Should Scotland leave ?

[CharlieH]

I know there are many expats here from Scotland, a referendum will be held later this year on whether or not to remain part of the UK.

What do you think and why ?

[BKK Blues Brother]

Up to the Scots to decide.

If the rest of the U.K had a vote, i guess it would be a done deal.....

Providing they cut the apron strings completely and the Royal Bank of Scotland pays back the 45 Billion pounds to the U.K taxpayer.

The rational, intelligent Scot will ditch that self serving Salmond and vote No.

[sustento]

If they leave who are they going to blame when things go wrong?

[BKK Blues Brother]

If they leave who are they going to blame when things go wrong?

The English of course, that's what all the commonwealth failed countries do or did when they gained their independence.

[Shurup]

Absolutely! Not just UK, leave the EU!

I'm neither English or Scot by the way.

[GinBoy2]

I just looked up the populations of the UK countries. It's so small would anyone even notice or even care if they left??

[davejones]

I think England should leave the UK. Why should the English always have to pay for the Welsh, Scottish and Irish?

[I Like Thai]

I think England should leave the UK. Why should the English always have to pay for the Welsh, Scottish and Irish?

I agree, but will the Germans take them back into Germany ?

[bigbamboo]

I think the people of all four constituent countries should be allowed to vote as to whether they want to be independent. It shouldn't just be for the Scots to decide if they want to break up the UK. After all, the Scots, Welsh and Irish make a big thing of being 'celtic' so perhaps they'd prefer a kingdom of their own without the English?

Plenty of English people would!

Edited February 7, 2014 by bigbamboo

[SeaVisionBurma]

Posts removed - non English and inappropriate language.

[Suradit69]

I think England should leave the UK. Why should the English always have to pay for the Welsh, Scottish and Irish?

I agree, but will the Germans take them back into Germany ?

And speaking of Germans, maybe Scotland could charge this gaggle of tourists for visas and re-entry permits every time they do a border run.

The Sachsen-Coburg und Gotha family at home

[Commander Tamson]

I'm Scots - just in case my avatar had you guessing - but if those left living there vote yes for independence, I want to have the right to maintain my British nationality. I'm British first, then Scots. I only hate the English when they beat us at rugby - an all too common occurrence unfortunately.

The population of Scotland is approx 4.5M, but it's estimated that 20 to 25 million are scattered across the globe - not sure if that figure is purely 1st generation of course. Not sure how the vote would go if the expat Scots were allowed the vote - too many romantics maybe. But I'm quietly confident that there's enough sensible folk left in them there purple glens to give it the big No it so rightly deserves.

PS - Mark Carney, the new Governor of The Bank of England, gave a speech to Scottish business leaders in Edinburgh last week. The whole speech is available on the BoE website if anyone's interested. He had to be very careful what he said, but it was what he didn't say that was most interesting!

Sent from my iPad using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Edited February 7, 2014 by Commander Tamson

[lmfao]

Woo Big steps there, will North Ire be next? are the British losing it?

[BwindiBoy]

I'm Scots - just in case my avatar had you guessing - but if those left living there vote yes for independence, I want to have the right to maintain my British nationality. I'm British first, then Scots. I only hate the English when they beat us at rugby - an all too common occurrence unfortunately.

The population of Scotland is approx 4.5M, but it's estimated that 20 to 25 million are scattered across the globe - not sure if that figure is purely 1st generation of course. Not sure how the vote would go if the expat Scots were allowed the vote - too many romantics maybe. But I'm quietly confident that there's enough sensible folk left in them there purple glens to give it the big No it so rightly deserves.

PS - Mark Carney, the new Governor of The Bank of England, gave a speech to Scottish business leaders in Edinburgh last week. The whole speech is available on the BoE website if anyone's interested. He had to be very careful what he said, but it was what he didn't say that was most interesting!

Sent from my iPad using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

You're going to hate us again tomorrow (today) then! ;-)

[sustento]

Woo Big steps there, will North Ire be next? are the British losing it?

Let's hope so...

[pineconehead]

Wow this is almost like watching the final divestment or stripping of the British Empire, fascinating to see.

Edited February 8, 2014 by pineconehead

[stevie403]

Better if Scotland leaves so would stop the english goverment and English people moaning about Scotland all the time, would put the onus into NI or Wales

Sent from my iPhone using Thaivisa Connect Thailand

[sustento]

Better if Scotland leaves so would stop the english goverment and English people moaning about Scotland all the time

Pot Kettle

[stevie403]

Lol yes

Sent from my iPhone using Thaivisa Connect Thailand

[baneko]

Yes....Freedom.

[lmfao]

"They may take away our lives, but they'll never take our freedom!" Braveheart

Maybe someone can translate into a Scottish accent?

[stevie403]

Sent from my iPhone using Thaivisa Connect Thailand

[dukeandduke]

They left last night's rugby match before it started, if that's any indication.

[smokie36]

I am Scottish and have a vote...which I will be using to say YES.

[Satcommlee]

I just wish the Welsh had the same option!

[Razzler1973]

All that I have seen regarding this just doesn't seem clear ... there are too many 'we'll sort that out later' answers to questions so before they decide I just hope they get a full overview of the facts and consequences before deciding as it affects everyone

[Commander Tamson]

All that I have seen regarding this just doesn't seem clear ... there are too many 'we'll sort that out later' answers to questions so before they decide I just hope they get a full overview of the facts and consequences before deciding as it affects everyone

Exactly!

There was a resounding No in the referendum in the 70's. Hollywood's version of Wallace's life is the only thing to have changed since. I don't believe all Scots are that stupid!

[Razzler1973]

I read that all current residents of Scotland can vote but overseas Scots cannot

i.e. An Englishman or German living in Scotland at the moment is eligible to cast a vote whereas a Scot living in Asia cannot. Not sure if there's a time limit on how long you have to have been living there either for those non-Scots

There's near 700 pages of documents but currencies, EU related things and various repurcussions all seem to be up in the air. I just hope the vote takes more into account than 'get up yee yee English' and hope a majority of Scots have more to them than 'sticking it to us English'

[sustento]

I just wish the Welsh had the same option!

Don't we all

[Commander Tamson]

"They may take away our lives, but they'll never take our freedom!" Braveheart

Maybe someone can translate into a Scottish accent?

I think it should it have read "They can take away our Wives (& in a lot of cases, good f'ing riddance), but they'll never take away our deep fried Mars Bars"