Jump to content

Police Say Taiwanese Actor Might Have Been Held Up For Possession of E-Cigarettes


webfact

Recommended Posts

4 hours ago, Crossy said:

Police Say Taiwanese Actor Might Have Been Held Up For Possession of E-Cigarettes

 

Surely the written report from the checkpoint would detail all charges, fines etc. and the confiscated vapes would be in evidence?

 

Oops, sorry, I forgot where we are and who we are dealing with :whistling:

Exactly, "might" can go both ways, also the rest of the article really said nothing.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, webfact said:

The Metropolitan Police chief said the head of Huai Khwang police station, responsible for the checkpoint, has been told to look into the matter. CCTV camera footage from January 3 to 5 will be inspected. The taxi driver will also be asked to come in to provide his account. Witness testimonies will also be collected from the hotel where the tourists were staying.

Conclusion: “We investigated ourselves, and we found we were innocent of all charges.” 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, roquefort said:

You are either exceedingly naive or trolling.

Or maybe I think that whole "WoKE pOliCE" stuff is just laughable nonsense made up by grifters to make old people scared of stuff. And I hope the actor sorts everything out... damn, I must be a wokeist or something ????

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, klauskunkel said:

A litmus test for Thailand's authorities

Without knowing any facts, who would you rather believe:

a visitor you don't know from a foreign country,

or this uniformed person

image.jpeg

At this point, I would go for "neither". We all know how it works here - you do something that is wrong according to the law, you can pay your way out.

 

I'm not defending it - but I find it hard to believe a bribe was paid without the threat of a stronger punishment. After all, what will the police do - keep her there forever if she doesn't pay? That's not how it works here. 

 

The ecig explanation does make a lot of sense, certainly much more than her version of doing nothing against the law but still needing to pay her way out. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its an interesting one as it was an official police check point.

 

There seemed to be more stop and searches as part of a crack down on meth amphetamines, if you are caught carrying you will likely be the one offering a small bribe.

  

Not heard of anyone yet getting fined for carrying weed though smoking in public opens you to a hustle.

 

Vapes are a grey, area walk 50 yards on sukhumvit and you could pick up 50 people for possession.  They don't though but tourists with big pockets are fair game it seems.

 

Local expats if opted to go to court would likely just get a few hundred baht fine and a warning but as someone else mentioned its the risk and time factor that it is actually easier to pay a small gift on the spot, if they had fixed on the spot 500 baht fines this would remove the hustle potential. They know tourists will not take the court risks so have been targeted in the past.

 

This one seemed to be a combination of no ID and a vape, the amount may have been far too much but I suspect many people would much prefer to pay a small fine and go on their way.

 

The publicity could go both ways, might reduce the hustle but could also reduce that small no hassle opportunity of on the spot payments. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, richard_smith237 said:

 

- Why were they stopped and asked for ID in the first place?

- What purpose does it serve for the safety of anyone that a taxi of tourists is stopped and they are searched ?

 

This was a shakedown from start to finish...

- The Police clearly hoping at first that they did not have their passports with with them, as most tourists wouldn’t... and then they could give an ‘on the spot fine’ but they had passports. 

- The Police accused them of having false stamps... attempted extortion. 

- The Police found e-cigs... crime of the century !!!...   a winning opportunity to extort the tourists. 

 

But as crossy wrote, IF the  BiB found something illegal, where is the official receipt for the fine, where is the report? where are the confiscated illegal items ??? (rhetorical - we know the answer).

Her (drunk and argumentative) story has been refuted by the taxi driver involved.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

These cops sure do have a lot of different versions of what happened....it's not rocket science...just tell the truth...why did you stop her, why was she detained, how much was her "fine" and what was it for, where is the receipt for said payment, is it on camera,  etc etc...basic police report 101 that barney fife could handle...

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

4 hours ago, bamnutsak said:

"held up". Classic.

 

Interesting how the police version of events has evolved over time, starting with "this didn't happen" through "it may have happened" to "Visa problem", to "fine for illegal vaporizer".

 

It's like dealing with pre-teen children that have been caught being naughty.

 

Really.

Edited by Mr Meeseeks
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, pomchop said:

These cops sure do have a lot of different versions of what happened....it's not rocket science...just tell the truth...

Telling the truth is antithetical to what their culture demands unfortunately. 

 

Lie, obfuscate, lie some more, feign ignorance...

 

Anything but man up and take responsibility.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, pomchop said:

These cops sure do have a lot of different versions of what happened....it's not rocket science...just tell the truth...why did you stop her, why was she detained, how much was her "fine" and what was it for, where is the receipt for said payment, is it on camera,  etc etc...basic police report 101 that barney fife could handle...

This is also normal here. The full truth won't come out from that side as it would implicate them. Instead there will be lots of versions of the story come out and you can pick which one to believe, although I still prefer "none of the above".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, richard_smith237 said:

One who has no reason whatsoever to make up a story that she was extorted by Thai place of 27,000 baht ????.....  :whistling:

 

You really believe the police over her story ?.... You really believe they have the ‘actual’ taxi driver ?... you really believe the taxi drive would tell anything other than what the police have told him to tell ????

 

Hmm......   I know you like to live in the black and white world of facts and what can be proven or disproven or printed in an article, but even you are pushing the boundaries of absurdity if you believe the police were acting in an honest, respectful and legal manner.......   why weren’t the tourists permitted to film? 

 

 

 

 

What we do know - police bribes are your classic carrot and stick scenario here. 

 

The stick - going to court for a committing a silly crime.

 

The carrot - making it all go away with a payment.

 

Admittedly, that's not much of a carrot. But without the stick, the police don't have leverage.

 

Same with traffic police. In that case, stick number 1 is a trip with them to the police station to "sort things out" - you get a chance to pay a bribe and not go to the police station. If you DO go to the police station, you are offered the chance to pay a higher bribe because you've inconvenienced them. The stick used then is the sentence for the crimes (no matter how silly) you committed. 

 

At a guess, I'd say she refused to pay a bribe on the spot because the police don't want to go to the police station - it takes their time away from bribing others. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, richard_smith237 said:

‘Says cabbie’.....    its not in his interest to suggest anything else !!...

 

I’ve seen foreigners involved in accidents and Taxi drivers (and other Thai’s) tell out right lies to protect another Thai or their interests. 

 

Because a taxi drivers statement has made it into print does not provide any authenticity to the taxi drivers statement.

 

 

That said: I very much believe the group did argue with the police 

When the police stop you, tell you to get out of a taxi for no reason, plenty of people would argue, I would. 

When the Police stop you, tell you t get out of a taxi and try you search you, plenty of people would argue, I would. 

When the Police take your passport and tell your arrival stamp is fake, plenty of people would argue, I would. 

When (if) the police found an item you see people using all day up and down all the streets of Thailand and tell you its illegal, you’d argue. 

When the the police want to extort you for money and pay and excessive fine for said item, you’d of course argue.

 

Of course the people argued with the Police - they were being extorted... Who wouldn’t argue in this situation ????????

Getting stopped.searched is inevitable if you go out late in Bangkok and take a taxi back. It's not all roads - but roads like Petchaburi often have checkpoints where they check EVERY car looking for drunks/drugs. 

 

Their first assessment of you is when they first talk to you in the taxi. They are watching your demeanour, they are looking at your pupils, they know what people on drugs look/sound like. If you are drunk, you will probably get searched. 

 

The absolute best thing to do is to simply comply with a smile on your face, be friendly with the cops, crack a joke or two. Arguing with them will simply be taken as a sign you have something to hide. You cannot prevent a streetside search by arguing with them, it simply escalates the situation.

 

Arguing is simply feeding your ego and pitting your ego against that of the cop. You need to park your ego in these situations. 

Edited by pedro01
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, pedro01 said:

What we do know - police bribes are your classic carrot and stick scenario here. 

 

The stick - going to court for a committing a silly crime.

 

The carrot - making it all go away with a payment.

 

Admittedly, that's not much of a carrot. But without the stick, the police don't have leverage.

Why do the police need leverage ???? I can think of only one reason...  to take money.

 

 

4 minutes ago, pedro01 said:

 

Same with traffic police. In that case, stick number 1 is a trip with them to the police station to "sort things out" - you get a chance to pay a bribe and not go to the police station. If you DO go to the police station, you are offered the chance to pay a higher bribe because you've inconvenienced them. The stick used then is the sentence for the crimes (no matter how silly) you committed. 

Take the details and give the ticket - just like it is in any other country.

 

I was stopped at a traffic lights for speeding (further back along the road) ....  the BiB couldn’t tell me the speed, but said a police officer further back had caught me on camera - I asked them to prove it, they couldn’t even tell me how fast I was going.... I told them to write me a ticket...  they didn’t and waved me on...  they were just trying it on and realised I was going to be too awkward. 

 

Thailand does have ‘roadside check points’ where ticketed payments can be made, legally. Thats fine, if a law has been broken, no licence, no helmet etc... 

 

However, your description above polishes the ’turd’ of corruption, the knock on effect is the news we see here. 

 

4 minutes ago, pedro01 said:

At a guess, I'd say she refused to pay a bribe on the spot because the police don't want to go to the police station - it takes their time away from bribing others. 

I'd suggest she definitely refused to pay the bribe - they ended up with 27,000 baht, so I wonder what they started at. 

 

And of course the Police didn’t want this to go to the police station... as soon as its logged officially, something like this is a slap on the wrist and negligible 500 baht fine at most.... The Police at the scene stand to pocket far more money if they embellish and extort... 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If cops are stopping cars to check for Criminal Vapers, they might also go to all the street stalls in Bangkok selling e-cig equipment. Surely they'd meet their quota of catching Criminal Vapers that way.

 

I never understood the random stopping of taxis. It isn't as if they test the driver for booze. It's always the passengers who are checked. I've been stopped many times riding in a taxi at night. I have to get out produce my passport and empty my pockets. I haven't been shaken down for money in BKK, but the whole thing just seems odd.

 

I've been stopped at a massive checkpoint on the highway before, where cops just went up to every vehicle and said simply "Two hundred baht". That was a shake down, a kind of dunamic toll booth for the Police Welfare Fund.

 

One time my taxi was stopped riding between Maesai and Chiangrai, a cop came and sat next to me in the back seat, put his face right into mine, and told me he was going to go through all my possessions. I told him to have at it and stared back at him. He smiled, and then climbed back out. I sort of understand that check, given the region of the country, but the other random stops are just odd.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Walker88 said:

If cops are stopping cars to check for Criminal Vapers, they might also go to all the street stalls in Bangkok selling e-cig equipment. Surely they'd meet their quota of catching Criminal Vapers that way.

 

I never understood the random stopping of taxis. It isn't as if they test the driver for booze. It's always the passengers who are checked. I've been stopped many times riding in a taxi at night. I have to get out produce my passport and empty my pockets. I haven't been shaken down for money in BKK, but the whole thing just seems odd.

 

I've been stopped at a massive checkpoint on the highway before, where cops just went up to every vehicle and said simply "Two hundred baht". That was a shake down, a kind of dunamic toll booth for the Police Welfare Fund.

 

One time my taxi was stopped riding between Maesai and Chiangrai, a cop came and sat next to me in the back seat, put his face right into mine, and told me he was going to go through all my possessions. I told him to have at it and stared back at him. He smiled, and then climbed back out. I sort of understand that check, given the region of the country, but the other random stops are just odd.

My experience with checkpoints in the evening is that they stop every car. 

 

Private vehicles yield drunk driving bribes, taxi's yield possession bribes. If the bribes weren't there, they would have stopped wasting time stopping taxis years ago. I think that is the "why" to these checkpoints.

 

I remember years ago scoring a .77 when the limit was .80. The police went mental - they were jumping up and down, laughing their heads off, patting me on the back saying "lucky man, lucky man" and asking me dumb questions like what lottery number I fancied. It was one of my most bizarre experiences in Thailand. I can tell you, I had a sweat on watching those numbers go up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.




×
×
  • Create New...