Jump to content

Italian couple crushed to death by oil tanker in southern Thailand


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
11 minutes ago, DrTuner said:

That is correct. Assume every single Thai on the road is a complete idiot and you just might survive. On a good day.

I rather stick to driving like them and react upfront to their stupidity, go with the flow of traffic and you are most safe.

Edited by tabarin
Posted
12 minutes ago, DrTuner said:

That is correct. Assume every single Thai on the road is a complete idiot and you just might survive. On a good day.

 

The fact is that you can do all of that and still come a cropper.

 

Perhaps you missed this recent thread; 

 

Posted

Tragic. Motorcycling in Thailand is dangerous, even for the most skilled riders. RIP to the dead couple, and condolences to their families. 

  • Like 2
Posted

There is a YouTube video regarding motorcyclists. It says you have to imagine you are invisible to all other road users. As a motorcyclist, I can relate to that.

 

In this instance, bearing in mind it is Thailand, I would believe I would have seen this tanker barrelling along and judged that we would meet at the junction and pulled over to the outside lane.

  • Like 1
Posted

Some more inflammatory personal attack posts have been removed:

 

7) You will respect fellow members and post in a civil manner. No personal attacks, hateful or insulting towards other members, (flaming) Stalking of members on either the forum or via PM will not be allowed.

Posted
30 minutes ago, Too young to be old said:

There is a YouTube video regarding motorcyclists. It says you have to imagine you are invisible to all other road users. As a motorcyclist, I can relate to that.

 

In this instance, bearing in mind it is Thailand, I would believe I would have seen this tanker barrelling along and judged that we would meet at the junction and pulled over to the outside lane.

Being invisible is very true. I survived 50+ years on a bike, about half in Asia including Bangkok. I would often tell Westerners and Thai alike, if you can't drive home in Bangkok, at night, with your lights off, you should not be on a bike here. No one ever sees you, even during the day.  I was not 'gaeng', I was very lucky.

 

The truck was coming way too fast, it would take the guy on the bike at least 1 second to digest the bizarre situation, by that time it was simply too late.

Posted (edited)

I scaled the attached video to real time and it shows how extremely fast the truck was really moving. If, the driver was really 64 years old then I think the break theory is at least possible. The truck had no chance of negotiating the curve and the driver probably never noticed the bike, he was too busy trying to save himself.

 

truckthai3.mkv

Edited by rabas
  • Thanks 2
Posted

Although the tanker driver is clearly in the wrong, (too fast, ignored the stop sign, perhaps trying to turn too sharply when/if he did see the m/c at the last minute) the motorcyclist appears to have done a couple of things that probably didn't help.

From the video it looks as if he was still pulling out from the left filter lane into the middle lane to go straight on, as he "clipped" the hashed area.  Being so far left as he approached with the vegetation on the verge would have obscured his view of anything coming out of the side road.

(I accept that m/c's should stay in the far left of the left lane and he was probably safer there than being in the middle lane, but he was perhaps a little too late in moving across).  Whilst moving across to the right he may have been closely watching his mirror to check for cars coming up behind him and so noticed the tanker a fraction of a second later than he might otherwise have done.  Also, being used to driving on the other side he may have been "looking the wrong way" and not expecting a vehicle coming from the left at such a speed.

 

I'm not making any excuses for the (w)tanker.  He should be hung out to dry, but there are a couple of lessons to be learned for anyone who rides a m/c here:-

Always expect the unexpected... and always be prepared to stop.  Even a soi dog running out can be enough to cause you to lose control.

Stay as wide as possible (where it's safe to do so) when coming to a side junction, to give maximum visibility into the side road, and avoid making last minute changes of lane or direction.

Don't drive too fast especially in unfamiliar areas.  (I was trained to be able to stop completely in the distance I can see to be clear.. and that includes other vehicles, pedestrians (or dogs) suddenly appearing in front of you.)

   

It doesn't matter if you have the right of way... in the event of an accident, having the RoW will rarely save your life.   So ride defensively and avoid being in an accident.

  • Like 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, steve73 said:

Although the tanker driver is clearly in the wrong, (too fast, ignored the stop sign, perhaps trying to turn too sharply when/if he did see the m/c at the last minute) the motorcyclist appears to have done a couple of things that probably didn't help.

From the video it looks as if he was still pulling out from the left filter lane into the middle lane to go straight on, as he "clipped" the hashed area.  Being so far left as he approached with the vegetation on the verge would have obscured his view of anything coming out of the side road.

(I accept that m/c's should stay in the far left of the left lane and he was probably safer there than being in the middle lane, but he was perhaps a little too late in moving across).  Whilst moving across to the right he may have been closely watching his mirror to check for cars coming up behind him and so noticed the tanker a fraction of a second later than he might otherwise have done.  Also, being used to driving on the other side he may have been "looking the wrong way" and not expecting a vehicle coming from the left at such a speed.

 

I'm not making any excuses for the (w)tanker.  He should be hung out to dry, but there are a couple of lessons to be learned for anyone who rides a m/c here:-

Always expect the unexpected... and always be prepared to stop.  Even a soi dog running out can be enough to cause you to lose control.

Stay as wide as possible (where it's safe to do so) when coming to a side junction, to give maximum visibility into the side road, and avoid making last minute changes of lane or direction.

Don't drive too fast especially in unfamiliar areas.  (I was trained to be able to stop completely in the distance I can see to be clear.. and that includes other vehicles, pedestrians (or dogs) suddenly appearing in front of you.)

   

It doesn't matter if you have the right of way... in the event of an accident, having the RoW will rarely save your life.   So ride defensively and avoid being in an accident.

 

 

I'm sorry but your assertions are complete nonsense. Even if you were right and he moved from the left turn lane to his position on the left line of the middle lane, there was NO CHANCE that he would have seen the truck even if not filtering from the left turn lane, as it simply was not there to be seen.

 

It's funny how all these people come out of the woodwork with their hindsight tips that are of no use whatsoever.

 

Wake up! You are watching a CCTV that has been slowed down by at least a factor of 8. Watch rabas's video above yours to get an idea of how fast the truck appeared out of nowhere.

 

Even if in the outside lane the rider would have been in peril. This is not a normal incident. The rider had no chance and likely neither would you under the same circumstances.

 

Look at rabas's video and tell me again...

 

  • Thanks 1
Posted
Although the tanker driver is clearly in the wrong, (too fast, ignored the stop sign, perhaps trying to turn too sharply when/if he did see the m/c at the last minute) the motorcyclist appears to have done a couple of things that probably didn't help.
From the video it looks as if he was still pulling out from the left filter lane into the middle lane to go straight on, as he "clipped" the hashed area.  Being so far left as he approached with the vegetation on the verge would have obscured his view of anything coming out of the side road.
(I accept that m/c's should stay in the far left of the left lane and he was probably safer there than being in the middle lane, but he was perhaps a little too late in moving across).  Whilst moving across to the right he may have been closely watching his mirror to check for cars coming up behind him and so noticed the tanker a fraction of a second later than he might otherwise have done.  Also, being used to driving on the other side he may have been "looking the wrong way" and not expecting a vehicle coming from the left at such a speed.
 
I'm not making any excuses for the (w)tanker.  He should be hung out to dry, but there are a couple of lessons to be learned for anyone who rides a m/c here:-
Always expect the unexpected... and always be prepared to stop.  Even a soi dog running out can be enough to cause you to lose control.
Stay as wide as possible (where it's safe to do so) when coming to a side junction, to give maximum visibility into the side road, and avoid making last minute changes of lane or direction.
Don't drive too fast especially in unfamiliar areas.  (I was trained to be able to stop completely in the distance I can see to be clear.. and that includes other vehicles, pedestrians (or dogs) suddenly appearing in front of you.)
   
It doesn't matter if you have the right of way... in the event of an accident, having the RoW will rarely save your life.   So ride defensively and avoid being in an accident.
Too right 100% thats what I meant but your much better than me explaining, well.done.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app

Posted
8 minutes ago, KneeDeep said:

 

 

I'm sorry but your assertions are complete nonsense. Even if you were right and he moved from the left turn lane to his position on the left line of the middle lane, there was NO CHANCE that he would have seen the truck even if not filtering from the left turn lane, as it simply was not there to be seen.

 

It's funny how all these people come out of the woodwork with their hindsight tips that are of no use whatsoever.

 

Wake up! You are watching a CCTV that has been slowed down by at least a factor of 8. Watch rabas's video above yours to get an idea of how fast the truck appeared out of nowhere.

 

Even if in the outside lane the rider would have been in peril. This is not a normal incident. The rider had no chance and likely neither would you under the same circumstances.

 

Look at rabas's video and tell me again...

 

It's not clear how much the m/c could have seen before the video started.  He does appear to have reacted by moving right.. perhaps hard braking would have been better (assuming the m/c had working breaks - but many rentals do not).

If you believe that you wouldn't have stood a chance in that situation then you should give up riding immediately, as similar things occur every day (perhaps not the tanker rolling on top though).

I think I ride defensively enough to be able to avoid such an incident, although obviously I hope not to have to try.  

Posted
On 3/1/2019 at 2:26 PM, BobbyL said:

The driver said as he approached the junction the (brakes) legs didn’t work properly causing him to lose control

 

????

 

Posted
On 3/1/2019 at 2:30 PM, MaxLee said:

:guitar:

Sometimes I would like to understand what experience means for them...
 

Posted

The fact remains that the HGV driver made a huge error of judgement.

I took a HGV driving test near 50 years back, I recall the instructor telling me to treat non HGV drivers as idiots, he wasn't being derogatory, he was pointing out one must think for them too when driving a HGV...He was right when I actually got out there earning a living.. 

  • Like 1
Posted
18 hours ago, mauGR1 said:

Are you a clairvoyant or just trying to sound smart ?

Nobody can anticipate the unknown.

I did not watch the video, but it appears from the comments that the victims should not be blamed.

I agree on driving defensively, but one can't drive defensively enough on these roads.

 

 

 

I'm so sorry to confuse you.   Perhaps I should have used the word "unexpected" instead of unknown.

Does that help to clarify things for you?    I hope so.

Look in the long run it's you fellows who fail to recognize and appreciate  defensive driving  and what it entails that will run into trouble with accidents.

I'll leave it at that  with it being your problem and not mine other than that  you may be the kind of driver I need to especially watch out for.

 

Have a great day and try to drive defensively.    It's not that hard to do.

  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, watcharacters said:

 

 

 

I'm so sorry to confuse you.   Perhaps I should have used the word "unexpected" instead of unknown.

Does that help to clarify things for you?    I hope so.

Look in the long run it's you fellows who fail to recognize and appreciate  defensive driving  and what it entails that will run into trouble with accidents.

I'll leave it at that  with it being your problem and not mine other than that  you may be the kind of driver I need to especially watch out for.

 

Have a great day and try to drive defensively.    It's not that hard to do.

I don't disagree with you, and i appreciate all the advises on defensive driving.

..

What i disagree with, is blaming the tourists for not being aware about everyday troubles on Thai roads.

It takes some time to get used to ride/drive safely on these roads, and even then, as you say , you can expect the unexpected.

Some 10 years ago, i was nearly hit by a coconut falling from some 15 m. while riding in traffic on some main road, eventually someone decided to cut the tree, but it was there for years.

Posted
On 3/2/2019 at 9:57 AM, overherebc said:

I was told once by a Thai driver that he had been taught to just turn left onto the main road and drive slowly near the left to give drivers on the main road time to see him and either slow down or overtake him. ????????????????

Thai highway rules actually give vehicles entering the road from the left, either merging or from a side road, priority. Incredible as it may seem, that is in the rule book and I only found out myself by reading it. That's a large part of the reason everyone drives in the right hand lane..

Posted

 

 

                      Just to make things clear: The road that the tanker is on,

                      before coming on to 4119 is the road (4098 I think) leading to the Lomphraya

                      catamaran  terminal, to the Chumphon Shrine and to Novotel.

                      When coming from same direction as the tanker, there is a

                      big gradient that is not shown in the pictures some people already sent

                      to this thread, it level out at the soi you can see, going right in the upper

                      corner of the picture but it is very steep. Furthermore, there is a "STOP" sign

                      which you don`t see in the picture, but it`s there! It`s NOT a"yield" sign,

                      it`s a "STOP" sign!!

                      Conclusion: The tank driver did not brake, gear down, which is the way to do,

                      especially with a big truck of, maybe, half full of liquid, squashing around in the tank.

                      And most important, he don`t even thinking about to STOP, as is required in this junction!

                      I did go there today, just so I could get the facts correct, and I have been coming

                      from ALL directions in this junction before, so I know all about that one!    

  • Thanks 1
Posted
4 hours ago, katatonic said:

Thai highway rules actually give vehicles entering the road from the left, either merging or from a side road, priority. Incredible as it may seem, that is in the rule book and I only found out myself by reading it. That's a large part of the reason everyone drives in the right hand lane..

Correct. Anyone doing their license renewal having been subjected to the 1 hour animated video (and manage to stay awake) with see this rule emphasized many times.

Posted

I've been driving for the first time in Thailand this year.

 

Generally speaking, when there is congestion, I drive more cautiously than my wife.

 

And when the road is clear ahead, I'm driving @ 90-100.

 

But yeah, I pay very close attention to the big trucks, same as America.

 

Think about it, how smart do you have to be to drive a truck? ????

Posted

 

 

 

                        Bdenner!

               

              When I have renewed my driving licence, people maybe look a the

              video for no longer than (maybe) 10 minutes, then their eyes are

              glued in their new babies, meaning their phones!  Go figure!!

Posted
On 3/1/2019 at 5:14 PM, Nsp64 said:

Maybe it really was brake failure, although I doubt it.

I think the maintainable schedule on hazardous chemical vehicles is much stricter. 

SPEED !  just look  at those rear tyres, the tanker was starting to tip before it got to the intersection, he was obviously speeding.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.




×
×
  • Create New...