Trump’s Proposal for Gazan Relocation makes perfect sense

[OneMoreFarang]

I have an alternative idea.

All Israelis will be invited to the USA. Maybe give them a part of Nevada or something like that.

And then let all the Palestinians return to their own land.

That solves many problems at the same time.

The Palestinians and probably all other countries in that region will be happy that there are no Israelis anymore. 

The USA loves Israelis. They spend already billions on them every year. The USA will welcome them in peace.

Israelis will live in peace and Palestinians will live in peace. Win/win.

Everybody will be happy.

Just do it!

[OneMoreFarang]

23 hours ago, bunnydrops said:

So, who would get the land? Trump or Israel.

Probably Trump would sell it to Israel. 

[Nick Carter icp]

Just now, OneMoreFarang said:

I have an alternative idea.

All Israelis will be invited to the USA. Maybe give them a part of Nevada or something like that.

 

 

   Removing a peoples from their land .

So, You are in favour of genocide .

Thats what genocide is, removing people from their land 

[OneMoreFarang]

3 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   Removing a peoples from their land .

So, You are in favour of genocide .

Thats what genocide is, removing people from their land 

No, genocide is killing other people systematically, that's what Israel did in the last year and more.

 

My suggestion is absolutely peaceful. Nobody has to die. Everybody will live happily ever after.

And by the way, it is the land of the Palestinian people, that the whole point. 

[Bkk Brian]

8 minutes ago, OneMoreFarang said:

No, genocide us killing other people systematically, that's what Israel did in the last year and more.

 

My suggestion is absolutely peaceful. Nobody has to die. Everybody will live happily ever after.

And by the way, it is the land of the Palestinian people, that the whole point. 

Here is Hamas starting the war on Oct 7th. Israeli is fighting back Hamas's constant attempts at Genocide and will never give up. 

 

"It is said that @POTUS will be sitting for a viewing of the raw footage from October 7 for the first time. Personally I’ve always said that the footage should have been released for everyone to watch and understand just how severe and barbaric it was. So for everyone here on X, I’m going to post this slightly shorter version of 21 minutes which will show you what happened on that day and allow you to understand exactly who our neighbors really are. For context, about half of those who took part in the rapes and torture and brutal massacres and the kidnapping were Gazan civilians, including Gazan children. Hamas, PIJ and UNRWA led the atrocities, but thousands of Gazan civilians took part willingly, and then tens if not hundreds of thousands celebrated it. I urge you all to watch however hard it may be to view it. It’s the only way you can fully understand what we deal with every day of the past many decades at the hands of Islamic terrorists. WARNING: EXTREMELY GRAPHIC CONTENT"

 

I have not put the video live as its graphic, to view you would need to click it.

 

https://x.com/CherylWroteIt/status/1886584827916218857

 

[Nick Carter icp]

1 minute ago, OneMoreFarang said:

No, genocide us killing other people systematically, that's what Israel did in the last year and more.

 

My suggestion is absolutely peaceful. Nobody has to die. Everybody will live happily ever after.

And by the way, it is the land of the Palestinian people, that the whole point. 

 

   Israelis will not go willingly to the USA, you would have to force them .

Putting an end to Israelis would indeed be classified as a genocide 

[OneMoreFarang]

9 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   Israelis will not go willingly to the USA, you would have to force them .

Putting an end to Israelis would indeed be classified as a genocide 

And do you think Palestinians will leave willingly their land? Or does that not really matter because they are anyhow not much better than dogs?

[Bkk Brian]

2 minutes ago, OneMoreFarang said:

And do you think Palestinians will leave willingly their land? Or does that not really matter because they are anyhow not much better than dogs?

Why are you saying they are not much better than dogs? Who claimed they were going to be forced out? 

[Nick Carter icp]

4 minutes ago, OneMoreFarang said:

And do you think Palestinians will leave willingly their land? Or does that not really matter because they are anyhow not much better than dogs?

 

   Do dogs take other dogs puppys and then hold them hostage and kill those puppy's if they don't get what they want ?

   

[Social Media]

Numerous off topic posts, posts making unsubstainiated claims and antisemitic rants removed. 

[bunnydrops]

2 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

Probably Trump would sell it to Israel. 

I don't know. I see a beachfront hotel and golf course in Gaza's future.

[Hanaguma]

5 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

No, genocide is killing other people systematically, that's what Israel did in the last year and more.

 

My suggestion is absolutely peaceful. Nobody has to die. Everybody will live happily ever after.

And by the way, it is the land of the Palestinian people, that the whole point. 

Yeah, no.  If Israel wanted to systematically kill off the Gazans, it would have been done in 72 hours. They have been remarkably restrained in their conduct of the war.  If I had been in Netanyahu's shoes, I would have turned the place into a parking lot after what happened on October 7. There is no living beside people like that- they are too far gone in their hatred and worship of death.

[MicroB]

Mr Trumpf stated "other places. You could have more than two......I think we need another location. I think it should be a location that’s going to make people happy,,,,, If we can get a beautiful area to resettle people permanently"

 

So he's volunteering to resettle Gazans in the United States of America if they want to come? There is precedent. FDR convened the Evian Conference in 1938 to discuss resettlement of Jews from Germany.  I'm sure he will agree that America is a beautiful country with lots of spare space. Even more so as he is deporting so many.

[hotsun]

The people that have interest in this topic had no interest in the stories of hostages recently released by hamas. Wonder why that is

[Ben Zioner]

On 2/3/2025 at 6:31 PM, Will B Good said:

So let me get this straight....he is proposing mass immigration to neighbouring countries..........you couldn't write this stuff.

Not "neighbouring countries", Greenland, or possibly Mars, as Elon suggests.

[MicroB]

12 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

And do you think Palestinians will leave willingly their land? Or does that not really matter because they are anyhow not much better than dogs?

 

While the land might be uninhabitable, there are Gazans who have legal title to the land, evidenced through Deeds. That ownership should be recognised, and land owners compensated  o No redevelopment of the land until ownership issuen an individual basis.  Given that the likely buyers would be Israeli property developers, I would suggest valuation based on utility as farm land, based on Israeli land prices. Much of thancien régimee Gazan strip was used for horticulture.

 

The Nazis might have run Germany, and indeed might have had significant support when balloted, but that did not entitle the Occupying Forces to arbitrarily seize property. Certainly the Bonn government was obliged to provide restitution in the cases of property that was seized during WW2 by the ancien regime.

 

Israel ratified the Geneva Conventions on July 6, 1951. Israel claims the Geneva Convention does not apply to operations in Gaza, as it is not sovereign territory. Others beg to differ. Mr Trumpf might agreewith Israel, until he realises what that means. Protocol V describes the Protocol on the Explosive Remnants of War. Basically it discusses what do you do with the battlefield afterwards. Who is responsible for demining territory they control.

 

https://geneva-s3.unoda.org/static-unoda-site/pages/templates/the-convention-on-certain-conventional-weapons/Protocol%2Bon%2BExplosive%2BRemnants%2Bof%2BWar.pdf

 

Quote

After the cessation of active hostilities and as soon as feasible, each High Contracting Party and party to an armed conflict shall mark and clear, remove or destroy explosive remnants of war in affected territories under its control

 

If Israel claims its a bit of Israel, then it has no obligation to demine it. It can leave it as wasteland, left to the dogs.  If Trumpf pushes Article V, he can force Israel to pick up the tab for deminng rather than expecting the American taxpayer to pay for it. Israel has droped about 90-95,000 tons of munitions over a 360 square km area of land, give or take, about 260 tons per square km.

 

Trumpf thought it would take a 2-5 years to demine the area. This is where is lack of experience in uniform becomes apparent. He is apparently unaware of the scale fo Allied bombing sorties over Germany during WW2. Berlin, a city of about 900 suare kms, received about 67,000 tons of British and American bombs. And these weren't the smart or precision bombs supposedly used on Gaza. About 15% of bombs never exploded, and that's probably still the case.

 

80 years on, they are still finding live bombs in the city. I'm not sure the Israelis and Trumpf have thought this through. They have salted the earth for 3 generations, and now they own the farm. I would suggest US taxpayers forcefully remind their representatives that the US budget is in deficit, and while 30% of US civil servants are set to lose their jobs, it would be an unwise act to send taxpayer money to a foreign state to decontaminate land that they contaminated. Its a cost that sould be picked up by Israeli government, and by extension, the Israeli taxpayer. 80 years, Germany spends abotu $10m per year on bomb disposal.

[MicroB]

29 minutes ago, hotsun said:

The people that have interest in this topic had no interest in the stories of hostages recently released by hamas. Wonder why that is

 

What you state is demonstrably a fib. It only exists in your head.

 

As a Briton, I think about the London Blitz. But I still feel sorry for the people that perished in the Hamberg Firestorm and others.

[MicroB]

15 minutes ago, Ben Zioner said:

Not "neighbouring countries", Greenland, or possibly Mars, as Elon suggests.

 

Why not New York?

[OneMoreFarang]

Just in case you haven't see it yet:

 

Trump says US will ‘take over’ and ‘own’ Gaza Strip and says US troops will be deployed ‘if it’s necessary’ – live

 

https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2025/feb/04/benjamin-netanyahu-donald-trump-israel-gaza-middle-east-ceasefire-latest-live-news

 

 

[MicroB]

32 minutes ago, hotsun said:

The people that have interest in this topic had no interest in the stories of hostages recently released by hamas. Wonder why that is

 

Well, what is notable is there are still hostages missing, live and dead. Trumpf is already talking about redevelopment of the land. Wonder why that is. He doesn't care about the hostages.

[Ben Zioner]

13 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

I have an alternative idea.

All Israelis will be invited to the USA. Maybe give them a part of Nevada or something like that.

And then let all the Palestinians return to their own land.

That solves many problems at the same time.

The Palestinians and probably all other countries in that region will be happy that there are no Israelis anymore. 

The USA loves Israelis. They spend already billions on them every year. The USA will welcome them in peace.

Israelis will live in peace and Palestinians will live in peace. Win/win.

Everybody will be happy.

Just do it!

 

A friendly reminder for the [deliberately] illiterate.

 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Israel

 

 

 

[thaibeachlovers]

2 hours ago, hotsun said:

The people that have interest in this topic had no interest in the stories of hostages recently released by hamas. Wonder why that is

 

There is no interest in the stories of Palestinian prisoners recently released by israel. Wonder why that is?

[thaibeachlovers]

1 hour ago, MicroB said:

 

Well, what is notable is there are still hostages missing, live and dead. Trumpf is already talking about redevelopment of the land. Wonder why that is. He doesn't care about the hostages.

Why should he?

[Bkk Brian]

2 minutes ago, thaibeachlovers said:

 

There is no interest in the stories of Palestinian prisoners recently released by israel. Wonder why that is?

Why should there be? Oh yea, forgot it was you, here you go.....................

 

"As hostages are released from Gaza, some of the world’s most dangerous terrorists are walking out of prison. "

 

 

 

[Hamus Yaigh]

1 hour ago, OneMoreFarang said:

Trump says US will ‘take over’ and ‘own’ Gaza Strip and says US troops will be deployed ‘if it’s necessary’

Seems like the orange buffoon has not asked the Palestinians what they think about this?

[NickyLouie]

It's really time for all the fellow good hearted Muslims to do the right things and accept those poor oppressed Palestinian people    

 

Really, Gaza can be the Paris of the Middle East ......

[impulse]

15 hours ago, Nick Carter icp said:

It has been spoken about in previous threads numerous times .

We cannot keep just having the same discussion  over and over again , it just ends up with the same few people saying the same thing back and forth to each other on a regular basis in different threads .

 

That's why Israel is in an intractable situation, since the British cock-ups after WW1 and WW2. 

 

Israel will still be fighting their neighbors in another 75-100 years unless something different happens.  Good luck settling on what that "something different" would be.

 

[KhunLA]

14 minutes ago, impulse said:

 

That's why Israel is in an intractable situation, since the British cock-ups after WW1 and WW2. 

 

Israel will still be fighting their neighbors in another 75-100 years unless something different happens.  Good luck settling on what that "something different" would be.

 

Yep ... Israelis leaving would be a permanent solution, as their never ending expansion of, land grabs by them is and well, always will be ... never ending.

[Dan O]

On 2/3/2025 at 6:20 PM, billd766 said:

Gaza does NOT belong to Trump or to the USA, nor even, though they don't believe it, does it belong to Israel. It belongs to the Palestinian people ONLY. They are the ones who should decide its fate, and no other country.

 

Imagine if the native Americans decided that the USA belonged to them and to them only, and all the later immigrants must go back to their own countries. Do you think that Trump would give in to that?

Get caught up as Trump wants to have the USA control the Gaza strip. So much for the anti war leader who wants to annex part of Canada, take the Panama Canal, buy or steal Greenland. Broke the peace deal with Russia and Ukraine giving Russia control of much of Ukraine lands. Thats just outside the USA, he's trying to take complete control over the Executive branch inside the country to have every department left answer only to him and prosecute anyone that does not agree with his demented thinking.  He's sounding more and more like his ideals Putin, Xi by declaring himself President for life. 

[impulse]

10 minutes ago, KhunLA said:

Yep ... Israelis leaving would be a permanent solution, as their never ending expansion of, land grabs by them is and well, always will be ... never ending.

 

I was doing my best to not go there.  I'll just say that I see their current situation as "intractable".