Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Thailand News and Discussion Forum | ASEANNOW

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

BILD reveal Gaza hunger photos staged by Hamas/Turkish media

Featured Replies

  • Popular Post

Photos of hunger and despair from Gaza were staged in collaboration with Hamas, German newspaper reveals

Süddeutsche Zeitung revealed photos of Gazans holding empty pots posing in front of photographers, and not in line for food aid;  Bild noted that one of the photographers was employed by a Turkish news agency, and posts anti-Israel content on social media; While the paper acknowledges that hunger exists in Gaza, expert warns of photo manipulations: 'They are intended to replace the cruel photos from Oct. 7'

 

 

https://www.ynetnews.com/article/skvxuqxdxl

 

 

 

  • Replies 50
  • Views 2.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Never mind the photos, the famine is real. Unless you want to ignore all aid agencies. Even trump has admitted the famine is real.

  • Chomper Higgot
    Chomper Higgot

    As an occupying military power it is a duty on Israel to ensure sufficient food, water, medicines and medical facilities for the civilian population under occupation.    

  • Are you joking? They are in the process of annexation, full takeover and extermination of the people.

Posted Images

  • Popular Post

Several Web sites have exposés of manipulated photos from Gaza:

 

recent:

https://www.camera.org/article/when-journalists-become-the-story/

https://david-collier.com/

 

 

older articles:

https://www.dw.com/en/fact-check-ai-fakes-in-israels-war-against-hamas/a-67367744

https://www.dw.com/en/fact-check-ai-generated-images-of-children-in-gaza/a-68146699

 

 

A separate thread on AN also deals with misleading Hamas photos:

 

8 hours ago, Evil Penevil said:

Palestinian freelance photographer munching a sandwich in Gaza on his way to photograph starving children:

 

Screenshot2025-08-06002647.jpg.c8147a9e4e7a46548137ea617e49abec.jpg

 

https://www.camera.org/article/when-journalists-become-the-story/

 

He and his buddy look well-fed and healthy, even if no one else in Gaza is.

 

On 8/3/2025 at 9:27 AM, Evil Penevil said:

 

Here are the details:

The New York Times included on July 29, 2025, the following paragraph at the end of a story ("Gazans Are Dying of Starvation") originally published July 24, 2025:

 

"Editors’ Note:   July 29, 2025  This article has been updated to include information about Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq, a child in Gaza suffering from severe malnutrition. After publication of the article, The Times  learned from his doctor that Mohammed also had pre-existing health problems. "  https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/24/world/middleeast/gaza-starvation.html

 

That's a pretty wimpy correction.  The crucial point is the child in the photo had had trouble swallowing food since birth.  That's very tragic and his health condition has certainly been aggravated by supply shortages caused by Hamas' attack on Israel and refusal to cease hostilities, but it doesn't indicate there is famine or starvation in Gaza.

 

The NYT and a number of news outlets had used a photo or photos similar to the one in the OP of this thread.  What the photos have in common is the prominence of the child's backbone to emphasize thinness.  In the pic below a garbage bag is used as a makeshift diaper,  putting more attention on the child's wretched situation.

 

child.jpg.ccfd808a237f76d83e7b8cf3db326d5c.jpg

 

childaa.jpg.4bae5470298aca582b3e379c3067d9e9.jpg

 

The NYT didn't run the info about his underlying health condition in the original story, nor did they publish the following photo that includes the boy's three-year-old brother who doesn't appear to be suffering from starvation.

 

Joud.jpeg.6356650bd1e896458419690693965320.jpeg

 

You can read  the entire expose in detail on the site of independent journalist David Collier.

The Truth Behind the Viral Gazan Famine Photo

This isn’t the face of famine. It’s the face of a medically vulnerable child whose suffering was hijacked and weaponised – first by Hamas, then by global media.   

https://david-collier.com/the-truth-behind-the-viral-gaza-famine-photo/

 

I'll follow up with information about another misleading photo of a malnourished child in Gaza.

 

 

 

 

On 8/4/2025 at 9:07 AM, Evil Penevil said:

The  pics of emaciated children in Gaza are not AI-generated fakes.  The pics that have been circulated by mainstream Western media and reposted thousands of times on social media are real,  BUT- and it's a big  butta.jpg.e8f876d43b6fa2156c94cd5b3783bb94.jpg - these photos are often misleading.  They show medically vulnerable children who have underlying conditions that result in emaciation.  The pics themselves aren't proof of mass starvation in Gaza.

 

The photo that tops the OP in this thread comes from an article in The Guardian published on Aug. 2.

 

Guardian.jpg.e076421f802a20bd4a25bd365ad2e06b.jpg

 

The caption credits Mahmoud Issa and Reuters, but doesn't give specific information about the woman and child portrayed. nor are they mentioned in the body of article.  The pic is there to illustrate The Guardian's claim Gazans are starving.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/02/gaza-famine-starvation-crisis-israel

 

I went to the Reuters' Web site and found the series of photos from which The Guardian pic had come.

 

pic.jpg.9038578547a2d94f5c2c7e98dc96b31a.jpg

 

The caption of the Reuters'  photo has a lot more info. It names the two people, says the boy suffers from cerebral palsy and says the photo was taken July 24.  There's no text story with the photo.  Reuters is a news agency and offers photos separate from its text articles.  Media outlets that don't have photographers of their own will often use a news agency photo.

https://www.reutersconnect.com/item/displaced-palestinian-mother-samah-matar-holds-her-malnourished-son-youssef-in-gaza-city/dGFnOnJldXRlcnMuY29tLDIwMjU6bmV3c21sX1JDMlpTRkE0TDgzUQ

 

The boy's emaciated appearance is mainly down to his cerebral palsy.  Children with cerebral palsy often have trouble swallowing.  The boy needs nutritional supplements and a feeding tube, neither of which is likely to be available in Gaza.  The shortage of supplies caused by the conflict has certainly aggravated the boy's fragile condition, but it doesn't prove their is mass starvation in Gaza.

 

Now to the really interesting part.  Reuters main competitor in the news agency business is the Associated Press of the U.S.  On July 26, two days after the Reuters pic went up, the AP displayed the following photo on its Web site:

 

AP.jpg.f7651a4dc86ae13791ac1be630d3a563.jpg

 

https://apnews.com/photo-essay/gaza-palestinians-israel-starvation-famine-children-fac87ecccdbe1bcdf0d3067b74f14411

 

The sidebar to the AP photo reads: "Matar poses for a photo with her son Yousef, 6, who suffers from malnutrition and cerebral palsy, at a U.N.-run school in Gaza City, Saturday, July 26, 2025. In Gaza, malnutrition is often worsened by preexisting conditions and compounded by illnesses linked to inadequate health care and poor sanitation, largely the result of the ongoing war. (AP Photo/Jehad Alshrafi)"

 

Two different international news agencies, two different photographers, two different dates, but almost identical pics in substance.  The AP pic is darker and has a different backdrop, but otherwise very similar to Reuters, down to the gray garbage bag diaper. The prominent backbone is the focal point of both photos.   :whistling:

 

I'm cynical enough to wonder if these might have been photo ops staged by Hamas to lend emotional impact to the claim of famine and starvation in Gaza.  Not fake photos, but definitely misleading.

 

Sometimes, however, the Hamas Media Office becomes disingenuous.  The photo below looks appropriately grim with yet another prominent backbone and a second child lying motionless off to the side.

 

afp.jpg.76cf9161b8b0a9bf1aa5a140a59fb302.jpg

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/on-the-inside/568411/nz-is-prepared-to-take-further-action-over-the-gaza-crisis-here-are-5-options

 

But when the second kid in the photo looks up, his face doesn't show any signs of starvation.  

 

afp2.jpg.f7a2a7d7a4646f45004bd36aeda56827.jpg

 

And the real kicker.  The pic below appeared in Al-Jazeera. It's the same photographer, day and news agency as above.

 

jihadi.jpg.85c566fb50629524d65e27ead5ba1151.jpg

 

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/7/26/israel-says-its-distributing-aid-in-gaza-so-why-are-people-starving

 

The brothers show no visible signs of malnutrition and are clothed.  So why is Yazan naked and deathly thin?  He's naked because it's a photo op to show off this thinness.  He's so thin because of an (and I'll spell it out) U-N-D-E-R-L-Y-I-N-G  M-E-D-I-C-A-L  C-O-N-D-I-T-I-O-N.  If the family were suffering from starvation, wouldn't the brothers be thin as well?

 

More revelations still to come.

 

 

 

  • Popular Post

Never mind the photos, the famine is real. Unless you want to ignore all aid agencies. Even trump has admitted the famine is real.

Not necessarily staged by Hamas, but possibly a result of the restricted media access afforded by the IDF? Lack of oversight by their own peers in the media is allowing the more opportunistic or biased "reporters" to make up tales that handily feed the Hamas narrative.

 

I had my doubts about these depictions of emaciated kids but the video released by Hamas of a skeletal Israeli hostage is undeniably closer to the truth.

8 minutes ago, stevenl said:

Never mind the photos, the famine is real. Unless you want to ignore all aid agencies. Even trump has admitted the famine is real.

 

No doubt there's a shortage of food in Gaza.  The issue is whether it amounts to starvation and specifically, whether the children with protruding backbones are emaciated due to Israeli policies on food aid or underlying  medical conditions.

  • Popular Post
9 minutes ago, Evil Penevil said:

 

No doubt there's a shortage of food in Gaza.  The issue is whether it amounts to starvation and specifically, whether the children with protruding backbones are emaciated due to Israeli policies on food aid or underlying  medical conditions.

There is famine, not ' a shortage of food '.

1 minute ago, stevenl said:

There is famine, not ' a shortage of food '.

 

How are you defining the word "famine?"

17 minutes ago, Evil Penevil said:

 

No doubt there's a shortage of food in Gaza.  The issue is whether it amounts to starvation and specifically, whether the children with protruding backbones are emaciated due to Israeli policies on food aid or underlying  medical conditions.

As an occupying military power it is a duty on Israel to ensure sufficient food, water, medicines and medical facilities for the civilian population under occupation.


 

 

24 minutes ago, Evil Penevil said:

 

How are you defining the word "famine?"

Again deflecting. Ask trump.

  • Popular Post
14 minutes ago, Chomper Higgot said:

As an occupying military power it is a duty on Israel to ensure sufficient food, water, medicines and medical facilities for the civilian population under occupation.

 

Failure to do is a war crime, not only to civilians, but to enemy combatants as well.

 

Anyone that orders, assists or aids and abets such measures are also guilty or war crime, as per international law. 

 

That's a lot of gallows for the IDF scum to swing from. 🙂

 

asd.jpg.9e84255b2c191fcf754c0c646f8b526a.jpg

 

Cogat, Israel's official numbers on how they are purposefully starving the population. 🙂 

53 minutes ago, Packer said:

Cogat, Israel's official numbers on how they are purposefully starving the population. 🙂 

Why do you think some people can’t believe the obvious facts?
it’s very strange.

1 hour ago, Evil Penevil said:

 

No doubt there's a shortage of food in Gaza.  The issue is whether it amounts to starvation and specifically, whether the children with protruding backbones are emaciated due to Israeli policies on food aid or underlying  medical conditions.

Shortage of food is a war crime, are you ok with that?
Many children have died of starvation or malnutrition.

Support the ongoing Israeli government is becoming more wrong every day. I can understand standing with Israel on Oct 7 but now defending the crimes makes one look stupid, uncaring, or religious extremist.

 

33 minutes ago, Chris.C said:

Shortage of food is a war crime, are you ok with that?
Many children have died of starvation or malnutrition.

 

It depends on the reason for the shortage of food.  Hamas is sabotaging the attempts of the Israeli government to deliver food to Gazans under circumstances that  prevent the food from falling into the hands of Hamas.  If many children are dying of starvation- and I've seen no evidence that's the case- then that is due to Hamas' failure to lay down its arms and release the remaining hostages.

 

33 minutes ago, Chris.C said:

I can understand standing with Israel on Oct 7 but now defending the crimes makes one look stupid, uncaring, or religious extremist.

 

I'm not defending any crimes, but I am defending the right of Jewish people to save their homeland from terrorist attacks by destroying Hamas.  Disagreeing with your take on the Gaza conflict doesn't make anyone stupid or a religious fanatic.  I will acknowledge that I don't care if Hamas and its supporters starve to death..

12 minutes ago, Evil Penevil said:

 

 

It depends on the reason for the shortage of food.  Hamas is sabotaging the attempts of the Israeli government to deliver food to Gazans under circumstances that  prevent the food from falling into the hands of Hamas.  If many children are dying of starvation- and I've seen no evidence that's the case- then that is due to Hamas' failure to lay down its arms and release the remaining hostages.

 

 

I'm not defending any crimes, but I am defending the right of Jewish people to save their homeland from terrorist attacks by destroying Hamas.  Disagreeing with your take on the Gaza conflict doesn't make anyone stupid or a religious fanatic.  I will acknowledge that I don't care if Hamas and its supporters starve to death..

Do you have any proof Hamas is responsible for the food shortage?
Do you not believe the 100 ++ aid agencies that say Israel is starving Gazans?

This is what I find very strange how Israel defenders can ignore these experts, Oxfam, Amnesty, etc.

Thanks for acknowledging you don’t care if people supporting a political group all are denied food until death.

  • Popular Post

The fabulously corrupt and morally bankrupt IDF is restricting media access, but multiple aid agencies have stated how real, how urgent, and how horrific the situation is. Israel is becoming a pariah throughout the world, and the blowback from this is going to last decades, and they deserve every ounce of it. 

1 minute ago, Chris.C said:

Do you not believe the 100 ++ aid agencies that say Israel is starving Gazans?

 

Actually, Israel's Cogat, the department in charge of food supply are saying that with their official documentation. They're undersupplying the population of Gaza by 40% of the minimum amount of food to meet basic needs. 🙂 

 

 

4 minutes ago, spidermike007 said:

The fabulously corrupt and morally bankrupt IDF is restricting media access,

They have a lot to hide.

Media might find buried medical workers and ambulances.

5 hours ago, Nick Carter icp said:

Photos of hunger and despair from Gaza were staged in collaboration with Hamas, German newspaper reveals

Süddeutsche Zeitung revealed photos of Gazans holding empty pots posing in front of photographers, and not in line for food aid;  Bild noted that one of the photographers was employed by a Turkish news agency, and posts anti-Israel content on social media; While the paper acknowledges that hunger exists in Gaza, expert warns of photo manipulations: 'They are intended to replace the cruel photos from Oct. 7'

 

 

https://www.ynetnews.com/article/skvxuqxdxl

 

 

 

Pick a newspaper, not a gossip paper, the worst paper available in Germany. 

I had a German instructor who grew up in the Sudentenland.

Her school group took a trip to Theresianstadt.

She said it wasn't so bad, the women there had lipstick.

 

 

  • Author
3 hours ago, stevenl said:

Never mind the photos, the famine is real. Unless you want to ignore all aid agencies. Even trump has admitted the famine is real.

 

  Where are all the photos of the famine and why do they need to make fake photos to pretend there's a famine ?

   Why don't they post genuine famine  photos ?

 

1 hour ago, Chris.C said:

Some don’t care, as they think Palestinians are less than human.

I find this extremely sad. 

 

I certainly don't think Palestinians are less than human.  I feel very sorry about Gazans'  suffering, but  they made a bad mistake in voting Hamas into power in 2006 and allowing it to seize the Gaza Strip.  They are are now paying a terrible, terrible price for that mistake.

 

I find it sad Hamas won't give up its avowed goal of destroying Israel.  As long as Hamas refuses to recognize the right of Israel to exist as the homeland of the world's Jews, there will never be a lasting peace in the region.

6 hours ago, Chomper Higgot said:

As an occupying military power it is a duty on Israel to ensure sufficient food, water, medicines and medical facilities for the civilian population under occupation.

Israel is not currently occupying Gaza!

8 hours ago, Evil Penevil said:

 

 

I certainly don't think Palestinians are less than human.  I feel very sorry about Gazans'  suffering, but  they made a bad mistake in voting Hamas into power in 2006 and allowing it to seize the Gaza Strip.  They are are now paying a terrible, terrible price for that mistake.

 

I find it sad Hamas won't give up its avowed goal of destroying Israel.  As long as Hamas refuses to recognize the right of Israel to exist as the homeland of the world's Jews, there will never be a lasting peace in the region.

Suggesting that the whole population "deserves" collective punishment, including death for voting the "wrong" party is morally indefensible. 

Democratic elections are not a license for mass retribution, especially when the electorate includes people who were too young to vote or never supported that party in the first place. This kind of thinking strips away the humanity of an entire people and sounds like you are justifying war crimes.

Yes, Hamas won the 2006 election, but.....The election was nearly two decades ago. Many Gazans alive today were not even born then. Hamas has not allowed free elections since, and dissent is suppressed. People under authoritarian regimes often have no realistic path to change their leadership.

Not all members of Hamas are part of its military wing, and not all Palestinians support Hamas. Painting 2 million people with the same brush is harmful.

Saying "they made a bad mistake and are now paying the price" shows a humanitarian catastrophe, a blockade, thousands of civilian deaths, widespread destruction, and lack of food, water, and medical care, as a form of just punishment. That is a profoundly inhumane view.

You don’t have to pick sides in a way that dehumanizes the other. Standing for human rights means standing for all human rights, whether the victims are Israeli or Palestinian.

  • Popular Post
5 hours ago, Liverpool Lou said:

Israel is not currently occupying Gaza!

Are you joking?
They are in the process of annexation, full takeover and extermination of the people.

9 hours ago, Chris.C said:
15 hours ago, Liverpool Lou said:

Israel is not currently occupying Gaza!

Are you joking?
They are in the process of annexation, full takeover and extermination of the people.

No, I am not joking.  Israel is not currently occupying Gaza.

22 hours ago, Chomper Higgot said:

As an occupying military power it is a duty on Israel to ensure sufficient food, water, medicines and medical facilities for the civilian population under occupation.


 

 

 

After the atrocities committed by the Gaza government I don't think they deserve any of those.

6 minutes ago, Liverpool Lou said:

No, I am not joking.  Israel is not currently occupying Gaza.

Yes, you love your semantics. Reality not so much.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.