The claim: "+2.8% is Biden's 2024 4th Q GDP growth" and "+.7% is Trump's 2025 GDP Growth." Reality: No, this comparison is apples-to-oranges and incorrect. Q4 2024 (Biden's last full quarter, Oct–Dec 2024): Real GDP grew at an annualized rate of 2.4% (final third estimate from BEA, March 2025 release; earlier estimates were 2.3%). Not 2.8%. • The 2.8% figure actually refers to full-year 2024 annual GDP growth (from 2023 level to 2024 level), not specifically Q4. • For Trump in 2025: There is no single ".7% for 2025 GDP Growth." The 0.7% (or 0.70%) figure matches Q4 2025 (Oct–Dec 2025) quarterly annualized growth (second estimate from BEA, around March 2026). Full-year 2025 annual GDP growth was 2.2% (a slowdown from 2024's 2.8%), with quarterly ups and downs: negative in Q1 2025 (-0.3% to -0.5%), stronger mid-year (e.g., 3.8%–4.4% in Q2/Q3), then slowing to 1.4% advance / 0.7% revised in Q4 2025 (partly due to factors like a government shutdown). • Math verdict: 0.7% (one weak Trump quarter) is obviously not > 2.4% (Biden's actual Q4 2024). But comparing one quarter under Trump to a full-year or mismatched figure under Biden is invalid cherry-picking. Full-year growth was higher under Biden (2.8%) than Trump's first year (2.2%), but quarterly volatility (including early-2025 contraction tied to policy transitions/tariffs) makes direct "Trump bad" claims oversimplified. The "math" here is like comparing a sprinter's best 100m time to a marathoner's yearly mileage and declaring victory—technically numbers are numbers, but the framing is rigged. Q4-to-Q4 or full-year apples-to-apples shows Biden's 2024 stronger in both GDP (2.8% annual) and jobs (~2.2M), while Trump's 2025 was weaker across the board (2.2% GDP annual, 181K jobs net). But boiling complex economies down to "Is X > Y?" without context (policy lags, revisions, one-off events like shutdowns) is classic forum gotcha, not serious analysis with some marginal factual basis—but your "selective math" seems designed to trigger rather than inform. Numbers don't lie; selective ones do. https://www.bea.gov/news/2025/gross-domestic-product-4th-quarter-and-year-2024-third-estimate-gdp-industry-and https://apnews.com/article/us-economy-gdp-growth-trump-tariff-9c6686a658241dbad8ebdeff632ff0ac https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/gdp-growth https://www.economist.com/interactive/trump-approval-tracker/economy https://www.longvieweconomics.com/news-and-media/press-coverage/818k-less-jobs-were-created-by-biden-admin.-calling-for-concerns-about-the-economy
Create an account or sign in to comment