Is It Possible To Find Out Why My Topic Was Closed

[chownah]

I started this topic http://www.thaivisa.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=47215 and after 6 posts it was closed. The subject was use of smileys and I was surprised that it would be so controversial that it would be closed. I sent pm's to everyone who posted explaining that I was surprised at its controversy and could they please explain what the controversy was about since I really was at a loss as to why it was closed. I got replies from all but one of the posters and they all said that the topic was no problem and most said that they thought it would be a fun topic. One of the pm's was to Dr. pat pong who was the only moderator on the thread and the last to post so I assumed that he had closed the topic. His response was that he saw no problem with the topic and had done nothing to hinder it. Upon receiving this response I replied to him that I was surprised that he had not closed it and then he replied to me and said he would check it out. I waited a few days and since I heard nothing from him I sent him another reply and he said that he did not close it and had found nothing. I'm not wanting to make a federal case out of this but I'm really wondering why my topic was closed. Is it possible to find out.... I just got suspended for 5 days last week for a post which I thought did not warrant a suspension...perhaps a warning since I've never had a warning and I had made similar posts in the same thread without a problem or warning....then Limbo starts to get on my case in the Chiangrai thread for what I consider to be a flimsy reason and I'm starting to think that there is something going on here that I should know about.......so.....what's up with my topic being closed when no one willing to respond to my inquiries says that they see it as a problem.....please.

[solo siam]

Well its a bit of a nothing topic TBH, just a load of spam - They probably didnt want the web space taken up with it.

I'm just guessing the gist of it as I didn't actually read your whole post because the paragraph was just way too long

Edited October 13, 2005 by Ben@H3-Digital

[cdnvic]

I don't know exactly why it was closed but I'd have to say it was because the topic was really about nothing, and going nowhere fast.

cv

[Judge]

Boring topics are vorbotten?

I, for one, found it slightly amusing.

[dr_Pat_Pong]

I never found out who dumped it. It certainly was a trite offering and bound to go nowhere.

[Kringle]

I just looked at it and to me it reaked of either a GS or Tm type of thread and didn't really seem to have a path much likely a road you could go on about. Just my 2 baht though.

[Jim 50]

I started this topic http://www.thaivisa.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=47215 and after 6 posts it was closed.  The subject was use of smileys and I was surprised that it would be so controversial that it would be closed.  I sent pm's to everyone who posted explaining that I was surprised at its controversy and could they please explain what the controversy was about since I really was at a loss as to why it was closed.  I got replies from all but one of the posters and they all said that the topic was no problem and most said that they thought it would be a fun topic.  One of the pm's was to Dr. pat pong who was the only moderator on the thread and the last to post so I assumed that he had closed the topic.  His response was that he saw no problem with the topic and had done nothing to hinder it.  Upon receiving this response I replied to him that I was surprised that he had not closed it and then he replied to me and said he would check it out.  I waited a few days and since I heard nothing from him I sent him another reply and he said that he did not close it and had found nothing.  I'm not wanting to make a federal case out of this but I'm really wondering why my topic was closed.  Is it possible to find out....  I just got suspended for 5 days last week for a post which I thought did not warrant a suspension...perhaps a warning since I've never had a warning and I had made similar posts in the same thread without a problem or warning....then Limbo starts to get on my case in the Chiangrai thread for what I consider to be a flimsy reason and I'm starting to think that there is something going on here that I should know about.......so.....what's up with my topic being closed when no one willing to respond to my inquiries says that they see it as a problem.....please.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Can't worry about what happens on TV, just cyber dude, not reality. Cyber cops, cyber big shots, cyber wack off artists.

Chook Gai Dee

[Judge]

I just looked at it and to me it reaked of either a GS or Tm type of thread and didn't really seem to have a path much likely a road you could go on about. Just my 2 baht though.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Just out of interest, what is a "Gs or Tm type of thread"?

If threads are closed for not being interesting, would it be possible to develop an emoicon that says: "CLOSED FOR BEING UTTERLY BORING" to embarrass the offending member into having better taste?

They wouldn't have to inquire about why their post was closed either.

[dr_Pat_Pong]

The OP thinks it was a post of great merit

[meadish_sweetball]

How about this thread. It isnt all that great either?

[Pattaya_Fox]

How about this thread. It isnt all that great either?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Same OP got anything to do with it?

[Judge]

How about this thread. It isnt all that great either?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Same OP got anything to do with it?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Mr. chownah brought up a legitimate question and is doing a great job of ignoring this thread that has turned so vicious, nasty and cruel.

I commend his vast self-control and inner discipline.

[kayo]

I just looked at it and to me it reaked of either a GS or Tm type of thread and didn't really seem to have a path much likely a road you could go on about. Just my 2 baht though.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yeah but TGS & TM don´t get their threads closed so quickly though..

Above sentence only inserted because the following would otherwise put me in the negative...

[Jockstar]

Whats wrong with TGS post? I like them. Buit then again i may be biased as i know him.

[kayo]

yeah, actually... To even put TGS and TM in the same sentence is pushing it, now I look back... Sorry TGS, er - Lads..