UdonRoy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 27 minutes ago, finy said: That doesn't make any sense. From what I could tell from Google translate they're trying to change things because the amount of people visiting immingation has shot up from 1000 to 5000. Eliminating overstay fines wouldn't fix that. Yes, you a right they did mention this. They said they were taken by surprise by how many people visited immigration and they will attempt to provide a better service by opening temporary offices if required. Something like that anyway. I am doing my best guys, please dont moan at me. This document is confusing (wow, who would of thought it) but we are trying to translate it in the way it is meant. 1
Zikomat Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 No fines for overstay. This time - straight to prison. I will not be surprised. 1
daveyboy69 Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 2 hours ago, samisaurus said: Good news starting to emerge, hopefully all is true.. fingers crossed guys! It's in their best interest to announce it all before we flood the immigration offices this coming week, 5k visitors a day lol what news
audaciousnomad Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 5 minutes ago, UdonRoy said: Yes, you a right they did mention this. They said they were taken by surprise by how many people visited immigration and they will attempt to provide a better service by opening temporary offices if required. Something like that anyway. I am doing my best guys, please dont moan at me. This document is confusing (wow, who would of thought it) but we are trying to translate it in the way it is meant. It might sound too good to be true. They could say....for those who are overstayed...the 500/day FINES will not be charged. But we will require you to apply for the usual 30-day extension, and the application FEEES of 1900 will be charged. See how the wording can be tricky? That's why lawyers get paid a lot.
Zikomat Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 1 minute ago, UdonRoy said: Yes, you a right they did mention this. They said they were taken by surprise by how many people visited immigration and they will attempt to provide a better service by opening temporary offices if required. Something like that anyway. I am doing my best guys, please dont moan at me. This document is confusing (wow, who would of thought it) but we are trying to translate it in the way it is meant. More offices for more people. This is exactly what we need now. Until they state that there is no need to visit their damned offices anymore - until then I doubt anything will really change. Just more bureaucracy, more requirements, more troubles.
daveyboy69 Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 4 minutes ago, Zikomat said: No fines for overstay. This time - straight to prison. I will not be surprised. is that true or your opinion
Zikomat Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 Also the question is not about fines. Will anybody on overstay be thrown into prison if caught by police or not? 1
Mapguy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 2 hours ago, jacob29 said: Well if only be had a crystal ball that they were going to actually make it *harder* (near impossible) to get an extension, while pretty much every other country is waiving requirements or making it easier. The next time we have a sniff of a pandemic, I suspect a great deal of people won't be coming anywhere near Thailand. Well, yes, some absurd Immigration requirements, but lots of tourists really looked both ways before "crossing the street" to Thailand and decided to play it save. You were planning on the government to save you ?! Others already here, not fearful but sensible, changed their plans. Sure, things have been changing fast, but not that fast! Until quite recently, it has been an individual's call. Lots of wishful thinking to stick around! Want to gamble? Buy a lottery ticket. Go to Las Vega when it reopens! 1
UdonRoy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 And just to reiterate, it contains very little real information other than the overstay fine being suspended from the 27th. No information on how this will be applied or criteria to qualify. All the rest is old news like needing the embassy letter. 1
Maestro Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 52 minutes ago, finy said: That doesn't make any sense. From what I could tell from Google translate they're trying to change things because the amount of people visiting immingation has shot up from 1000 to 5000. Eliminating overstay fines wouldn't fix that. Perhaps immigration is thinking about allowing foreigners to go on overstay without later collecting a fine, which would mean that they won't have to apply for the emergency extension under the Covid-19 memorandum. At the moment they are only thinking about it. We have to wait and see if this gets translated into action. 2 The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place. — George Bernard Shaw
Mapguy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 To change the popular slant of this general conversation somewhat, the TAT minister (Tourism and Sports, folks for those who are visiting) must be having absolute HYSTERICS with how the Ministry of the Interior is handling the situation! All sound like a bunch of Trump hires doing an extra gig! Oh yeah, the TAT minister is the guy who convinced the PM not to restrict OA visas very early on? Not that long ago. Yeah, maybe even a Trump reject!
samisaurus Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 1 minute ago, Maestro said: Perhaps immigration is thinking about allowing foreigners to go on overstay without later collecting a fine, which would mean that they won't have to apply for the emergency extension under the Covid-19 memorandum. At the moment they are only thinking about it. We have to wait and see if this gets translated into action. I originally thought this is what they meant, then more experienced forum members dissected what it could mean and how they'd implement it, factoring in thai mentality of how'd they do things... then i realized that im just naive and the members speak more wisdom based on experience of dealing with the government here. 1
audaciousnomad Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 2 minutes ago, Maestro said: Perhaps immigration is thinking about allowing foreigners to go on overstay without later collecting a fine, which would mean that they won't have to apply for the emergency extension under the Covid-19 memorandum. At the moment they are only thinking about it. We have to wait and see if this gets translated into action. If so, it would be similar to what other ASEAN countries (Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia) have done. And it would be a nice gesture of good will towards tourists who chose to spend their time and money to travel to Thailand. (And would like to in the future) 1
Popular Post jacob29 Posted March 29, 2020 Popular Post Posted March 29, 2020 11 minutes ago, Mapguy said: Well, yes, some absurd Immigration requirements, but lots of tourists really looked both ways before "crossing the street" to Thailand and decided to play it save. You were planning on the government to save you ?! Others already here, not fearful but sensible, changed their plans. Sure, things have been changing fast, but not that fast! Until quite recently, it has been an individual's call. Lots of wishful thinking to stick around! Want to gamble? Buy a lottery ticket. Go to Las Vega when it reopens! I don't want saving, I just want reasonable options to extend when I can't extend using traditional means. I don't even mind paying for it, and I don't think that's too much to ask when basically every other country has done so. I had a flight to Vietnam booked, but even that had me spooked, as I would rather not fly at this time. The socially responsible thing to do is stay put if you can, regardless of daft immigration requirements. Not safe to travel between provinces, but safe to travel internationally. How does that work? 5
UdonRoy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 7 minutes ago, jacob29 said: I don't want saving, I just want reasonable options to extend when I can't extend using traditional means. I don't even mind paying for it, and I don't think that's too much to ask when basically every other country has done so. I had a flight to Vietnam booked, but even that had me spooked, as I would rather not fly at this time. The socially responsible thing to do is stay put if you can, regardless of daft immigration requirements. Not safe to travel between provinces, but safe to travel internationally. How does that work? Well said that man. Stay put and deal with the consequences later. Hopefully by doing this we will be alive to deal with the consequences! 1
Mapguy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 Well, you have had choices. Your timing was off and, unfortunately, you have made an inconvenient choice. Really shouldn't expect governments to bail you out when you do have discretionary leeway. That has been my point. You have had choices Be glad for that! Most people don't. 3
Popular Post jacob29 Posted March 29, 2020 Popular Post Posted March 29, 2020 10 minutes ago, Mapguy said: Well, you have had choices. Your timing was off and, unfortunately, you have made an inconvenient choice. Really shouldn't expect governments to bail you out when you do have discretionary leeway. That has been my point. You have had choices Be glad for that! Most people don't. I don't want a bail out lol, I just want an extension! You make it sound like this is some kind of major inconvenience for immigration, one that warrants putting lives at risk. 6
Mapguy Posted March 29, 2020 Posted March 29, 2020 I NEVER said Immigration policy and procedures have been helpful or healthy! I was talking about the choices individuals have had the privilege to make themselves to avoid the complications. So, enjoy your stay as best you can! Crummy way to spend a vacation, of course.
Popular Post UdonRoy Posted March 29, 2020 Popular Post Posted March 29, 2020 We are not in North Korea so the privilege of having choices is a given Your suggestion that people could have made different choices to avoid complications is laughable. Each and every person I have communicated with had a plan that would allow them to comply with Thailands immigration laws. Enter Covid-19, now unless I was some kind of soothsayer or oracle no one could have forseen the issues that would arise in it's wake. Well laid plans that would enable compliance have been made impossible. It should be noted that compliance with immigration is the only goal. Nobody is asking to be bailed out, they simply want a system in place that allows them to at least have some legality to their stay in Thailand during a global crisis. Their only goal being to legally stay in here. People are desprate for information that will enable this and nobody is trying to play the system. People should be applauded for trying to comply in these difficult times and not have snide little remarks suggesting that any complications are self inflicted. 12 4
Popular Post Drew3223 Posted March 29, 2020 Popular Post Posted March 29, 2020 3 hours ago, UdonRoy said: We are not in North Korea so the privilege of having choices is a given Your suggestion that people could have made different choices to avoid complications is laughable. Each and every person I have communicated with had a plan that would allow them to comply with Thailands immigration laws. Enter Covid-19, now unless I was some kind of soothsayer or oracle no one could have forseen the issues that would arise in it's wake. Well laid plans that would enable compliance have been made impossible. It should be noted that compliance with immigration is the only goal. Nobody is asking to be bailed out, they simply want a system in place that allows them to at least have some legality to their stay in Thailand during a global crisis. Their only goal being to legally stay in here. People are desprate for information that will enable this and nobody is trying to play the system. People should be applauded for trying to comply in these difficult times and not have snide little remarks suggesting that any complications are self inflicted. Thank you Udonray. I have my letter from the Embassy but was told to come back another day last Friday from a ridiculously crowded Samui. I am not taking two more boat trips to Samui and not risking my health amongst so many people again. I need Thailand please to show clemency. 3 1
audaciousnomad Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 Anyone got a report of how things are going today at immi?
dayward1 Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 Just got back with a 28 day COVID extension. My Single Non-O + 60 day ext. expired today. (guardian visa) If you have the same visa as me, go to Counter N, not the usual counter L. This visa isn't attached to the Non-o. She didn't want any birth certificates, rental agreements / house address, not even the front page of my passport! I came home with a stack of papers normally needed for a Non-O ext.. She took all of the usual applications w/pictures and the letter from my US Embassy. Took 15 minutes. I got there about 4.45 and was 42nd in line, ushered in around 5.30 and given a number. Around 7.15 they started letting numbers in about 7.45. I was out by around 8.30. 1
audaciousnomad Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 57 minutes ago, dayward1 said: Just got back with a 28 day COVID extension. My Single Non-O + 60 day ext. expired today. (guardian visa) If you have the same visa as me, go to Counter N, not the usual counter L. This visa isn't attached to the Non-o. She didn't want any birth certificates, rental agreements / house address, not even the front page of my passport! I came home with a stack of papers normally needed for a Non-O ext.. She took all of the usual applications w/pictures and the letter from my US Embassy. Took 15 minutes. I got there about 4.45 and was 42nd in line, ushered in around 5.30 and given a number. Around 7.15 they started letting numbers in about 7.45. I was out by around 8.30. So you got the "Under Consideration" stamp with instructions to return on a specific date.
BangkokReady Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 5 hours ago, audaciousnomad said: Anyone got a report of how things are going today at immi? Richard Barrow is saying that the new building was closed and people were told to come back tomorrow.
uberfarang Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 Just got back from CW to extend my tourist visa (SETV) with letter from the embassy. They started by saying that the letter must be an original and color copy of email was not accepted. Then they asked for a copy of that copy (why?) and also to see a proof I was living at the address I wrote on the form (fortunately I brought my lease and a copy too). Now guess how many days I got? 30? 14? wrong, I got 11. Where does that number come from? They explained that a superior needed to review it and I have to come back on April 10 and they will let me know if I get the rest of the days... This is the same stamp as everyone else "APPLICATION OF STAY IS UNDER CONSIDERATION, APPLICANT MUST CONTACT AGAIN IN PERSON ON", and everyone seem to be given a completely different and arbitrary number of days. If this was an evaluation of how much they like us, I guess I didn't make such a good impression. 2
samisaurus Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 28 minutes ago, uberfarang said: Just got back from CW to extend my tourist visa (SETV) with letter from the embassy. They started by saying that the letter must be an original and color copy of email was not accepted. Then they asked for a copy of that copy (why?) and also to see a proof I was living at the address I wrote on the form (fortunately I brought my lease and a copy too). Now guess how many days I got? 30? 14? wrong, I got 11. Where does that number come from? They explained that a superior needed to review it and I have to come back on April 10 and they will let me know if I get the rest of the days... This is the same stamp as everyone else "APPLICATION OF STAY IS UNDER CONSIDERATION, APPLICANT MUST CONTACT AGAIN IN PERSON ON", and everyone seem to be given a completely different and arbitrary number of days. If this was an evaluation of how much they like us, I guess I didn't make such a good impression. That's insane because was at Canadian embassy today and they said if letter is approved they'll send us an email, meaning they don't give it out on the spot. That's crazy, needing original in times when travel is not recommended, and isolation is encouraged. 1
timoti Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 2 minutes ago, samisaurus said: That's insane because was at Canadian embassy today and they said if letter is approved they'll send us an email, meaning they don't give it out on the spot. That's crazy, needing original in times when travel is not recommended, and isolation is encouraged. lol why do they treat it like it's some precious scarce thing? they act like giving more letters make them look bad, so they do everything in their power not to give them. what reason did you tell them?
samisaurus Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 31 minutes ago, timoti said: lol why do they treat it like it's some precious scarce thing? they act like giving more letters make them look bad, so they do everything in their power not to give them. what reason did you tell them? Zero idea to be honest. In situations like these is when things should be streamlined. Especially by the embassy of a developed nation. 2
samisaurus Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 16 minutes ago, Vajra Kilaya said: Got the letter this morning in my email. Went to Udon immigration this afternoon. had a color photo copy that the IO spent time scrutinizing, had two photos, had copies of passport pages but they do not ask for them here, they make them and charge you 2000 baht for extension, also had a proof of residence in the form of a copy of apartment owners housebook, Thai ID,copy and signature. They specifically asked for the proof of residence. Received under-consideration stamp and the date of April 14 on the stamp. Told to come back on that date... My original extension expires on March 31. FYI Also, they start telling people to come back tomorrow at around 3pm. Good luck to all. Wow regarding the whole residence house/Thai ID card. Ridiculous...
Caldera Posted March 30, 2020 Posted March 30, 2020 As it so happens, last week I finally asked my Thai landlord to register for TM30 online reporting. He got his username and password instantly, filed a report for me and provided me with a screenshot. Looks like that might come in handy when it's my time to ask for an extension, I thought they had relaxed this at CW but apparently they ask (some?) people for proof of address.
Recommended Posts