Advisor Urges Public Not to Criticise PM Paetongtarn for using iPad

[webfact]

 

Jirayu Huangsap, an advisor to the Prime Minister, has asked the public to refrain from criticizing the Prime Minister for using an iPad to read speeches.

 

He clarified that while the Prime Minister often speaks without a script, international forums require accuracy. At these global events, world leaders must adhere closely to prepared statements, as such agreements cannot be altered in the way impromptu speeches might be.

 

Jirayu emphasized that Thailand is stepping onto the world stage, and he urged Thais to show support for their leader.

 

Jirayu addressed recent criticisms surrounding the Prime Minister’s use of an iPad during the recent Asia Cooperation Dialogue (ACD) summit.

He explained that the Prime Minister was following protocol typical for international agreements, where every word must be carefully read to maintain accuracy. According to Jirayu, this approach is necessary because international statements carry a weight that general speeches do not.

 

“Globally, citizens are more concerned about the substance and benefits of their leaders' actions rather than the medium they use to communicate," Jirayu said.

 

He stressed that these actions ultimately contribute to the country’s progress on an international level.

 

Jirayu also pointed out that the Prime Minister is comfortable speaking off-the-cuff at domestic events, but for significant global forums, prepared remarks are essential. He likened this to government policy announcements, where adherence to exact wording is required.

 

Jirayu concluded by urging the public to support the Prime Minister and work together to help Thailand advance on the world stage.

 

Picture courtesy: TNA

 

-- 2024-10-07

 

[Bday Prang]

Is he using his hands to hide a smirk or his brown tongue?

[OneMoreFarang]

Nobody expects from her to know what she is talking about. We should be happy that she is able to read (what her father wrote for her).

[Tropicalevo]

What on earth is the complaint here?

That the PM is using a prompt or that she is using an iPad.

I realise that using an iPad shows poor taste, but it is a personal preference.

All world leaders use prompts.

[lordgrinz]

So she has a direct link to Papa from wherever she is? Well, that's convenient, he can even control her speeches now. Daddy thought of everything! 😉 

[webfact]

Paetongtarn defends iPad use at Qatar summit amid criticism
by Ryan Turner 

 

Image: Reuters

Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra addressed criticisms after a photograph of her reading from an iPad at her first international summit in Qatar circulated on social media. The image, taken last week, raised questions about the 38 year old’s leadership abilities.

 

Responding on Instagram, Paetongtarn addressed a netizen who posted the photos and described them as embarrassing for Thailand. The netizen also unfavourably compared her to former Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha. In her statement, Paetongtarn urged that all leaders across the globe use scripts.

 

“Thank you for the advice. Please watch the news and read more information. During meetings like these, leaders across the world read scripts. It’s a commitment. It must be recorded. Everyone reads scripts, from sheikhs to ministers,

“Keep an open mind, and you’ll be happier.”

In an Instagram story, Paetongtarn reiterated her preparation for the event.

 

“It’s not like I went without doing my homework. It was an international event in which it would be inappropriate to break the norm.”

Noppadon Pattama, Pheu Thai Party list MP and former foreign affairs minister defended Paetongtarn, stating that reading from a script is standard practice in international meetings. He suggested that the criticism was unwarranted and urged critics to focus on the substance of her remarks instead.

 

Veteran journalist Suthichai Yoon also commented on the situation. In a post made on X (Twitter), he questioned why was her script written in English.

 

“Why read from an iPad? Why was it in English? Why didn’t the Foreign Affairs Ministry prepare an interpreter for her? Didn’t the Iranian president speak in his own language?”

 

Suthichai argued that Paetongtarn needs ‘special care’ due to her inexperience in international meetings, blaming the foreign affairs ministry for not adequately preparing her for the event, reported Bangkok Post.

The debate about Paetongtarn’s iPad underscores a broader conversation about modern diplomatic norms and expectations. The tool used by many leaders for its convenience and efficiency became a focal point for critics rather than the significance of her participation in the summit.

 

Source: The Thaiger 

-- 2024-10-07

 

 

[sscc]

1/  Better speaking in Thailand official language :  Thai

2/  Better speaking according to the written script in international forum.  ( Not as ignorance type suggested her to talk without script,  making mistakes and regretting afterwards ) 

3    iPAD  or Samsung PAD or  paper or card  are all fine.  ( there is no Thai PAD ) 

   

[lordgrinz]

38 minutes ago, webfact said:

The debate about Paetongtarn’s iPad underscores a broader conversation about modern diplomatic norms and expectations. The tool used by many leaders for its convenience and efficiency became a focal point for critics rather than the significance of her participation in the summit.

 

Yeah, I'd like to see them removed, let leaders say what they really mean, not what was written by someone else.

[Dan O]

1 hour ago, Tropicalevo said:

What on earth is the complaint here?

That the PM is using a prompt or that she is using an iPad.

I realise that using an iPad shows poor taste, but it is a personal preference.

All world leaders use prompts.

The complaint was that she is playing on her IPad like a teenager and not using it for her mission visit. 

[Bday Prang]

43 minutes ago, Dan O said:

The complaint was that she is playing on her IPad like a teenager and not using it for her mission visit. 

Indeed  I imagine she is as addicted to "the face"  as the rest of them

[Bday Prang]

Maybe it has an app that enables "daddy" to do the actual talking but  sound just like her

[chiman]

maybe it should have been etched into a stone tablet? 

[jippytum]

reading instructions via Line.

From guess who. Oh it's Daddy

[BarraMarra]

My god so what if she is using an i-pad its called moving with the times or would the Thai's still prefer white chalk and a blackboard.

[Taboo2]

Am I high on weed, or is this a real news worthy issue?

[Marco51]

3 hours ago, webfact said:

 

Jirayu Huangsap, an advisor to the Prime Minister, has asked the public to refrain from criticizing the Prime Minister for using an iPad to read speeches.

 

He clarified that while the Prime Minister often speaks without a script, international forums require accuracy. At these global events, world leaders must adhere closely to prepared statements, as such agreements cannot be altered in the way impromptu speeches might be.

 

Jirayu emphasized that Thailand is stepping onto the world stage, and he urged Thais to show support for their leader.

 

Jirayu addressed recent criticisms surrounding the Prime Minister’s use of an iPad during the recent Asia Cooperation Dialogue (ACD) summit.

He explained that the Prime Minister was following protocol typical for international agreements, where every word must be carefully read to maintain accuracy. According to Jirayu, this approach is necessary because international statements carry a weight that general speeches do not.

 

“Globally, citizens are more concerned about the substance and benefits of their leaders' actions rather than the medium they use to communicate," Jirayu said.

 

He stressed that these actions ultimately contribute to the country’s progress on an international level.

 

Jirayu also pointed out that the Prime Minister is comfortable speaking off-the-cuff at domestic events, but for significant global forums, prepared remarks are essential. He likened this to government policy announcements, where adherence to exact wording is required.

 

Jirayu concluded by urging the public to support the Prime Minister and work together to help Thailand advance on the world stage.

 

Picture courtesy: TNA

 

-- 2024-10-07

 

 

[john donson]

what about the actual speech? was it in thaiglish?  I would want to have a laugh at least once a day...

[ThaiFelix]

Probably translated into stick diagrams for clarity.

[hotchilli]

3 hours ago, webfact said:

He clarified that while the Prime Minister often speaks without a script, international forums require accuracy. At these global events, world leaders must adhere closely to prepared statements

Can't screw up daddy's words.

[MCos]

She’s not talking to a bunch of people in a cafe or whatever 

Making a speech to a gathering of world leaders is a serious business and it’s common to use a prompt. 
Furthermore

Shes inexperienced at speaking at these important occasions and it’s important she doesn’t go off track 

[blazes]

My wife drew my attention to the Thai version of this "story."  In that story she was shown reading from her iPad while the President of Iran was sitting to her left and waiting patiently for.... whatever.

 

I confess I know next to nothing about Thailand's relations with Iran, but I'd certainly like to know what she actually said to the man ultimately responsible for the terrorism committed all over the Middle East.  Have a nice day, sir?  We love  your oil?

[BarraMarra]

lets not forget the previous PM Invited Lavrov to Thailand with hand shakes all around. 

[Geoffggi]

3 hours ago, webfact said:

Suthichai argued that Paetongtarn needs ‘special care’ due to her inexperience in international meetings

Thia could also be translated into lack of experience much like the reason why the move forward party was rejected or was the reason wrong family ................LOL

[Dave1954]

And all those critics are articulate enough to get up and do an extremely important speech in front of an international audience without a script, ''I think not'' go away you morons and get a life

[Luuk Chaai]

4 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

Nobody expects from her to know what she is talking about. We should be happy that she is able to read (what her father wrote for her).

She should borrow a pre-programmed teleprompter from Kamala.  Cluck cluck cluck cluck cluck haaaaaaa haaaaa haaaa

[dinsdale]

This whole thing is because of  "a netizen" who obviously has the intellectual development of a toddler. Absurd and should never get any attention. I hate PTP and I hate the royalist military establishment but surely this is a non-story.

[ericbj]

 

Incomprehensible why, at an important international event, she should be expected to blather whatever thoughts may enter her head on the spur of the moment.

Notes of a prepared speech, whether anything from brief mnemonics to full text, are essential in such instances for those without an infallible, encyclopaedic memory.

English still tends to be regarded as THE international medium of communication.  Not yet displaced by Mandarin.

[Slocum]

4 hours ago, webfact said:

 

Jirayu Huangsap, an advisor to the Prime Minister, has asked the public to refrain from criticizing the Prime Minister for using an iPad to read speeches.

 

He clarified that while the Prime Minister often speaks without a script, international forums require accuracy. At these global events, world leaders must adhere closely to prepared statements, as such agreements cannot be altered in the way impromptu speeches might be.

 

Jirayu emphasized that Thailand is stepping onto the world stage, and he urged Thais to show support for their leader.

 

Jirayu addressed recent criticisms surrounding the Prime Minister’s use of an iPad during the recent Asia Cooperation Dialogue (ACD) summit.

 

He explained that the Prime Minister was following protocol typical for international agreements, where every word must be carefully read to maintain accuracy. According to Jirayu, this approach is necessary because international statements carry a weight that general speeches do not.

 

“Globally, citizens are more concerned about the substance and benefits of their leaders' actions rather than the medium they use to communicate," Jirayu said.

 

He stressed that these actions ultimately contribute to the country’s progress on an international level.

 

Jirayu also pointed out that the Prime Minister is comfortable speaking off-the-cuff at domestic events, but for significant global forums, prepared remarks are essential. He likened this to government policy announcements, where adherence to exact wording is required.

 

Jirayu concluded by urging the public to support the Prime Minister and work together to help Thailand advance on the world stage.

 

Picture courtesy: TNA

 

-- 2024-10-07

 

She is wise to use a ipad...so little or no mistakes are made..she is not a demi god....better than the old Fool or idiot out there speaks and famble most of the time... That's why he lasted only 1 term...had to Bow out and make way for V.P....

[dinsdale]

NON-STORY made up by an idiot and being pushed by the press. Should be ashamed. Everyone uses notes. Well not everyone, that's true. Idiots don't. Notes are notes though and needed to keep on point. Hence bullet points. Reading verbatim is not a good look and you'll look like an idiot. Scripts and teleprompters are definitely not ideal but if that's the intellectual capacity of the orator then it is what it is. IMO as a leader you need to know what your talking about. This is an example and you should YT it. (censorship here is still very active so not sure I can post it). KAMALA: "32 day's, 32 days, 32 days........................................  when the teleprompter glitched. Gold. She's an idiot.

[AustinRacing]

Very risky. What if the iPad blew up? On a related matter, the guy implies domestic speeches carry less weight. No?