From Yellow Stars to ID Cards

[ChristineC]

From Yellow Stars to ID Cards – Then and Now

In Nazi times, Jews wore yellow stars – big, clear, cruel.
They were marked – for shame, for fear, for death.
The star meant – "You are not one of us."
It was forced – sewn on by law, backed by hate.

Now – in Israel – every citizen carries an ID.
Jew, Arab, Druze – all have them.
The card lists your name, your birth, your number.
Once – it also showed your group. That part was dropped in 2005.
Still – the system knows if you're Jewish or not.

Some say it matters – too much.
Arab Israelis – one in five – can vote, work, live.
But many say – they face less. Less funding. Less housing. Less voice.
The ID card is civil – not hateful – but it still divides.

It is not the yellow star – not even close.
That star was for death. The card is for order.
But both raise a sharp question – who belongs, and who doesn’t?

Fairness needs watching – always.
A label can start as a tool – and end as a wall.