Jump to content
Login with your Gmail HERE and start posting in seconds! ×
Don't just read! Be part of the Community! Join the conversation ×
Our Newsletter now includes a Sunday edition! Stay updated 7 days a week!

A monk's life for 30 days?

BusyB

By BusyB
in Buddhism

 Share

Recommended Posts

BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
Posted (edited)

I have just stumbled across a community called monklifeproject(dot)com. It seems to be pukka and above board but I thought I'd check back here first.

They offer a week's lay introduction and then ordination for a total 30 days, 60 if you're gripped by it. The whole process takes place at 3 different sites in the north-west.

I'm wondering if this is a good idea.

 

Is it realistic? I suppose it is, since Thais ordain for a mere week sometimes and then disrobe.

Is it trustworthy/effective? There is a fee of $500,-. Having said that the ambient and facilities seem a bit more welcoming than Suan Mokkh's austerity. Almost appealing.

 

The Wat Pananachat forest monastery offers an attractive 6 week layman's experience, and I am seriously looking at that as well, besides a second retreat at Suan Mokkh. But Wat P is set up with long term ordination as a potential  goal. The layman's period as a guest/visitor also appeals to me and would be available, but I have no plans to leave the laity permanently yet. (I think I'm too old for them at mid-60 anyway.)

 

But what do you bhikkhus think? Is a 30 day ordination for 500 bucks a worthwhile goal?

 

(By the way I came across my original Suan Mokkh post (from 2012) as I scanned the forum for any hints about monklifeproject. I realized I hadn't reported back. I'll catch up on that soon. Thanks for those who offered guidance - I could really relate to some of it in retrospect. But I am also at a completely different level of development now having found MY meditation position - unfortunately after 4 years more struggle 555.)

Edited by BusyB
Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Popular Post
khaowong1 Platinum Member

khaowong1

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted

The Monk Life Project seems like the place to go, if you have the $500.  The reason I say that is, they seem to be more involved in teaching you how to be a monk. And they do it in English with books in English. Wat Phananachat and others usually treat you like you already know and not much in the way of teaching in English.    After you've been there 30 days as a ordained monk, you can always go somewhere else.  I was 64 when I became a monk and stayed until I was almost 70.  The only reason I left was my Mothers health got bad and I left to help her out.  If you have the $500, give it a shot.  That's my opinion.  And good luck.  And keep me informed.  I will help you with what I can.  

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
kickstart Gold Member

kickstart

Posted
Posted

Remember 14th of next month is Khow Pen Sar, the start of the  Thai lent anyone who enters the monkhood then is supposed to stay they for 3 months until the end of the Thai lent .

Now ,if these retreats and forest temples follow the same lines, I would not know. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Brucenkhamen Gold Member

Brucenkhamen

Posted
Posted

On the surface it does look like they are packaging as a commodity something that is freely available elsewhere and aiming it at tourists.

 

It might be a good experience fort you but I think it would be better to do retreats as a layman at places like those you've already mention, Wat pah nanachat, or Wat Suan mokh.

 

I don't think there is much point thinking about a temporary ordination unless you've found a monastery or teacher and want to spend more time there.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
khaowong1 Platinum Member

khaowong1

Posted
Posted
On 6/25/2022 at 11:34 PM, Brucenkhamen said:

On the surface it does look like they are packaging as a commodity something that is freely available elsewhere and aiming it at tourists.

 

It might be a good experience fort you but I think it would be better to do retreats as a layman at places like those you've already mention, Wat pah nanachat, or Wat Suan mokh.

 

I don't think there is much point thinking about a temporary ordination unless you've found a monastery or teacher and want to spend more time there.

Unless you speak really good Thai and read it, Wat Suan Mohk is not the place to go.  Wat Pah Nanachat is a great place but really, really difficult to get in, and they won't ordain you until you've spent at least a year as a white clothed novice.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 6/16/2022 at 2:47 PM, Bobtheblob said:

https://www.watpahnanachat.org/

You can ordane there and stay as long as you like they don't charge. 

Indeed. It is the confluence of largish sums of money and potential effects on spirituality that I was wondering about ... Nanachat is the more 'regular' place I had in mind.

I wonder if this monkfor30 is recognized by the Thai Buddhist Council ... I'll check that out and get back.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 6/17/2022 at 1:59 AM, Zaphod said:

The Monk Life Project - embrace the path of Dhamma in Thailand:
https://thethaiger.com/sponsored/the-monk-life-project-embrace-the-path-of-dhamma-in-thailand

 

The thaiger had a youtube video to with someone from the temple.  You can search it for more info. 

Thanks very much. I've seen their videos and they are nicely done which only added to my (mild) misgivings. However the Thaiger article presents them better than they themselves ...

Indeed interesting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 6/17/2022 at 3:52 PM, khaowong1 said:

The Monk Life Project seems like the place to go, if you have the $500.  The reason I say that is, they seem to be more involved in teaching you how to be a monk. And they do it in English with books in English. Wat Phananachat and others usually treat you like you already know and not much in the way of teaching in English.    After you've been there 30 days as a ordained monk, you can always go somewhere else.  I was 64 when I became a monk and stayed until I was almost 70.  The only reason I left was my Mothers health got bad and I left to help her out.  If you have the $500, give it a shot.  That's my opinion.  And good luck.  And keep me informed.  I will help you with what I can.  

Yes I will, thanks. I'm aiming to be in LOS before September and staying till mid next year, so it's all still in the gestation phase right now.

And thanks for the Phananachat info. I don't want to have to struggle too much. Especially if it's only for 2-3 months or so. (Who knows? 555)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted
16 minutes ago, proton said:

Cult, avoid unless loaded! 

Yeah that's the Flying Saucer bunch.

 

Wikipedia: The temple has been referred to as the only influential organization in Thailand that has yet to be subdued by the ruling junta, which has shut down most opposition since it took power.

 

They seem to be regarded as heretical and corrupt by establishment media and institutions. I'm not all sure I like their approach in terms of self/non-self anyway. But the retreat on Samui could be a good way of testing the waters.

 

Otherwise there's always https://dipabhavan.weebly.com just down the road if I feel like it. That's a branch of the Buddhadasa Suan Mokkh school.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On 6/26/2022 at 6:34 AM, Brucenkhamen said:

On the surface it does look like they are packaging as a commodity something that is freely available elsewhere and aiming it at tourists.

 

It might be a good experience fort you but I think it would be better to do retreats as a layman at places like those you've already mention, Wat pah nanachat, or Wat Suan mokh.

 

I don't think there is much point thinking about a temporary ordination unless you've found a monastery or teacher and want to spend more time there.

Good points.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Thanks for all the replies guys. Much food for thought.

 

Monk4-30 gets the nod on the basis of actually ordaining and living quickly and English language teachers - the process also looks appealing.

 

Phananachat gets the nod a) for it's basic and more traditional approach and also b) because it was founded by Ajahn Chah. I know more about him and his teachings now having followed the Buddhist Society of Western Australia's Ajahn Brahm since 2020, who effectively got me through the lockdown. He was taught along with a few others by A. Chah himself.

 

Anyway, plenty of time ... see how it pans out. 

I'll let you know.

Edited by BusyB
Link to comment
Share on other sites
BusyB Gold Member

BusyB

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
On 6/27/2022 at 3:20 PM, khaowong1 said:

Unless you speak really good Thai and read it, Wat Suan Mohk is not the place to go.  Wat Pah Nanachat is a great place but really, really difficult to get in, and they won't ordain you until you've spent at least a year as a white clothed novice.  

I know, they've attached quite a few conditions to entry. And as a layman your limit is roughly 6 weeks unless you want to ordain AND they want you.

 

Suan Mokkh - Garden of Liberation rather than the actual Wat - was all English language instruction when I was there a few years ago. (Including much by a German guy whose English sense of humor and irony was stellar!)

Edited by BusyB
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bobtheblob Senior Member

Bobtheblob

Posted
Posted

https://www.watpahnanachat.org/

 

This place is indeed the real deal, I first visited around 18 years ago before they built the new temple. Was always clean and tidy even back then. 

   In the UK I frequented 2 if its sister monistary. 

https://amaravati.org/

And

https://www.cittaviveka.org/

Both excellent places if you are in the UK. 

Also 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ajahn_Sumedho

 

Has requested on his death for his remains to be housed in wat na na chat. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
khaowong1 Platinum Member

khaowong1

Posted
Posted
5 hours ago, proton said:

Cult, avoid unless loaded! 

I stayed for a month at one of their satellite temples in the South of Thailand for 30 days once.  They had a American monk running their meditation program then, can't remember his name or the name of the temple.  But it was good and not as bad as you would expect.  Yes their self/not self program was a little strange.  I'll do some digging and find out more for you. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
khaowong1 Platinum Member

khaowong1

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, khaowong1 said:

I stayed for a month at one of their satellite temples in the South of Thailand for 30 days once.  They had a American monk running their meditation program then, can't remember his name or the name of the temple.  But it was good and not as bad as you would expect.  Yes their self/not self program was a little strange.  I'll do some digging and find out more for you. 

I'll bet the monklifeproject people will know this American monk.  He was quite famous in their project. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 2 years later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.





  • Topics

  • Latest posts...

    1. 6

      Can I send the 400,000 baht to my wife's account?

      It is based on marriage. Thank you. I thought it would be easier to send the money to my wife first so it will already be in Thailand. My bank doesn't have a simple international transfer method.
      Lestat777 in Thai Visas, Residency, and Work Permits
    2. 84

      Why experts are blasting Trump for 'already breaking the law'

      snipped for brevity. As I understand trump cannot enact legislation without the support of Congress, but can use Exec Orders, not the same. Highly likely will only have two years to do so,. Then reversed when Dems get back in power. So far trump is establishing a Cabinet comprised of many sycophant's - best of luck with that...especially with the Health Care system with a nut case running it, if approved.
      simple1 in Political Soapbox
    3. 6

      Chinese loan shark gang member arrested at Bangkok airport

      police raided the single-story house, uncovering a treasure trove of evidence, including thousands of illegal loan business cards, bank records, mobile phones, helmets, and four motorcycles believed to be linked to the gang’s predatory operations. ------------------------------------------------- Looks like they seized almost everything they need to have to prove their crimes. One Stop Bust.
      black tabby12345 in Thailand News
    4. 0

      Bangkok Uncovered: Essential Tips to Avoid Scams in the Land of Smiles

      image:tawatchai07 Bangkok, the vibrant capital of Thailand, is renowned as one of the most popular tourist destinations in the world. Its captivating culture, tantalizing cuisine, and lively nightlife draw millions of visitors each year. However, alongside its many attractions, the city is also known for a variety of scams that can catch unprepared travelers off guard. This guide delves into common scams in Bangkok while offering essential tips for avoiding them. Common Transportation Scams Transportation is a vital aspect of exploring Bangkok, but it can also be fraught with scams. Being informed about potential pitfalls can help travelers navigate the city more effectively. Airport Taxi Scam Upon arrival at Suvarnabhumi Airport, tourists may find themselves approached by unofficial taxi drivers who offer inflated flat rates for transporting them into the city. These drivers often target tourists arriving at the airport, leading to overcharges that can be avoided. The best practice is to proceed to the regulated taxi stand located on Level 1, where metered taxis are readily available. A typical fare to the city center costs around 150 Baht, plus a 50 Baht airport surcharge. No Meter Taxi Scam Although taxis are required by law to use meters, some drivers may refuse this law, insisting on a set price that is often much higher than the actual fare. To avoid this scam, it is advisable to hail a taxi that is driving by rather than one waiting curbside in tourist-heavy areas. Passengers should insist that the driver turns on the meter by politely saying "meter krub." If the driver refuses, it is best to exit the taxi and find another. Scenic Route Scam Another tactic employed by some taxi drivers is the scenic route scam, where the driver takes a longer, unnecessary route to increase the fare. To avoid this unpleasant situation, using a navigation app such as Google Maps can help passengers track their journey. By checking the route taken by the driver, passengers can easily recognize if they are not headed in the correct direction—allowing them to request correction or to stop and exit the vehicle. Wrong Change Scam This scam typically unfolds during payment. Taxi drivers may claim they do not have change for larger bills, creating confusion and opportunities for deceit. To minimize risks, carrying smaller denominations of Baht is highly recommended. Additionally, any unusual requests from drivers should raise red flags regarding the possibility of a scam. Scams Related to Sightseeing and Attractions Exploring Bangkok's attractions can be a highlight of any visit, but being mindful of potential scams is crucial. Friendly Stranger Scam Scammers often approach tourists with seemingly genuine friendliness, attempting to engage in conversation. Once rapport is built, their goal is to direct the tourists towards purchasing overpriced items or unwarranted services. Remaining cautious and skeptical when approached by strangers in tourist-heavy locations is advisable. Closed Attraction Scam Another common scam involves individuals close to popular attractions, such as the Grand Palace, falsely claiming that the site is closed due to special events. They then offer alternative tours that often lead to destinations whee additional scams are orchestrated. It is wise to independently verify the operating status of major attractions. Bird Seed Scam In high-traffic areas, people may offer free birdseed to tourists, encouraging them to feed birds and create a connection. Afterward, the "generous" offer turns into a request for payment, highlighting the deceptive nature of such interactions. Remembering that almost nothing is free in a tourist-centric environment can prevent unwelcome surprises. Tailor Scams While Bangkok boasts several reputable tailors, many scams exist as well. Tailors may lure customers with deals, but often utilize sub-par materials or quality control. Researching established tailors through online reviews before committing to a purchase can help avoid falling victim to a tailor scam. Accommodation and Tour Scams Finding suitable accommodation and booking tours are essential components of traveling, and visitors should be alert to potential scams in these sectors. Accommodation Fraud With countless hotels and rental properties, not all offer honest portrayals of their offerings. Many hotels display outdated photos that do not accurately depict the current state of the property, leading to disappointment upon arrival. Reading recent reviews on Google, as opposed to solely relying on popular booking websites, can aid in selecting trustworthy accommodations. Tour Scams Travelers should exercise caution when booking tours, especially with companies that have unclear pricing structures. Some tour operators may not include all necessary fees upfront, resulting in unexpected expenses during the trip. It is advisable to ask detailed questions about what is covered in the tour price and check reviews of the company beforehand. Nightlife Scams Bangkok’s nightlife is thrilling, but with excitement comes potential scams that can lead to significantly inflated bills if not carefully navigated. Padded Bill Scam This scam is particularly prevalent in nightlife spots. Bars and restaurants may add extra charges for items that were never ordered, leading to shocking bills at the end of the night. Paying for each drink upon receiving them can help to avoid such surprises. Pingpong Show Scam Some bars promote "free" shows, only to present exorbitant bills on departure. Visitors should exercise caution and explore reputable venues by researching online beforehand.Check reviews nd comments and experiences by other travelers. Fake Alcohol Scam Visitors should be aware that drinks purchased from dubious establishments, particularly near tourist hotspots, may be of poor quality or counterfeit or watered down. Staying informed about the sources of beverages helps minimize the risk of unpleasant experiences. General Safety Measures While exploring Bangkok, adopting prudent safety measures can significantly enhance the experience. 1. **Stay Alert**: Maintain awareness of surroundings and closely monitor belongings to avoid pickpocketing attempts or thefts. 2. **Avoid Confrontations**: If approached with a potential scam, maintaining a calm demeanor and politely exiting the situation is often a better route than escalating the matter. 3. **Use Trusted Apps**: Ride-hailing applications like Grab and Bolt offer transparency in pricing, reducing the risk of overcharging. Familiarizing oneself with these platforms can promote safer transportation options. 4. **Report Scams**: In the event of falling victim to a significant scam, contacting the English-speaking tourist police by dialing 1155 can provide assistance, as they frequently deal with such issues. Bangkok is a city filled with culture, excitement, and endless opportunities for adventure. However, awareness of potential scams is crucial for a rewarding and safe visit. By staying informed about common scams, utilizing smart strategies, and maintaining a cautious attitude, visitors can enjoy everything Bangkok has to offer while minimizing the risks associated with dishonest practices. With the right preparation, a memorable and authentically enjoyable experience awaits in this dynamic country often referred to as the £The Land of Smiles" - DONT leave your common sense in the departure lounge!
      CharlieH in Bangkok
    5. 104

      Pete Hegseth-Sec Def Nominee

      For Trump that was in the past. For Musk does he currently hold a government security clearance? If he does then it could be an issue.
      sqwakvfr in Political Soapbox
    6. 81

      Misogynistic Attacks Against Women Surge on Social Media Following Trump’s Election Win

      I already did. Shaved off their blue hair for a buzz cut and adopted celibacy instead of sleeping around and subsequently having abortions. They also appeared to still be ardent users of Musk's free speech platform X. Great to see them turn their lives around. Incel? 😅 Pretty difficult to be involuntarily celibate in Thailand. You of all people should know that living in Pattaya 😆.
      JonnyF in World News
    7. 104

      Pete Hegseth-Sec Def Nominee

      He is totally qualified. Your opinion was formed before you even heard the name.
      pedro01 in Political Soapbox
    8. 115

      The major backers of "populist" trump

      A whole knew generation of Trump apologists, who is fed the winning recipee of gold myrra and smoke. Just discovered btc is one of the ingredients How many people own Bitcoin in the USA? Key Findings Cryptocurrency awareness and ownership rates have increased to record levels: 40% of American adults now own crypto, up from 30% in 2023. This could be as many as 93 million people. Among current crypto owners, around 63% hope to obtain more cryptocurrency over the next year.26. sep. 2024 https://www.security.org/digital-security/cryptocurrency-annual-consumer-report/
      Hummin in Political Soapbox

  • Popular in The Pub


ASEANNOW

ASEANNOW (formally ThaiVisa) is Thailand's oldest and most popular expat and foriegner forum. Sign up today and have your say!

MORE INFO

POPULAR AREAS

CONTACT US

219/59 Asoke Towers, 15th Floor, Soi Sukhumvit 21, Watthana, Bangkok 10110
(+66) 99 196 1100
[email protected]

×
×
  • Create New...