Montreal Erupts in Violent Anti-Israel Protests

[mdr224]

2 minutes ago, proton said:

 

The Arabs did in May 1948 when 5 muslim armies invaded Israel, beaten then and in every other war of destruction they started.

What i meant was, in his reality there was no October 7. And if trump lost, he would be right. There probably would have been no Oct. 7. The left trying to rewrite history

[tmd5855]

1 hour ago, MalcolmB said:

Rubbish. 
The IDF are shooting unarmed people holding up white flags. 
 

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/3-israeli-hostages-tried-only-killed-military-rcna130912

 

They are killing foreign aid workers, women and children and doctors and are bombing ambulances.

 

1982 the Argentinians near "School House" displayed a white flag and two paras approaching got shot.  Not many prisoners taken after that little trick.

Hamas uses human shields without a second thought!!!  Methinks a couple of white bed sheets is fair game

[nobodysfriend]

49 minutes ago, Yagoda said:

Any person who is critical of Israels actions is the enemy of humanity

 

Not only you suggest that Israel and their actions are above all criticism , but anyone criticizing them is an enemy of humanity ...?

There is something seriously wrong with you ...

[dinsdale]

35 minutes ago, MalcolmB said:

As I said, I have only been anti Israel for a year.

I assume your anti Muslim sentiment goes back longer than that so your view on their genocide is skewed.

 

 

Israel’s warfare in Gaza is consistent with the characteristics of genocide, with mass civilian casualties and life-threatening conditions intentionally imposed on Palestinians there, the UN Special Committee to investigate Israeli practices* said in a new reportreleased today.

“Since the beginning of the war, Israeli officials have publicly supported policies that strip Palestinians of the very necessities required to sustain life — food, water, and fuel,” the Committee said. “These statements along with the systematic and unlawful interference of humanitarian aid make clear Israel’s intent to instrumentalise life-saving supplies for political and military gains.”

 

 

https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2024/11/un-special-committee-finds-israels-warfare-methods-gaza-consistent-genocide

You use a UN report to support your position, a report that doesn't mention the close 1,000,000 tonnes of food that Israel has let into Gaza, water, medicines, the polio vaccine program, Hamas stealing food aide, Hamas using civilians as human shields etc. It's a report that pushes the UN narrative.

[Donga]

1 hour ago, thaibeachlovers said:

Apparently you are a committed follower of government ordained news

sources.

17 thousand dead children are not an acceptable "collateral damage" by any civilised nation.

Hamas figures but nevertheless:
1. How many were terrorists, as we know Hamas has many teens in their ranks. What do you do when fired up on by them?
2. How many been killed by missiles from either Hamas or the other mob that misfire, 10 % of them land in Gaza
3.How many were kids were in schools, hospitals surrounded by militants infrastructure and and terrorists firing munitions at IDF
4. How many were nearby militants and their munitions when IDF takes out the terrorists and boom, blamed on IDF

Most importantly, why doesn't Hamas lay down its arms and return the remaining hostages? Because they win the hearts of ignorant Western luvvies by sacrificing civilians. Suggest you look deeper into it as truly... Why would Israel wish to wantonly kill kids? They continually advise civilians to move, and Hamas has been known to try stop them moving.

Just as Hamas raid the supplies coming in, hide stuff in their tunnels, like the barbaric rats that they are. They care <deleted> about Gazans.

[lordgrinz]

Protesters or Terrorists? Masking up and committing violence is not protesting, arrest them all and put them in reeducation camps, with many years of hard labor before gaining their freedom back.

[Yagoda]

Just now, nobodysfriend said:

 

Not only you suggest that Israel and their actions are above all criticism , but anyone criticizing them is an enemy of humanity ...?

There is something seriously wrong with you ...

Glad you outed yourself this early. Of course, all you have is ad hominems

 

Let me sharpen your thoughts a bit, maybe there is hope.

 

On December 7, 1941 the Japanese attacked us. We proceeded to ultimately nuke them and now they are wonderful people. But that was just between us and them. And that is how a war is handled, you beat and beat and destroy and kill everyone in sight and if you want to save your own populace, surrender.

 

And the reason we are so cruel and mean to you Japanese is because you did it to us, first, or will do it to us because that is what you do. Look at China.

 

Now it is a civilizational war for which philosophy will govern the affairs of humanity. The Judeo-Christian Western AMERICAN tradition of tolerance, freedom and progress vs the destructive vision of the revolutionary Left and their allies. 

 

Hamas, on behalf of the evil Iranian regime they kowtow to, and with the approval of the Left's propaganda machine and 5th columns in the freedom loving West started this with us, the US of America, the great Satan, the Great Oppressor of Humanity, etc. They killed Americans. Now IMHO, it sucks to be them.

 

They should be thankful that the Israeli military at least tries to minimize. Far as I am concerned, we should be using our planes to bomb Iran. To kill the snake, cut off the head. 

 

 

 

[mikebike]

23 minutes ago, dinsdale said:

a report that doesn't mention the close 1,000,000 tonnes of food that Israel has let into Gaza

How generous. Is that supposed to balance the 1,000,000 tonnes of ordnance dropped?

[dinsdale]

1 minute ago, mikebike said:

How generous. Is that supposed to balance the 1,000,000 tonnes of ordnance dropped?

Let me take you back to Oct 7. No Oct 7 no ordinance dropped also no civilian shields then way, way, way, way less civilian casualties. Always interesting how these two facts are missing from the "Free Palestine" narrative.

[Social Media]

@MalcolmB if I have to remove any more off topic posts from you, the posts will not be the only things removed.

[mdr224]

@MalcolmB

quite frankly, your defense of muslims considering what theyve done to your country is bizarre and i dont understand it. Do you blame jews for that?

[Yagoda]

1 hour ago, KhunLA said:

What better way to protest violence in mid east, than creating some yourself 

 

Jews ... not a fan of their govt, and matter of fact, hate & loathe them, as scum of the earth IMHO ... think USS Liberty ... nuff said.

 

Jews themselves, the people, only personally know the ones in my family, and pleasant folks.  Only met 2, tourist here in TH, and seemed quite pleasant also, though short chat.  

 

Unless wearing a kippah, or yarmulke, don't know how I'd tell if anyone is Jewish, so can't comment or generalize about them.   If they support the govt's expansion then the puts them on the negative side of things.

 

The older sect, black hats & long curly sideburn-ish thingys, that use to control the diamond street in Philly seemed a little off putting, and never smiled.   Could simply be a defense mechanism, as it was a jewelry district.

 

Terrorist, if not the freedom fighting version, deserve death, immediate with no due process ... IMHO

 

And keep your freedom fighting to military targets, or die miserably.

The diamond guys are Satmars I think, ultra ultra Orthodox, opponents of Israel LOL. In NYC, most of them are armed because they might be carrying a million dollars worth of diamonds they sell on a handshake. They dont like anyone except other Satmars.

[Woke to Sounds of Horking]

54 minutes ago, lordgrinz said:

Protesters or Terrorists? Masking up and committing violence is not protesting, arrest them all and put them in reeducation camps, with many years of hard labor before gaining their freedom back.

This will never happen in Turdeau's Canada, I'm afraid.

[jippytum]

Not suprising when you allow unristricted illegal immigation.  The majority being Muslim men. 

 

 

 

[Woke to Sounds of Horking]

1 hour ago, dinsdale said:

It's a report that pushes the UN narrative.

Though the hardcore Lefty gets a stiffie when they hear "UN," they are perhaps the real enemy to humankind.

[nobodysfriend]

2 minutes ago, jippytum said:

Not suprising when you allow unristricted illegal immigation.  The majority being Muslim men. 

 

 

 

 

Sometimes , I wonder how these western countries welcoming immigrants could have been so naive not to set up a psychological test before granting them asylum . Not all asylum seekers are good people ...many come from war torn countries and have a complete different cultural background . It should have been clear that there will be big problems for some to integrate , assimilate ... Some are good people who just want to escape their hellish countries and work , take care for a family ...

Some just come to exploit their host country , make as much money as possible and cause disturbance and preach hate  .

I am sure that a clever psychological test would have been able to separate the good ones from the bad ones .

Not pass the test , sent back directly . Do not listen to their lies or papers they present . Individually check every asylum seeker for his motivations and psychological background .

 

[Nick Carter icp]

2 hours ago, MalcolmB said:

I think you will find of the Israelis living there now the vast majority are imports or children of imports or children of children of imports.

 

 

   Same as the USA , Canada , Australia &  New Zealand ?

The Muslim protestors in Canada are imports to Canada .

[spidermike007]

3 hours ago, mdr224 said:

You also stated that israel started the war

Please show me the quote where I said that. I never said that, I never even insinuated that they were not compelled to respond. You're just simply (desperately) resorting to making things up and creating fiction out of thin air. At least try to remain credible, try to stick with the facts.

 

I've spent a lifetime opposed to a lot of extreme Israeli government policy and it hasn't been easy as a centrist and moderate American Jew. I'm constantly accused of being anti-Semitic, a Jew hater, anti-American, and the traitor, which is all nonsense. Criticism is the very foundation of democracy, however that's not a concept that Israel agrees with. They are very think skinned and so are alot of American Jews and Trump supporters, and both are very intolerant of criticism. 

[herfiehandbag]

5 hours ago, nobodysfriend said:

 

More than 45000 death , most women and kids , is not an over reaction ?

That is the claim of Hamas.

 

I have been to the scenes of genocide, I have been to, and guarded the mass graves whilst the forensic reams did their work. That was in Former Yugoslavia whilst I was a soldier.

 

Those were graves which contained at most hundreds of bodies at a time. The stench ( stomach turning, we literally vomited for hours on end) let alone the mounds confirmed what lay under the ground. That was hundreds. It, they, can't be hidden.

 

There is nothing like that in Gaza, no burial pits, no mass killings. Do you think that a society like Israel, a democracy with an army largely composed of draftees and civilian reservists, a free press, huge use of social media and a population renowned for and disposed towards arguing and loud demonstrative debate, would, could, commit killings on the scale alleged, and manage to hide it? Gaza is probably at present the most surveilled parcel of land in the world, by satellites and electronic means, do you think killings on that scale could be kept hidden?

 

There is no evidence. Civilians have died, in what is cynically described as " collateral damage" most often because of HAMAS's universal tactics of using them as shields for their activities, not in the numbers HAMAS claim.

 

[pacovl46]

5 hours ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   Its NOT an over reaction at all in Gaza .

Israel are wiping out the group that carried out the Oct 7 terror attack and also trying to free the hostages .

    Why is World wide Anti Semitism acceptable ?

Would it be acceptable for there to be World Wide Anti Muslim protests  because of actions say Saudi Arabia participated in ?

   Attack all Muslims World wide because Saudi bombed Yemen ?

Oh please! Israel has been provoking for long enough. They totally brought this upon themselves and the victim card doesn't fly anymore, so now the whole world sees Israel for what it really is - the oppressor! It's time to take your blinders off! 

[Nick Carter icp]

5 hours ago, MalcolmB said:

There are hundreds of Palestinians, including children being held hostage in prisons without trial, for every one Israeli hostage.

 

   That is a lie .

Palestinians are not being held hostage in Israel .

Seems like you don't know the difference between a hostage and a prisoner 

[GammaGlobulin]

4 hours ago, save the frogs said:

 

Yeah, I was thinking the same thing.

Relocate the entire country out of there. 

There doesn't appear to be any better solutions being proposed. 

 

 

Unfortunately, I am sure that you are correct.

 

The only problem is.....

 

Where?

 

If Global Warming can somehow be sped up....then.....

 

Greenland might be good.

 

The Israelis have vast experience making the desert bloom...and so....

They ought to be able to do exactly the same thing with GreenLand.....

 

Just imagine, would you.....

 

If Israel were moved to Greenland...then.....

Israel could have, once and for all, a safe place, and a secure place.

 

And, in turn, the World could have.....Flowers Everywhere.....Up North....

 

 

 

OR:  Why not the USA??????

 

Most Isralies would love to go to the USA.....  We could create a separate state for Israel in Florida.  I would vote for this!!!!!!!!!

 

And then......

 

The Middle East Problem would finally have its.....  FINAL SOLUTION.....!!!!!!