Australia: Former Home Affairs Secretary Criticizes Government’s Decision on Gazan Visas

[Social Media]

 

Former home affairs secretary Mike Pezzullo has argued that the Albanese government should have taken a more cautious approach before approving nearly 3,000 visas for Palestinians fleeing Gaza in the wake of the October 7 attacks. Pezzullo suggested that the government should have "paused" the process to more carefully assess the character of applicants and the potential risks involved.  

 

The Australian government extended refuge to Gazans after Hamas’ attack on Israel in 2023, despite growing concerns from some quarters that elements of the conflict could be imported into Australia. The increase in antisemitic incidents, including shocking attacks on the Jewish community, has intensified scrutiny of the decision, with critics questioning whether enough was done to ensure national security.  

 

Speaking with Sky News' Sharri Markson on Monday, Pezzullo weighed in on the matter, saying that he would have taken a different approach. "There is an issue here of judgements about character, last year there was a debate about whether there'd been an ASIO screening," he said. "From an abundance of caution, I probably would have paused any consideration, even from a character point of view." He explained that the Migration Act allows for ministerial discretion in assessing character and that he would have applied this authority to temporarily halt visa approvals.  

 

When pressed by Markson on whether he would have actively paused the process, Pezzullo confirmed: "Yes, I would." He elaborated that he would have sought extensive consultations with Australia’s intelligence allies, including Five Eyes partners and Israeli authorities. "I would have taken a step back, consulted with Five Eyes partners, consulted with the Israelis," he said. "Of course, there are checks done—you can't cross into Egypt, for instance, without going through an Israeli checkpoint. That would have helped."  

 

Pezzullo argued that gathering intelligence from international allies and putting a temporary freeze on visas would have been a more prudent approach. "I would have just, until the situation became clearer and after extensive consultation with Five Eyes, European, Israeli and other colleagues, I would have taken an extra cautious view of those visas on character grounds and not just simply the more narrow lens that the director general of security has to, by law, apply in a very restricted fashion."  

 

His comments come amid a rise in antisemitic incidents across Australia, including a suspected terror plot involving a caravan filled with explosives and a note listing Jewish targets in New South Wales. Over the weekend, antisemitic attacks were reported in Sydney, with a group of women having eggs thrown at them at Bondi Beach and offensive graffiti being spray-painted on multiple properties and vehicles in Kingsford and Randwick.  

 

 

Expressing concern over the safety of the Jewish community, Pezzullo acknowledged the growing fears among Australian Jews. "I can't imagine what it would be like living as a Jewish Australian person in Sydney, Melbourne or indeed anywhere else," he said. "You certainly would feel that apprehension of an expected attack. So I don't want to take anything away from that visceral feeling that regrettably some members of our community have and they shouldn't have. They should feel safe."

 

Based on a report by Sky News 2025-02-05