the difference in treatment one gets anywhere from shops to restaurants if one is sharply dressed with a stylish haircut vs. casual with a 2-day stubble. I know superficial but Thais are big on appearances. And money talks really loud here.

right, they see with their eyes and not their hearts, perfect Buddhist

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Los Luver said:

Once, a year or so ago, I read on pattayaone that the police was called to 7/11 near Soi Buakhao. 2 farangs were suspected of stealing from the shop. When the police arrived. They found that the 2 farangs weenre hiding lot of items such tooth paste shampoo and other things... and the only things they wanted to pay were nudles and generally few items that costed less than 10 Baht.....

Later, the police found out that the thieves were overstaying their visas.....

when your down to stealing toothpaste, time to go home

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So ok we can  go 'anti farang' bashing and like all of us on here we've witnessed said things fore mentioned such as (in my case)the Irish guy some 5 years back who used to beg for money up around Soi 15 Suk' with his sob story sign to get home..then I busted him drinking in a bar on the corner of soi 20!No remorse and quite arrogant infact...but then the German guy with the beard and rag clothing (no shoes)who slept in the doorways up around soi 14/16 who was mentally ill and did receive help(eventually).My personal spin on things now are that Thailand most certainly isn't the cheap promised land/utopia it once was and any Cheap Charlie landing on these shores now will quickly be found out economically if they have no money.These new laws are aimed at these types I suspect!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/22/2019 at 1:26 AM, SteveK said:

Thailand has historically often hosted some of the shiftier farangs, who were either into something suspect or couldn't return home for whatever reason. And then you've got the reputation as being a sex-pat haven. I suppose they want to clean up their international reputation.

Yes I read some stories and news, you are 100% correct.

 

But why those criminals and sex tourists choose Thailand? Did those bad people shifted Thailand from law abiding country to chaos?

 

No. It's because everyone including police and government is easily corrupted. They take their cash and look the other way.

 

That's the issue needed to fix.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, kenk24 said:

It seems to be a thing all around the world now... 

 

It used to be that farang were viewed as being wealthy... there now seems to be a large increase in farang who can no longer afford to live in the Western World and have chosen here above homelessness... 

 

I think most of it so far is not anti-farang just enforcing the rules that existed. No more unverifiable income statements and a bit of tightening up... 

 

In general, I think many farang over value their personal value to the Thai economy. 

Anti-farang attitude everywhere.  The constant attempts of trying to get money out of you in any way they could think of, Even from friends or thai wife with exaggerated bills.

 

Regarding farang value, we can go back to the basic economic law of "More people. more money spent"  Even the west is taking in millions of immigrants and refugees knowing that they will spend money even on basic goods, therefore increasing tax revenue and economic activity

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/22/2019 at 10:28 AM, Traubert said:

That's an awful lot of money between 250,000 farangs.

 

What are they eating? Gold?

 

249,999 when you take the man at Thaepae Gate out of the equation. Plus subtract todays jumpers.

2.3 trillion baht spent between 40m tourists, google it since its against the rules to post links to news.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, newnative said:

  Thailand welcomes people to come and live here and is far more welcoming than some other countries.  Now, they do want you to be able to support yourself here so they require you to either have 800,000 in the bank or an income of 65,000 a month.  Seems perfectly reasonable to me--they give you not just one but two ways to qualify.  If you have neither 800,000 or 65,000 monthly income, perhaps you should remain in your home country where, hopefully, you will be able to avail yourself of support services for the needy.

ok what about younger guys who made a killing with the internet or crypto.  They still have to mess with the BS

 

No retirement visas for them

 

Thailand can make their choices, we will see in the long run what happens and it does not seem to get better, there are many other countries.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, gamini said:

The retirement reform is to weed out retirees who are breaking the law by using agents to put up the funds required to get the necessary visa. You can't blame Thailand, just blame the dishonest farangs .

No it isn't, though you may wish it were so.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, Vacuum said:

lol. These "undesirables" just have to scrape up 20K baht for the agent, to get a one year extension. The real "undesirables" are the corrupt IOs who let them doing this.

Many guys use those agents irrespective some contributors hobbling attempts.

Edited by SheungWan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/22/2019 at 9:09 PM, baansgr said:

Most guys like this is due to the fact they lost all their money to a Thai hooker and her family.....blame the thais if anyone.

NO!  blame to stupid farangs, as the saying goes,a fool and their money soon parted 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/21/2019 at 12:23 PM, DingDongLing said:

My point of the thread is still, all these anti farang rules just lower thai economy overall. 

 

If they are criminals, they will get arrested here.

 

If they are poor and stealing fruit, they will get deported eventually (hopefully)

 

 

The last 2 things cost Thailand money. And maybe the first.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, DingDongLing said:

ok what about younger guys who made a killing with the internet or crypto.  They still have to mess with the BS

 

No retirement visas for them

 

Thailand can make their choices, we will see in the long run what happens and it does not seem to get better, there are many other countries.

 

 

      I agree there shouldn't be an age limit on the retirement visa if you can meet the financial requirements.  However, if someone younger has, as you say, 'mada a killing', then they should be able to afford the Elite Visa if they want to live in Thailand.  Yes, 'no retirement visas for them' but they do have a visa option.   If they can't afford it, maybe they really aren't financially ready to retire yet and should work a few more years--or look for a country with better visa rules for their situation.  

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, kenk24 said:

If someone is a jerk and disrespectful and calling Thai stupid as I see here so often, sure, they are going to get a different reaction from Thai... and likely they will see people being anti-farang, after they show themselves to be anti-Thai... 

So true.  Just about every Thai-bashing farang I know are unlikable sort of guys.  Complain and whine/whinge is all they ever do.  Funny how they don't realize what pr*cks they are themselves.  True karma. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, DingDongLing said:

Anti-farang attitude everywhere.  The constant attempts of trying to get money out of you in any way they could think of, Even from friends or thai wife with exaggerated bills.

And do you think it's different for Chinese or Korean guys married to Thai ladies? No it's not.

This "Anti-farang attitude" exist in your mind only, but I must agree that many Thai people have "some attitude" towards foreigners.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Geez, Gecks - where can I start, if you add words that I did not use, it becomes something else - right... where did I say Sin Sod had to be "generous" - - yet you go off on the generous aspect. I would have used the term "fair" if you asked.... but it is a Thai custom and should be observed. In my case, my wife was never married and I was pleased to give a gift to her parents... no pain or problem for me. 

19 minutes ago, Gecko123 said:

A foreigner showing up in mid-life simply can't compete with this. You might as well have landed in a flying saucer in the middle of a rice paddy.

 Yes, when you show up that is probably true - however, when you stay and participate through time, deal with emergency situations, and are there to help in any way you can, when you are reliable and caring and present, things change. 

 

when you sit on the hospital bed with a dying child, my niece, all night in rotation with many many family members, all who have dropped everything during the crisis, when you cry together through a life and death experience bonds form... and when the toddler survives and you bring the child into your house and go through all the sacrifices and ordeal of putting your all into raising that child, educating that child, as your family, things change... and people notice and though they don't fuss, they do appreciate. 

 

and through nearly 20 years, there are many examples... 

32 minutes ago, Gecko123 said:

 

14 minutes ago, Gecko123 said:

Your post contains two huge fallacies in my opinion. The first is that rural Thailand is a cultural nirvana full of genuine friendly welcoming people, proud you have selected their village to live in and eager to integrate you into their community. The second is that anyone who struggles with this assimilation process must have a social skill or psychological deficiency. That's absolute nonsense, and what's more, I think you know it

sorry, I can't see any of these implications in my post?? many do not have the luck I have had in finding a nice family. Sounds like you are projecting your situation onto me? Yes, I find many friendly people, proud and eager, again those are your words - no, I would never say that. 

 

i never said it was a cultural nirvana, nor did I make any implications about others who do not assimilate... you are accusing me of saying things that are not even hinted at... becoming part of a Thai village family is quite obviously not for everyone and easier for some than others and much, maybe most, depends upon the family. I met my wife through an introduction from a trusted friend who told me only one thing - she has a great family,... he was right. But, I never even set out to live in a village or try to assimilate into a family. It just happens. And it takes time. 

 

34 minutes ago, Gecko123 said:

Someone has a medical emergency and doesn't have the money, where are the repayment funds coming from? If they're such good credit risks, why aren't they borrowing from other family members or friends?

Well, in the most recent example of a motorcycle accident and immediate surgery and hospital stay required, the money was needed immediately, I had it readily available, and a family member working in korea had the funds but it would take a few days to arrive. I was paid back in full in 3 days... thanks for asking... but, and this is what you are missing, maybe, - - they are borrowing from me because they consider me a friend and family member... and yes, the rare time I have needed anything, they were there for me... 

 

My wife has a big family and I am in no way saying that it is "nirvana", again, your word, I did not even say I have assimilated, I just don't look at life in that term, it is more that as living together in a family compound, when someone is sick or legitimately needs help, you help, you don't stop and think how assimilated you might feel. 

 

There have been rare times where errant extended family members wanted to borrow money and my family told me not to lend it... there are occasional instances of bad behavior, but mostly, I have a great family. And I have seen other farang in my area who have really nice family situations too... and none of us ever sit around and discuss or try and measure to what % we have assimilated... 

 

And, thanks in advance for your concern... the niece who nearly died is now 14, my wife and I have raised her as a daughter and she is thriving in school... 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Gecko123 said:

'm sorry but your suggestion that paying a generous sin sod is the key to good family relations in my mind ranks as one of the most ludicrous comments I have ever read on TVF.

I never said that!! I made not even a minor reference to people paying a generous sin sod..  what I said is below... I am talking about people who reneged on paying sin sod.. we are talking about opposite things... 

 

"I have a couple of times in 20 years seen the exxagerated bills thing, but that was definitely in response to the reneging on the sin sod, and the Thai Family feeling they were cheated. The 'I don't pay no sin sod' farang, at best, pay for it in bad relations with family, though rarely do they connect the dots... "

 

and yes, though they may not voice it to the farang, I have seen instances where families have been terribly insulted because the farang did not go along with the custom.... 

 

But yes, I do agree that my experience is my own - and likely different than many others... The vast majority, I don't know about... in my area, a place where farang don't tend to settle, most seem to be doing ok in similar fashion. They moved to the area because they have wives who want to be near their family. 

 

good luck in future endeavors... 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/23/2019 at 9:35 AM, kenk24 said:

Geez, that is really over dramatic... 

 

What for most is a simple process of paying an annual fee and filling out a few forms for the privilege of being allowed to take up residence in a foreign country [of my choosing] - - a very minimal effort... 

 

for some reason makes you and others feel discriminated against and like a criminal... really? 

 

Not sure where you are from but how easy is it for a Thai person to go live there? 

 

Not sure what you might want? 

You conveniently omit 90 days reporting, now that most definitely IS like a criminal on good behavior. 

You also omit TM30.

 

I don't have any visa problems.

But since the beginning of this year I have to deal with immigration every month, for different reasons. It has not been like this for the past 20 years. I do not like it.

I am seriously contemplating to go through an agent,  which seems to be the point of the whole exercise. 

Edited by uhuh
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/22/2019 at 1:26 AM, SteveK said:

Thailand visa policies are still much easier to adhere to than countries like Canada or the UK.

 

Thailand isn't anti-farang, it's anti-poor (at least when it comes to allowing foreign visitors into the country).

 

 

You should compare Thailand to Malaysia,  indonesia,  Philippines,  not to UK or Canada.  That's Thailand's peer group.

 

If Thailand is anti-poor but not anti-farang why is it so easy for Chinese to immigrate? 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The economic impact of tourism on Thailand is 20% of GDP. That's huge. 

 

The economic impact of foreign retirees as opposed to short-term tourists is far less,  but in the villages of Isarn it is very visible and obviously quite big.

The Thai ruling classes have no interest in economic development of the Isarn poor if they cannot get a cut.  To the contrary,  the conflicts in Thailand over the last 15 years were all about keeping the poor poor so they will better serve the rich. 

Do you remember the good old times when a middle class Bangkokian could afford a live-in maid from Isarn (all condos had a windowless cubicle for her), a driver and a gardener, and a mia noi? Now they build condos without cubicles for the maid,  drivers and gardeners want real money, and the mia noi...

This is owed to Thailand's economic development (not to foreign retirees) through CP, Toyota, Sony, Marriott and so on. From this development, the rich get a cut in form of taxes, tea money, share dividends (Thaksin introduced the current economic model to Thailand with the help of Morgan Stanley and made a killing on the stock market. Ironically, at the time farang didn't like him because they, too, profited from Isarn poverty).

Thai ruling classes don't have any advantages from farang retirees in Isarn, however, just some - relatively minor, but sizable - disadvantages. So why should they keep the farang retirees here?

 

BTW other foreigners in Thailand are treated very differently because the established powers do have advantages from their presence:

Burmese, Cambodians, Laotians are cheap labor

Chinese help to integrate Thailand in the Chinese co-prosperity sphere aka Belt and Road.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, uhuh said:

I am seriously contemplating to go through an agent

good idea - - it makes my life very easy and I find the cost quite reasonable... and I definitely do not feel as though I am out on good behaviour... quite the opposite, I feel I am lucky to be permitted in, to stay in a country of my choice... I don't like filling out forms either, but when I can pay a professional to take care of it for me, that's great... life is easy... 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/22/2019 at 5:26 AM, Bang Bang said:

Case in point, million-baht Elite visa holders are VIPed through airports and have zero immigration hassles to deal with.

That's what I was expecting when I purchased mine.

 

The reality, however, is turning out to be a different story (read: TM30 nightmares.)

 

Feeling like I'm just one small step away from being fitted for an ankle bracelet.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/23/2019 at 8:40 PM, kenk24 said:

Sorry - i live near a small city, in a family oriented village... I just don't see any anti-farang attitude. I am friendly and people respond to me with friendly... there are no constant attempts to get $$ from me... there are occasional loans for health emergencies, but those get paid back.... in direct contrast to farang, who rarely pay back. 

 

I have a couple of times in 20 years seen the exxagerated bills thing, but that was definitely in response to the reneging on the sin sod, and the Thai Family feeling they were cheated. The 'I don't pay no sin sod' farang, at best, pay for it in bad relations with family, though rarely do they connect the dots... 

 

so often you get just one side here... the other factor is that life in Patpong, Patong, Pattaya and Phuket... not representative of mainland Thailand... 

 

If someone is a jerk and disrespectful and calling Thai stupid as I see here so often, sure, they are going to get a different reaction from Thai... and likely they will see people being anti-farang, after they show themselves to be anti-Thai... 

You say thais paid back loans to you?

 

Sure living in a small village and making friends is much better then the average farang. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, DingDongLing said:

You say thais paid back loans to you?

Yes, in cash and within the time periods they set... or sooner. I never had to remind or ask... they brought the $ to me when they had it... 

 

one friend who I gave 10,000 baht for an operation around year 2000, I really did it as a gift and forgot about it... he actually gave me a gift of his grandfather's ring after the operation... 

I had not seen him for a while and bumped into him about 15 years later and he said he finally had a decent job and had saved up the money to give back to me... I refused. 

 

I have had several farang who did not even have an intention of paying me back. There was simply more utility for them in drinking etc... than returning the $. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/23/2019 at 10:54 PM, Berkshire said:

So true.  Just about every Thai-bashing farang I know are unlikable sort of guys.  Complain and whine/whinge is all they ever do.  Funny how they don't realize what pr*cks they are themselves.  True karma. 

I have many thai friends., many female friends and know their families.  I blend in.  Very likeable and friendly guy.....yet I am not naive or stupid.  I see how they try to scam others and even attempt to scam me.  I do not care if its 200 baht.  But if you lie about needing food/milk when you own a food stall/spa/business and make more then me.......  come on. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.




×
×
  • Create New...