Thailand beach murders: Hannah Witheridge and David Miller may have argued in bar with gangster

[ozzyrules]

Well I stepped up a few hours ago but my post was deleted by Thaivisa, you can rest assured that some people don't want to know or allow the truth to be conveyed..

This crime is a lot worse than Murder...there is photograpic proof from the crime scene that has been released by the police in private that shows and proves the female victim was murdered BEFORE she was raped twice...

counting the minutes till this post is deleted, but not to worry, there will be copies of the photos/proof sent to the western news, no more cover ups!!!!!!!!!

[LanceGringo]

Well I stepped up a few hours ago but my post was deleted by Thaivisa, you can rest assured that some people don't want to know or allow the truth to be conveyed..

This crime is a lot worse than Murder...there is photograpic proof from the crime scene that has been released by the police in private that shows and proves the female victim was murdered BEFORE she was raped twice...

counting the minutes till this post is deleted, but not to worry, there will be copies of the photos/proof sent to the western news, no more cover ups!!!!!!!!!

How do you know she was raped after being murdered?

[bander]

"Police last night said they were planned to DNA test every male on the island."

What have taken them so long? Afraid to lose face again?

http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/scot-goes-hiding-thai-island-4302708

[englishoak]

Guy in the picture with brother suspect that sean took ...... the one on the right of the picture is the brothers m8 and guess what ? hes .......... police

[ozzyrules]

Well I stepped up a few hours ago but my post was deleted by Thaivisa, you can rest assured that some people don't want to know or allow the truth to be conveyed..

This crime is a lot worse than Murder...there is photograpic proof from the crime scene that has been released by the police in private that shows and proves the female victim was murdered BEFORE she was raped twice...

counting the minutes till this post is deleted, but not to worry, there will be copies of the photos/proof sent to the western news, no more cover ups!!!!!!!!!

How do you know she was raped after being murdered?

I have seen photos from the crime scene..A forensic expert can confirm whether someone is penetrated before or after death...I am no expert but have it on experts advice that these phootos undoubtedly prove these rapes occurred after the murder..

I has been explained to me the difference and makes total sense..there is a huge cover up going on here still..

[LanceGringo]

Well I stepped up a few hours ago but my post was deleted by Thaivisa, you can rest assured that some people don't want to know or allow the truth to be conveyed..

This crime is a lot worse than Murder...there is photograpic proof from the crime scene that has been released by the police in private that shows and proves the female victim was murdered BEFORE she was raped twice...

counting the minutes till this post is deleted, but not to worry, there will be copies of the photos/proof sent to the western news, no more cover ups!!!!!!!!!

How do you know she was raped after being murdered?

I have seen photos from the crime scene..A forensic expert can confirm whether someone is penetrated before or after death...I am no expert but have it on experts advice that these phootos undoubtedly prove these rapes occurred after the murder..

I has been explained to me the difference and makes total sense..there is a huge cover up going on here still..

Can you explain what the differences are, based on photographic evidence alone?

[bristolgeoff]

_{i think this is the truth with these deaths,also they are long gone now from the island with what happened.}

[ozzyrules]

Well I stepped up a few hours ago but my post was deleted by Thaivisa, you can rest assured that some people don't want to know or allow the truth to be conveyed..

This crime is a lot worse than Murder...there is photograpic proof from the crime scene that has been released by the police in private that shows and proves the female victim was murdered BEFORE she was raped twice...

counting the minutes till this post is deleted, but not to worry, there will be copies of the photos/proof sent to the western news, no more cover ups!!!!!!!!!

How do you know she was raped after being murdered?

I have seen photos from the crime scene..A forensic expert can confirm whether someone is penetrated before or after death...I am no expert but have it on experts advice that these phootos undoubtedly prove these rapes occurred after the murder..

I has been explained to me the difference and makes total sense..there is a huge cover up going on here still..

Can you explain what the differences are, based on photographic evidence alone?

I'll try to explain it ...there are photos that prove it....Imagine when a person dies,rigamortis setsin and their body gets hard quickly, so if a person was penetrated after death it would be usual for their point of penetration to remain open rather than close naturally...the photos show this clearly...

My apologies to the families and friends involved, but by sharing this horrific knowledge I can only hope the animals that did this get what is coming to them.....

[bander]

<script type='text/javascript'>window.mod_pagespeed_start = Number(new Date());</script>

I'm trying to keep up on multiple threads so I may have missed this but has anyone passed the screen shot pics of the alleged bar owner/guy on the beach to the Western media?

I have to agree that the guy on the left, very much looks like the guy who was on the crime scene with the police on other photos. If that is the case, then I wonder how he also ended up on this picture?

In the video it's even more stark - the guy on the left is the guy standing on the beach with police at the crime scene. So who is he that he's walking all over the crime scene? Why was he there if he isn't police?

He was there to remove any evidence who could implicate Thai locals

[rhythmworx]

Will someone please clarify which one of the dead tourists news threads is the latest official one?

There's so many of them I'm not sure which is the one to comment in.

I

[penoirz]

Guy in the picture with brother suspect that sean took ...... the one on the right of the picture is the brothers m8 and guess what ? hes .......... police

Really? has this been confirmed?

[MJP]

Will someone please clarify which one of the dead tourists news threads is the latest official one?

There's so many of them I'm not sure which is the one to comment in.

I

I'm totally lost, Worx.

Really need a locked thread updated by a moderator as 'factoids' come in. Impossible to keep track otherwise.

[Fred Flinstone]

The Scot will be detained for a while .

He is now known to have worked illegally-

Returned the day of the crime. (to the island)

Made strong accusations against Thai nationals .

Hopefully, DNA will support his claims.

His prior conviction for child porn will hit Thai media Today most likely.

I guess they will take his blood sample to check for drugs.

This boy might be in a world of pain soon.

If he has been less than truthful a very sorry state of affairs await as the chips fall against him

[englishoak]

Guy in the picture with brother suspect that sean took ...... the one on the right of the picture is the brothers m8 and guess what ? hes .......... police

Really? has this been confirmed?

i should say so

the television news interview with the brother given to thai media, Thairath online while answering questions he said his friend with him was police.

Right from the horses mouth if you can understand thai you can listen to it yourself.

[MJP]

The Scot will be detained for a while .

He is now known to have worked illegally-

Returned the day of the crime. (to the island)

Made strong accusations against Thai nationals .

Hopefully, DNA will support his claims.

His prior conviction for child porn will hit Thai media Today most likely.

I guess they will take his blood sample to check for drugs.

This boy might be in a world of pain soon.

If he has been less than truthful a very sorry state of affairs await as the chips fall against him

You mean he didn't make it to Italy?

[Fred Flinstone]

Quote

The police last night released two men, who own Intouch Bar and AC Pub on the resort island, after interrogating them for three hours and finding no evidence linking them to the crime

Unquote

I thought he was in protective custody in Bangkok.

Pretty sure thats the case still.

However , this case needs more facts

[Snookyville]

I have seen photos from the crime scene..A forensic expert can confirm whether someone is penetrated before or after death...I am no expert but have it on experts advice that these phootos undoubtedly prove these rapes occurred after the murder..

I has been explained to me the difference and makes total sense..there is a huge cover up going on here still..

Can you explain what the differences are, based on photographic evidence alone?

I'll try to explain it ...there are photos that prove it....Imagine when a person dies,rigamortis setsin and their body gets hard quickly, so if a person was penetrated after death it would be usual for their point of penetration to remain open rather than close naturally...the photos show this clearly...

My apologies to the families and friends involved, but by sharing this horrific knowledge I can only hope the animals that did this get what is coming to them.....

I catch your drift but rigor mortis normally sets in 3-4 hours after death depending on environment temperature etc. I just don't think they have waited for so long.

Although on the other hand:

• Physical exertion just prior to death: If someone dies while engaged in strenuous activity like exercising or struggling against drowning, rigor mortis can set in immediately. This instant onset, sometimes called cadaveric spasm, happens because the person's muscles, at the moment of death, were depleted of oxygen energy and ATP. This is why the victim of a violent attack may still be clutching the attacker's hair or a piece of clothing.

http://health.howstuffworks.com/diseases-conditions/death-dying/rigor-mortis-cause2.htm

[Goshawk]

Will someone please clarify which one of the dead tourists news threads is the latest official one?

There's so many of them I'm not sure which is the one to comment in.

agree . . . seems there's a 'new' thread on this tragedy opening up in the 'news section' all the time.

quite disgusting really . . if you factor that the friends & relatives of those two poor people are probably reading all this speculation on these pages too. TV should close them all, except for the very latest one they are posting/promoting.

[LanceGringo]

Will someone please clarify which one of the dead tourists news threads is the latest official one?

There's so many of them I'm not sure which is the one to comment in.

agree . . . seems there's a 'new' thread on this tragedy opening up in the 'news section' all the time.

quite disgusting really . . if you factor that the friends & relatives of those two poor people are probably reading all this speculation on these pages too. TV should close them all, except for the very latest one they are posting/promoting.

If my son/daughter or someone in my family had been the victim of a crime like this, the last thing I think I would be doing is reading forum posts/threads about every detail online in a chat forum. Just my opinion.

Having said that, and anyone related or who knows the victims is reading these posts, I just want to say how desperately heartbroken I am for them, I really hope the murderers are brought to justice. This case has really affected me, and even though I don't know the victims, I want the families and their friends to be able to get some closure from knowing that the guys responsible for this awful crime have been caught and punished.

[TV7]

It's great news that the Thai police are now interrogating Thai mafia. But remember McAnna didn't say these two guys were the culprits, only that they threatened him and may know who did it. So the DNA results may come back negative and then we're back to square one. I think the killers are long gone, they would have fled the island immediately knowing that they had left DNA behind and it would be only a matter of time before they tested everyone on the island. The row in AC bar may prove to be a red herring

[Goshawk]

Will someone please clarify which one of the dead tourists news threads is the latest official one?

There's so many of them I'm not sure which is the one to comment in.

agree . . . seems there's a 'new' thread on this tragedy opening up in the 'news section' all the time.

quite disgusting really . . if you factor that the friends & relatives of those two poor people are probably reading all this speculation on these pages too. TV should close them all, except for the very latest one they are posting/promoting.

If my son/daughter or someone in my family had been the victim of a crime like this, the last thing I think I would be doing is reading forum posts/threads about every detail online in a chat forum. Just my opinion.

are <deleted> serious? if it was my daughter, i'd be scouring every possible avenue i had available to me to find the bast**ds that harmed her. That includes places like this!

Close the multiple threads though TV. They are not helpful. Content & ad revenue isn't everything you know (ouch)

[TV7]

It's great news that the Thai police are now interrogating Thai mafia. But remember McAnna didn't say these two guys were the culprits, only that they threatened him and may know who did it. So the DNA results may come back negative and then we're back to square one. I think the killers are long gone, they would have fled the island immediately knowing that they had left DNA behind and it would be only a matter of time before they tested everyone on the island. The row in AC bar may prove to be a red herring

There are also still a lot of questions around this. Like, if D and H weren't together that night, how did they end up on the beach together? How did the killers get H onto the beach? Why did D go back to his room alone and then return later? Why was D found naked? What about the cigarette that H shared with one of the rapists? Would she share a cigarette with a goon who has been hassling her all night and had a public row with? How did D end up in the sea? Why was H found in a secluded part of the beach? Was she lured onto the beach by someone she knew and trusted?

[Albertosez]

It's hard to follow - but it sounds like the bro of the owner of AC Bar is still in custody whilst another younger member of the family ( maybe cousin or nephew ) is still on the run. They have found a connection between the Hoe and the family and have detained the one brother of the bar.

In effect, if this is all true, then the whole murder case can be traced back to the bar. ( AC Bar ) which has been claimed to be the case many days ago. The elder members of the family who seem to own the 2 x bars in question initially refused DNA Tests - but have since given samples. Why was this ? The answer in my opinion is quite simple - the DNA samples would / should definitely prove a close match and at least incriminate the family and that is why they refused to give samples initially. This has allowed the younger member of the family to make a run for it.

If there hadn't been the strong pressure from the International Press then I suspect this would have also been swept under the carpet. Unfortunately, for them, the media and social media has exposed the most obvious clues they were trying to overlook - but people pressure has not allowed that. It does seem ( IMO ) that they will now catch the right Perps ........in spite of the significant efforts of the locals to make this problem go away!

I will be telling all my family and friends where not to visit in Thailand. This is the only real justice that they will get !

Regretfully, none of this exposure has been pleasant for the respective families, but unfortunately, I doubt these cases would have been nailed had it not been for such public exposure and finger pointing !

[JenniferSG]

It's great news that the Thai police are now interrogating Thai mafia. But remember McAnna didn't say these two guys were the culprits, only that they threatened him and may know who did it. So the DNA results may come back negative and then we're back to square one. I think the killers are long gone, they would have fled the island immediately knowing that they had left DNA behind and it would be only a matter of time before they tested everyone on the island. The row in AC bar may prove to be a red herring

There are also still a lot of questions around this. Like, if D and H weren't together that night, how did they end up on the beach together? How did the killers get H onto the beach? Why did D go back to his room alone and then return later? Why was D found naked? What about the cigarette that H shared with one of the rapists? Would she share a cigarette with a goon who has been hassling her all night and had a public row with? How did D end up in the sea? Why was H found in a secluded part of the beach? Was she lured onto the beach by someone she knew and trusted?

The beach was 300 feet from her bungalo. David stayed in the same building.

[Plutojames88]

Many years ago a Thai man produced a knife at 4am and proceeded to Rob my girlfriend and myself on a beach front just prior to dawn.

A thud was heard and the robber fell to the ground smashing his head further on the ground and out cold.

A soccer hooligan type appeared immediately .

He had thrown a full bottle of beer ( a large one)

He then began kicking the unconscious Thai man , who I ironically now needed to save from being kicked to death.

The girl with me was Thai and trying to strangle him to death likewise.

Had it not been for my efforts this guy was done.

What I learnt is violence begets violence.

These little nasty Thai thugs on some island picking on westerners need to know their are some lunatic westerners on the loose in those environments .

Killing them is just as bad

I urge not to seek retribution ....but allow due process.

Notice boards are threatening retribution on grubby bar owners and Jet ski scammers and boat operators.

That will just create further violence .

Killing Thais or beating them near an inch of death is wrong .

Go the way of peace

[TV7]

It's hard to follow - but it sounds like the bro of the owner of AC Bar is still in custody whilst another younger member of the family ( maybe cousin or nephew ) is still on the run. They have found a connection between the Hoe and the family and have detained the one brother of the bar.

In effect, if this is all true, then the whole murder case can be traced back to the bar. ( AC Bar ) which has been claimed to be the case many days ago. The elder members of the family who seem to own the 2 x bars in question initially refused DNA Tests - but have since given samples. Why was this ? The answer in my opinion is quite simple - the DNA samples would / should definitely prove a close match and at least incriminate the family and that is why they refused to give samples initially. This has allowed the younger member of the family to make a run for it.

If there hadn't been the strong pressure from the International Press then I suspect this would have also been swept under the carpet. Unfortunately, for them, the media and social media has exposed the most obvious clues they were trying to overlook - but people pressure has not allowed that. It does seem ( IMO ) that they will now catch the right Perps ........in spite of the significant efforts of the locals to make this problem go away!

I will be telling all my family and friends where not to visit in Thailand. This is the only real justice that they will get !

Regretfully, none of this exposure has been pleasant for the respective families, but unfortunately, I doubt these cases would have been nailed had it not been for such public exposure and finger pointing !

I think the brother has been released awaiting DNA results and has spoken to the media. It is clearly suspicious that the son has gone to Bangkok. But there were two sets of DNA. If the brother is one of the rapists/murderers why didn't he also leave the island....on a fishing boat at the dead of night? Surely the chief of the island who is the owner of the AC bar and is the brother and father of the two suspects could have arranged this? Unless of course there was a third person, perhaps not related, who may also have left the island. Maybe the brother was involved but wasn't one of the two rapists.

[JenniferSG]

Hannah's parents should hire their own investigator to take DNA samples, espicially of the people Sean McAnna exposed.

[ezywalker]

Royal Thai Police will get these people. Times are a chang'n

[media]

Hi how to make sure it if