Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Thailand News and Discussion Forum | ASEANNOW

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

An Over Reaction Of Terms

Featured Replies

I guess every one has heard of the floods in the UK, Tewksbury and Gloucester have been hit, as has Oxfordshire, where I have been affected.

However I have been dismayed by the continual terminology and reference to the The Blitz or the Dunkirk Spirit.

I accept it has been incredibly difficult and the Community Spirit has been outstanding, but surely this continual reference to these incidents are wrong.

Or am I over reacting?

Moss

I agree Moss,

Completely inappropriate references.

They could rather, for want of filler for their news stories (how can they lack material now??)

reference other such incidents around the world, when communities have pulled together due to the devestation of Climate related disasters.

Likening any of this to some of the maddest moments in the ugliest war we've ever seen is just wrong!

Since the aim of the 'shorthand' is to convey the positive responses generated by facing adversity, I'm inclined to the over reaction viewpoint. Since these events are occurring in England it would be problematic to use examples such as the tsunami spirit, would it not?

Regards

The latest news headline from England is "Apocalypse Now"

These floods are not as serious as the 1947 (if I remember correctly) floods in the same areas.

Look back at the archives of the local papers of that time and the photos are almost exactly the same. Now, hiwever, there are better facilities for recovery - although it seems they have not been mobilised efficiently.

I guess every one has heard of the floods in the UK, Tewksbury and Gloucester have been hit, as has Oxfordshire, where I have been affected.

However I have been dismayed by the continual terminology and reference to the The Blitz or the Dunkirk Spirit.

I accept it has been incredibly difficult and the Community Spirit has been outstanding, but surely this continual reference to these incidents are wrong.

Or am I over reacting?

Moss

It's tabloid journalism! What will they use if something really bad happens!

ps this is not to lessen the really bad floods that have effected 1000's of people!

The latest news headline from England is "Apocalypse Now"

Next years headlines will be Apocalypse Now REDUX.

Putting my feelings as to the causes of, and the preparedness for, the floods in Thailand aside; one thing I admire about the Thais is their ability to pick themselves up, get out a mop and bucket, and get on with their lives. No need for hyberbole, as it doesn't garner a greater ratings share or settlement check. It is what it is.

Unfortunately, as we are all aware, these grabs are designed for the sole purpose of selling media with little thought to the morality of it. It reminds me of a decade or so ago when some bright spark came up with the grab that 'X' city had 'lost its innocence' due to 'Y' event. Over the ensuing few years, nearly every major city in the world 'lost its innocence'. In some cases, even entire coutries lost this ethereal quality. Oddly enough, I recall Melbourne having lost its innocence in relation to one incident and then losing it again 12 or so months later over a different incident. (There must have been some 'reconstructive surgery' in the iterim...) I consider it despicable for some two bob sub-editor to sell papers by comparing (albeit disastrous) natural events with wide-scale evil or criminality such as the warmongering of the Axis powers.

Wait a couple of weeks, and then when they announce a hose-pipe ban, feel free to over-react.

Wait a couple of weeks, and then when they announce a hose-pipe ban, feel free to over-react.

:o That's true that is! :D

The great emotive cries about such a sad situation in the "modern" era , are poorly veiled attempts by Government on spin doctoring the situation.

Evoking the WW2 spirit may, if they are lucky, delay the questions about central Government funding for rural England

( note England. The " West Lothian" question remains key ).

Who in power has resigned, over turning down recommendations so implicitly put, that the flood defences in these communities were, and still are, so sadly lacking ? No one.

Wouldn't happen in Scotland where local people have considerably more power over local issues, that's for sure.

What amazed me about the English, from the limited experience I had there, was they could live thirty years next door to someone and never speak a word yet clean out the wardrobe and pantry for the neighbour should his house burn down.

I suppose you could call that the Blitz and Dunkirk spirit.

  • Author
Since these events are occurring in England it would be problematic to use examples such as the tsunami spirit, would it not?

Yes it would, the Tsunami would be a largely irrelevant term, when considering widespread flooding, whether the Tsunami happened in SEA or the western world.

Did the papers of these affected countries refer to the man made disasters of various wars, I would be interested to know.

These floods are not as serious as the 1947 (if I remember correctly) floods in the same areas.

You did remember correctly, they have not reached the '47 peaks, not in Oxfordshire anyway.

I consider it despicable for some two bob sub-editor to sell papers by comparing (albeit disastrous) natural events with wide-scale evil or criminality such as the warmongering of the Axis powers.

:o

Although I wouldn't go as far as to call it despicable, outrageous perhaps and down right over exageration to sell newspapers definately.

Wait a couple of weeks, and then when they announce a hose-pipe ban, feel free to over-react.

:D I wont even complain then, it is almost a given here in the south East.

I suppose you could call that the Blitz and Dunkirk spirit.

Well, this is my contention, I think it is a bad analogy, regarding the misery and courage that these guys went through in contrast and comparison to the flooding.

Community Spirit and common Christianity or any other religious equation is pretty specific and ticks all the boxes, why on Earth bring in the Blitz or Dunkirk.

Moss

Well, this flooding has been going on for ages now and they still build new homes on flood plains. When will they start to take note of the "3rd World Countries" :o who build their houses on stilts?

Knowing our planners though, they'll build brick houses on wooden stilts :D

The latest news headline from England is "Apocalypse Now"

I love the smell of toast in the morning. :o

I think they're saving the phrase 'of biblical proportions' just in case JC does come back to kick some butt.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.