41 minutes ago, JimGant said:

Wrong. CRS reporting is for showing income earned abroad by a resident of a CRS reporting country. Then, the relevant tax authorities can assess taxes.

 

That is actually waht I said

 

1 hour ago, The Cyclist said:

then international transfers ( by some means ) will have to be checked to ensure that tax has been paid, the transfer is tax exempt, or tax has / will be paid in the Country that it has been remitted to.

 

What part of that did you not understand ?
 

It will have to be checked ( by some means ) to ensure that tax has been paid.

 

28 minutes ago, stat said:

spot on correct, as there is not data on international remittanced in crs,

 

Try reading and comprehending. I have never said CrS data contains data on international remittances.

 

I have said that those remittance will have to be checked ( by some means ) to ensure that the appropriate taxes have been paid and that  tax avoidance / evasion is not taking place.

 

CRS being a tool in the fight against tax Avoidance / evasion.

 

Or are you trying to tell me that is a load of poppycock and ithat CRS is really nothing to do with tax avoidance / evasion ?

Go for a quick or long trip outside the country every 175 days and carry on with your occasional transfers from abroad.......... 

23 hours ago, Mike Lister said:

Yes, Thanks, I need to change the wording on para 8 to reflect that there is a special class of visa that is outside the RD rules.

Welcome! Do you still have the link to the source showing the statement in paragraph 4 saying:

 

4. There are also certain types of visa that fall outside of the RD tax code. The LTR visa for example received its tax exempt status by royal decree hence visa holders will not to be assessed for Thai tax and they are specifically excluded from this explanation.

 

If not, can I ask you how you came to know that?

Thanks

On 1/7/2024 at 9:48 AM, jayboy said:

 

Actually he has a perfectly reasonable point.If it is quite clear that if certain income stream/s (probably best ask competent Thai tax adviser to confirm in case of doubt) are not subject to Thai tax, then I see no point in including them in Thai tax return.This complies with Thai requirements and avoids the boring task of sitting down with RD to decide what is taxable and what is not.

 

Like everyone else - I too am unclear how this will all play out.

 

But in regards to your statement which I quoted, in regards income that may be considered non-assessable, there are countries in the world that are interested in all such global income for their citizens or for people who earn income in their country.  And they don't care if they still can't tax such. They want to know.

 

For such countries, ALL GLOBAL income for them is 'assessable' even though clearly no tax is required on such.

 

Case in point: Canada.  I receive interest income from Canada investments, Old Age Security, and Pension.  Accordingly I have to file a Canadian Tax return every year, even thou I spend > 182 days per year in Thailand.  Further, in that Canadian Tax return, Canada wants to know ALL my global income, even thou they can't tax it.  They want to know every last cent earned from outside of Canada.  Why?  Because my global income is what they use to assess my tax rate and hence assess how much they will tax my Canadian Old Age Security, how much they will tax my Canadian pension, and how much they will tax any interest I get from funds in Canada.  In fact, if my global income is too high, they will claw back part or claw back all of my Canadian Old Age Security.  

 

Its my TOTAL GLOBAL INCOME that Canada uses to determine my tax rate for any income from Canada.  And this is as a non-resident to Canada.  If I was a resident to Canada it would be much worse.

 

As it turns out, as a non-resident to Canada, most of my income comes from OUTSIDE of Canada, and as a result I pay MUCH higher taxes on my Canadian Old Age Security, my Canadian pension, and my interest from Canadian savings (than I would if I had no such extra income from outside of Canada). Even thou I am not a Canadian resident, for me to not declare my global income to Canadian authorities would be illegal from Canada's perspective.  And as noted, if I was a resident to Canada it would be worse (as they would tax all income from outside of Canada (if and as governed by any DTA with other countries )).

 

I am NOT saying this is what Thailand may be thinking, but I do note that there are examples of other countries, where such countries require one to state ALL their global income, even thou it can not be taxed and even thou it is covered by a DTA.  So at this stage of us not knowing, possibly Thailand is pondering something like that. And possibly not.  I simply don't know - and I think at this stage we are all just giving this our best guess.

 

My hope is that there will be no requirement to file income tax returns in Thailand for the majority of us resident here (where our income comes from abroad) but at this stage I think we have many educated guesses , but we really don't know yet exact how this will turn out.

 

58 minutes ago, CANSIAM said:

Go for a quick or long trip outside the country every 175 days and carry on with your occasional transfers from abroad.......... 

 

Won't work, as one can only be here for a total of 179 days in a calendar year doing this. That trip would have to be for more than six months...

7 minutes ago, oldcpu said:

My hope is that there will be no requirement to file income tax returns in Thailand for the majority of us resident here (where our income comes from abroad) but at this stage I think we have many educated guesses , but we really don't know yet exact how this will turn out.

 

There probably won't be clarity until March/April 2025, and even then things might change again at will.

1 hour ago, Danderman123 said:

Today, I paid my Thai condo HOA fee of 17,000 baht via WISE transfer from a US bank account (rather from my Thai bank account).

 

I suspect that some here will state that such a transfer is a taxable event.

 

 

 

Yes, it absolutely is a taxable event under the new system. 

43 minutes ago, Metapod said:

 

Yes, it absolutely is a taxable event under the new system. 

Not exactly.

It could be.

It depends on the source of that money, etc.

1 hour ago, StayinThailand2much said:

 

There probably won't be clarity until March/April 2025, and even then things might change again at will.

Thr less clarity the )onger the better for tax consultants and their ilk. Bonanza time!

3 hours ago, StayinThailand2much said:

 

There probably won't be clarity until March/April 2025, and even then things might change again at will.

I could not agree more. Prepare for the worst and be happy if the law is not applied/controlled which is likely IMHO.

2 hours ago, Metapod said:

 

Yes, it absolutely is a taxable event under the new system. 

It is assesable to be precise... It is only taxable if 100% of the amount transfered is profit that arose in 2024

On 1/9/2024 at 9:37 PM, Mike Lister said:

I understand your rationale but it seems unreasonable to provide guidance to others by saying that there is a law you can safely ignore because it's not being enforced at present or there's no associated fine, yet. Everyone needs to know what the law says and make their own decision whether to follow it or not.

Thanks Mike. As someone who has used the 65K+ per month retirement exension modus operandi since year 2007 , I saw this AN post way back in September 2023:

 

 

But no matter how good your intentions, some will always want to play the "How could they ever find out if ..." game.

9 hours ago, Danderman123 said:

Today, I paid my Thai condo HOA fee of 17,000 baht via WISE transfer from a US bank account (rather from my Thai bank account).

 

I suspect that some here will state that such a transfer is a taxable event.

Further guidance from the Revenue Department on Foreign Sourced Income

 

In addition to examples of scenarios in which taxpayers should be exempt from Thai tax on foreign-sourced income, the FAQ also clarifies several points, including: 

 

“Remittance of income into Thailand” is defined as any action in bringing the income sourced abroad into Thailand, including wiring money from a bank account, transferring money via e-banking, or physically carrying cash into Thailand.

 

However, the FAQ did not confirm whether spending money in Thailand from an offshore bank account, credit card, or debit card could be considered a remittance of income into Thailand. 

 

https://www.mazars.co.th/Home/Insights/Doing-Business-in-Thailand/Tax/Revenue-Department-s-guidance-on-foreign-income

11 hours ago, Metapod said:

Yes, it absolutely is a taxable event under the new system. 

 

Presumably that US bank account from which your Wise transfer came from had funds in it pre 1 Jan 2024. And maybe a deposit on 1 Jan 2024 of a private pension, and a deposit of a government pension. So, from which part of this fungible pot of money did your Wise remittance come from?

 

Until they come out and mandate Fifo or Lifo (first in first out, last in last out) -- which they probably won't -- it's up to you. And since GAAP (generally accepted accounting principles) defines fifo and lifo relative to inventories, not remittances -- I'd say you're free to pick and choose what tranche of your bank account funded your Wise transfer. So, if you had sufficient pre-2024 funds in your bank account, or your government pension was large enough, or a combination of the two -- there you have it, as these are non assessable income remittances. With no instructions to the contrary, you can pick and choose the non assessable tranches of your bank account. In this example, you would not pick the private pension tranche, as this is assessable income. Just keep good records, particularly showing the tranches you choose had enough funds to cover your remittance.

 

Anyway, this is my guess. All part of what's going to necessarily be a self-assessment drill.

 

 

4 hours ago, jerrymahoney said:

However, the FAQ did not confirm whether spending money in Thailand from an offshore bank account, credit card, or debit card could be considered a remittance of income into Thailand. 

 

Presumably your plastic sucks money from your bank account; just make sure this account had sufficient pre-2024 deposits, plus gov't pension and social security deposits, going forward (for Yanks, anyway). Then, same advice as the above posting.

33 minutes ago, JimGant said:

 

Presumably your plastic sucks money from your bank account; just make sure this account had sufficient pre-2024 deposits, plus gov't pension and social security deposits, going forward (for Yanks, anyway). Then, same advice as the above posting.

All my income that is remitted to Thailand is current monthly. There are no deposits other than when goes through and out every month. I keep some small cash cushion for emergencies.

13 hours ago, jerrymahoney said:

Further guidance from the Revenue Department on Foreign Sourced Income

 

In addition to examples of scenarios in which taxpayers should be exempt from Thai tax on foreign-sourced income, the FAQ also clarifies several points, including: 

 

“Remittance of income into Thailand” is defined as any action in bringing the income sourced abroad into Thailand, including wiring money from a bank account, transferring money via e-banking, or physically carrying cash into Thailand.

 

However, the FAQ did not confirm whether spending money in Thailand from an offshore bank account, credit card, or debit card could be considered a remittance of income into Thailand. 

 

https://www.mazars.co.th/Home/Insights/Doing-Business-in-Thailand/Tax/Revenue-Departmentr it's equivalent in Amy other c

 

This thread has become too unwieldy and confused to be of real value any longer. It is too long for most posters to scroll through to find pertinent information and will be closed.

 

A new thread will be opened shortly, designed to complete the Simple Guide to Personal Taxation which remains incomplete. The objective there is to construct a single document that will benefit ALL members, recording all the things that are known and listing the things that are unknown or unclear. The purpose is so that everyone, readers and contributors alike, achieve a similar understanding so that some of the fear and anxiety of the unknown, is removed.  

 

If anyone wishes to start a discussion about CRS or any other aspect of taxation, please open a dedicated thread that focuses on just that topic but please be clear what the scope is.Please keep it within the appropriate forum

On 1/10/2024 at 9:58 PM, John207 said:

Welcome! Do you still have the link to the source showing the statement in paragraph 4 saying:

 

4. There are also certain types of visa that fall outside of the RD tax code. The LTR visa for example received its tax exempt status by royal decree hence visa holders will not to be assessed for Thai tax and they are specifically excluded from this explanation.

 

If not, can I ask you how you came to know that?

Thanks

What about Thai elite visa ?

A post commenting on moderation contravening our Community Standards has been removed:

• If you would like to discuss moderation contact Support

10 hours ago, kiever said:

What about Thai elite visa ?

https://www.siam-legal.com/thai-elite-visa/legal-applications-on-the-new-thai-tax-law-and-thailand-elite-visa-holders/

10 hours ago, Mike Lister said:

https://www.siam-legal.com/thai-elite-visa/legal-applications-on-the-new-thai-tax-law-and-thailand-elite-visa-holders/

 

They seem to be suggesting the day counts for Tax they way immigration count, any second in the local time calendar day as a full day, rather than the at the midnight end of the day convention ... + 1 tax days for the 21:00 flight +2 tax days if its overbooked and they put you on the 02:00hrs outbound...

3 hours ago, UKresonant said:

 

They seem to be suggesting the day counts for Tax they way immigration count, any second in the local time calendar day as a full day, rather than the at the midnight end of the day convention ... + 1 tax days for the 21:00 flight +2 tax days if its overbooked and they put you on the 02:00hrs outbound...

I read that as being from the date stamp on departure to the date stamp on arrival, which is manageable to some degree since you would need to go airside before midnight for most long hauls. The problem is that the same day could count as being resident in two different countries, which can add up over the year.

On 1/11/2024 at 4:24 PM, Mike Lister said:

This thread has become too unwieldy and confused to be of real value any longer. It is too long for most posters to scroll through to find pertinent information and will be closed.

 

A new thread will be opened shortly, designed to complete the Simple Guide to Personal Taxation which remains incomplete. The objective there is to construct a single document that will benefit ALL members, recording all the things that are known and listing the things that are unknown or unclear. The purpose is so that everyone, readers and contributors alike, achieve a similar understanding so that some of the fear and anxiety of the unknown, is removed.  

 

If anyone wishes to start a discussion about CRS or any other aspect of taxation, please open a dedicated thread that focuses on just that topic but please be clear what the scope is.Please keep it within the appropriate forum

 

Only 211 pages....Come on we can do 500 pages....I am a believer...

11 minutes ago, redwood1 said:

 

Only 211 pages....Come on we can do 500 pages....I am a believer...

Please, be my guest.

 

Make no mistake, whilst the thread is very long, there is a lot of seriously helpful information in there, finding it is not always easy but it's worth sifting through for many and asking questions of those who are knowledgeable about CRS and related topics. Meanwhile, for those with simpler needs, the Simple Tax Guide Thread awaits.

i settle my finances here already here in 2003 by reducing my dependence on thailand  , at this time taxsin was here introducing -a 0% intrest for foreigners at the banks ( at this time was 5% for thais)- not allowing international transfers for foreigners without premission of BOT- and cancelled the 3mb investmnet visa

today i very happy about Mr taxsins crazy ambitioous plan ( bcs today to do it like i done is nearly impossible due to regulations)  , it avoid me many problems , incl now , and makes me sleep much better

 

..but for all dont worry, nothing here is sure ,and some of their fantastic ideas, going to  none existent very quick , like it was in 2003 ( all revoked in 2004 already like 0 policy and transfers)

On 1/11/2024 at 4:24 PM, Mike Lister said:

This thread has become too unwieldy and confused to be of real value any longer. It is too long for most posters to scroll through to find pertinent information and will be closed.

 

A new thread will be opened shortly, designed to complete the Simple Guide to Personal Taxation which remains incomplete. The objective there is to construct a single document that will benefit ALL members, recording all the things that are known and listing the things that are unknown or unclear. The purpose is so that everyone, readers and contributors alike, achieve a similar understanding so that some of the fear and anxiety of the unknown, is removed.  

 

If anyone wishes to start a discussion about CRS or any other aspect of taxation, please open a dedicated thread that focuses on just that topic but please be clear what the scope is.Please keep it within the appropriate forum

 

I disagree that the thread should be closed.  If people find it no longer useful or interesting, they will stop using it and it will die of natural causes. The same thing has been said about the PR and citizenship threads on occasion but both are now nearly 20 years old and still going strong. Members who are interested in the tax guide thread will find their own way there.

2 hours ago, Dogmatix said:

 

I disagree that the thread should be closed.  If people find it no longer useful or interesting, they will stop using it and it will die of natural causes. The same thing has been said about the PR and citizenship threads on occasion but both are now nearly 20 years old and still going strong. Members who are interested in the tax guide thread will find their own way there.

The thread was never closed. It was locked for a couple of days in order for the more focused thread on tax to achieve traction, the thread was subsequently unlocked and has been for some time.

4 hours ago, Dogmatix said:

 

I disagree that the thread should be closed.  If people find it no longer useful or interesting, they will stop using it and it will die of natural causes. The same thing has been said about the PR and citizenship threads on occasion but both are now nearly 20 years old and still going strong. Members who are interested in the tax guide thread will find their own way there.

I agree with you 100%.

 

Speaking softly, politely, and gently I think a Tax Guide thread could perhaps give people a false sense of security in following its words - as it seems to be written by nontax professionals who are not native speakers of Thai (or near-native speakers). It also could open the forum up to legal issues if someone follows it and has problems...

 

Then again many people may prefer a tax guide thread as it is... and I am all for freedom of speech.

 

I love the Voltaire quote:

 

"I may detest what you have to say but I will die for your right to say it..."

 

 

On 1/14/2024 at 3:21 AM, Mike Lister said:

I read that as being from the date stamp on departure to the date stamp on arrival, which is manageable to some degree since you would need to go airside before midnight for most long hauls. The problem is that the same day could count as being resident in two different countries, which can add up over the year.

Some trivia.....

 

Just checked the five next trips someone has booked ( of which two of the the outbound flights are the same as ours were, about 6 months ago, and we ended up a few minutes past midnight, on checking the departure stamps, even though we were hurrying as that channel was perhaps closing at midnight).

So with Thailand counting any part of the day as a full day for Tax Purposes, and UK using midnight to count the day.

 

Most probably, even 

1. O/B Thailand = Yes   UK=Yes (Same Calendar Day)

Counted both places on 1 day

2. I/B Dep UK=No 1Day, Next Day Arrival Thailand = Yes

Not counted 1 day + counted 1 Day

3. O/B Thailand = Yes, Next Day Arrival UK =Yes

1 Day + 1 Day

4. I/B Dep UK=No 1Day, Next Day Arrival Thailand = Yes

Not counted 1 day + counted 1 Day

5. O/B Thailand = Yes   UK=Yes (Same Calendar Day)

Counted both places on 1 day.

 

So on the two counting conventions; of 8 dates, Thailand 5 days,  UK 3 days, Nowhere 2 days (UK departures), counted for Tax presence. 5 / 3 to Thailand. (if that elite  article is correct https://www.siam-legal.com/thai-elite-visa/legal-applications-on-the-new-thai-tax-law-and-thailand-elite-visa-holders/ )

Random chance of bookings could catch someone out, if pushing the 179 days tax non-residence to the edge 

 

[I remember Going through DMK about twenty years ago, and one of our family group got a little stamp in their passport, presumably overstay of 20mins, at the other desk. No one else got one we were all trying to get to the gate for the departure. But not knowing we had taken the 29 and a half days in time to be under 30 Days! oops, but only one jobsworth on duty]