Expat group launches online petition calling for TM.30 to be scrapped

[ukrules 29698]

23 minutes ago, lkv said:

Greenland has issues handling too many requests?

 

Datacenter: Key-Systems GmbHServer IP: 185.247.61.32

Location: Greenland

City: Nuuk

Nameservers: ns11.globehosting.net, ns12.globehosting.net

 

End of the tracertoute :

Edited July 28, 2019 by ukrules

[Luckysilk 1290]

They better clean up the comment section where a comment posted  IO's are called clowns and a female officer is called a bitch.

 

That won't go over well lol 

[ChipButty 20393]

3 minutes ago, lkv said:

Maybe it would be good if Thai landlords and agents would be signing this, they don't like it any more than foreigners do.

I know a few Thai's who dont like it

[IvorBiggun2 2085]

35 minutes ago, manarak said:

TM 30 is absolute nonsense.

Second only to a TM47. Thais are only bitching because they're getting fines for not doing it.

Edited July 28, 2019 by IvorBiggun2

[simon43 16220]

Even if immigration ignore this petition, they may not be able to ignore the media reports about this petition.

 

I've signed it.... but am leaving Thailand on 8th August

[phuketrichard 4066]

28 minutes ago, Roy Baht said:

No it can't. The Thai government bowing to pressure from foreigners? It would cause loss of face and set a dangerous precedent. If anything, it will make them enforce the law more strictly.

not to mention that your signing a petition that is Against something the thai officials came up with>
nothing good can come of that
wont see my name there>

 

[Travello01 25]

Divided, you can only complain about their new rules.

 

But create a group and you can ask for changes that could be taken seriously.

 

It's what China does and they get results. 

 

If they don't compromise, then get another SEA government on the phone and make an agreement with them to respect your group and in exchange you'll all move there with your money, all of the ingenuity and work ethics that European men bring to the table.

 

You're more valuable than Thailand allows you to be.

Edited July 28, 2019 by Travello01

[wisperone 1648]

If you don't like it, leave.

[Slip 3587]

18 minutes ago, Roy Baht said:

I've been dealing with Thai bureaucrats for 30 years. They will not respond to pressure from foreigners, particularly foreigners living in Thailand.  More likely the strict enforcement will fade away on its own after a year or two.  Remember when you told the head of your favorite taxi company in Pattaya "who you were" and he had zero response? That will be Thai Immigration's response to this petition.

There was some small measure of success from the fb page about illegal searching in Tong Lor some years ago, but the situation has since returned to normal.  They also seem to be mobilising again a little.

[Roy Baht 1179]

3 minutes ago, phuketrichard said:

not to mention that your signing a petition that is Against something the thai officials came up with>
nothing good can come of that
wont see my name there>

Yeah, to be placed on a blacklist is a misfortune. To sign up for one is just carelessness.

[smedly 54082]

I am not going to sign it 

 

The reason - it is too selective and specific and doesn't go far enough, there are many rules/issues introduced by Immigration recently that make absolutely no sense at all.

 

If you are going to go to the trouble of making proposals to Immigration for possible changes then it should encompass a lot more than just this one issue

 

Of these issues many are forcing western expats to rethink their retirement options and Thailand is rapidly dropping down the list

 

I have no issues with sensible changes if Immigration want to introduce them but so far none of these new rules make any sense at all 

 

IMO they need to consider the effect they are having on the people that have complied with the rules rigorously for years and have now been thrown into an environment of expensive money transfer charges that do not always comply with their strict inflexible approach, they also need to consider the strength of the Thai baht and the pressure that is exerting on some that might now have difficulty reaching financial requirements after years of compliance  

[ChipButty 20393]

Send it out in the newsletter to all TV members 

[smedly 54082]

I don't have a problem making suggestion to Thai immigration - I don't think they would take a negative view at all, there may be issues brought to their attention they didn't consider, nobody is saying they are wrong, we are just making suggestions they maybe didn't consider 

[cyril sneer 5492]

not surprised Thailand are strict on immigration

 

they can see what's happened to Londonistan etc. so just trying to protect their country

 

how many people signing that petition have been directly affected by it? very small percentage I expect...

[BestB 14514]

32 minutes ago, Roy Baht said:

I've been dealing with Thai bureaucrats for 30 years. They will not respond to pressure from foreigners, particularly foreigners living in Thailand.  More likely the strict enforcement will fade away on its own after a year or two.  Remember when you told the head of your favorite taxi company in Pattaya "who you were" and he had zero response? That will be Thai Immigration's response to this petition.

In other words you do not have a clue at all, but you think you know what the outcome would be.

 

So i suppose best is not to do anything, just stick to bitching and moaning on anonymous forum?

 

In case of my taxi, he never met me and did not know who or what owner was.

 

And yes, there was no response on the day of driving me, 3 days later when i instructed staff to stop using this company, he did call and did offer apology, not to me directly but via my staff and did offer to drive me free of charge.

 

And yes, Immigration may not offer direct response, they may even respond with some negativity or justifications for their actions, but it does not mean it will not be noted and does not mean they may think twice before making any more changes.

 

You might even be surprised if some embassy's come on board or international media

 

 

[MRToMRT 3045]

I signed it BUT the opening sentence did not represent me, wish we could get over this "married to a Thai" thing, if they are married and working they should get PR.

 

".......representative group of foreign and Thai people living in Thailand with Thai spouses or partners and Thai children. We work here...."

 

Best of luck though as hopefully any press will benefit us all irrespective of personal situation. 

 

 

[BestB 14514]

2 minutes ago, MRToMRT said:

I signed it BUT the opening sentence did not represent me, wish we could get over this "married to a Thai" thing, if they are married and working they should get PR.

 

".......representative group of foreign and Thai people living in Thailand with Thai spouses or partners and Thai children. We work here...."

 

Best of luck though as hopefully any press will benefit us all irrespective of personal situation. 

 

 

Getting PR is not as easy as it sounds even for the married and guys working for decades. Not to mention waiting time and non refundable payment of few hundred thousand.

[Ron jeremy 2478]

Why put up with this Thai bullshit? Leave, many nice countries in the region with currencies worth something.

whats the draw with Thailand anyways?

[Joe Mcseismic 2301]

Unfortunately, the more foreigners push against the TM30 form, the more intransigent the authorities will become.

It's all part of "Thainess", so I don't think much will come of this petition.

[evadgib 17474]

1 hour ago, Myran said:

Nice move, will sign for sure. But they should've let someone proofread the letter beforehand. It's a bit of a mess.

It could do with being a lot shorter IMO & I'd like to have seen realistic references to the problems caused by the exchange rate & perhaps a suggestion to grant PR to married/retired/working foreigners after say 3 years of trouble-free living in the Kingdom.

Just my 2p 

 

Edited July 28, 2019 by evadgib

[evadgib 17474]

13 minutes ago, BestB said:

Getting PR is not as easy as it sounds even for the married and guys working for decades. Not to mention waiting time and non refundable payment of few hundred thousand.

#50

[NCC1701A 57771]

"Hey Big Joke, how are you?"

"I'm fine Big Oud, I hear Expats are signing a petition to ban TM-30"

"Who are Expats? TM-30? Is that new model BMW?"

 

 

Edited July 28, 2019 by NCC1701A

[worgeordie 53991]

I don't know why all the carry on about TM30,last time i did one was

2 years ago when i arrived back from Vietnam,i don't believe you have

to do a TM30 report if you are just travelling within Thailand.

There's no way they are going to scrap it,the big boss of Immigration,

just the other day told us that it had to be done,and it's easy(maybe 

he has not tried his own app,as people are saying it does not work !),

BUT there's no way he's going to back down after saying that,AND it's

a very good money earner, Chiang Mai alone must have taken in millions

issuing 1600 Thb fines.but good luck with the petition.

regards worgeordie

 

[worgeordie 53991]

8 minutes ago, NCC1701A said:

"Hey Big Joke, how are you?"

"I hear Expats are signing a petition to ban TM-30"

"Who are Expats? TM-30? Is that new model BMW?"

 

 

Its now ,Lt-Gen Sompong Chingduang, Big Oud, the one in the front ,who's pulling the strings,

regards worgeordie

[NCC1701A 57771]

yes thank you. you see big oud says hello to big joke and then big joke talks and then big oud responds.

[Traubert 4726]

57 minutes ago, Travello01 said:

It's what China does and they get results. 

 

 

Very true, but it's Chinese nationals petitioning the Chinese Government, with the support of their village/township/city/provincial Councillors.

 

Hand the Chinese Government a list of foreign resident dissidents and it's party time. I do hope the same doesn't apply in Thailand. This should have been discussed at a higher level than Mins Bar.

[NCC1701A 57771]

100 signatures in the last hour alone.

[KMartinHandyman 2424]

100 signatures in the last hour alone.

Let me know when it’s 9,999

[Luckysilk 1290]

Petition our home countries to apply the same rules and track Thai nationals every step.

 

That would get their attention much more than this petition lol

[Joe Mcseismic 2301]

22 minutes ago, NCC1701A said:

100 signatures in the last hour alone.

Yes, the triumph of hope over experience.......