The fatal shooting of Alex Pretti by Border Patrol agents in Minneapolis has sparked intense debate over federal response tactics during protests. Pretti, a 37-year-old ICU nurse, was shot and killed after being pinned down on a cold street. A video shows agents retrieving a gun from Pretti's holster before firing point-blank, leaving him dead on the sidewalk.

Opinions among policing experts are sharply divided. Some claim the shooting amounts to "murder," while others withhold judgment pending clarification on the threat perceived by the officer who fired. Chuck Wexler of the Police Executive Research Forum stresses the urgent need to uncover why agents felt it necessary to use lethal force.

This incident has resurfaced concerns about whether immigration enforcement officers are sufficiently trained for protest scenarios. Former Boston police commander Tom Nolan criticized the prevailing use of heavy-handed tactics by federal agents, showcasing a broader pattern of inadequacy in protests.

The issue extends beyond Minneapolis. Jason Houser, a former DHS counterterrorism official, noted the lack of centralized command and poor coordination with local law enforcement. He emphasized that agents are often thrust into high-stress situations without adequate preparation, which compromises their ability to handle such encounters safely.

Despite requests for comment, DHS has remained silent, though officials have previously stated their aim to de-escalate tensions as they navigate President Trump’s aggressive immigration policies. Gregory Bovino, Border Patrol commander, stated that the involved agent, with eight years of service, had extensive training as a range safety officer.

The confrontation began as Pretti filmed officers and intervened for a person on the ground. Experts like criminologist Tod Burke and use-of-force witness Mickie McComb argue that, once disarmed, there was no longer a justification for deadly force. McComb insists, “If you disarm him and he’s not reaching for a weapon, you can’t use deadly force.”

David Klinger, a former police officer, highlighted the complex dynamics officers face. He noted, “This was tense, this was uncertain, this was rapidly evolving.” His comments underscore the chaotic nature of such incidents and the need for careful examination of how decisions were made.

The controversy has led to renewed calls for rigorous investigation. The unusual decision for DHS to lead the investigation, typically falling under FBI jurisdiction, has added to the complexity, especially after Minnesota state investigators faced barriers accessing the scene with a warrant.

As the situation unfolds, the case of Alex Pretti highlights systemic issues within federal enforcement during protests. The broader implications reverberate across national discussions about police practices and accountability, emphasizing the need for reform and better training standards.

Ultimately, understanding the decisions made during Pretti’s confrontation and addressing identified shortcomings could prevent future tragedies and build trust in law enforcement.

Key Takeaways:

• Experts clash over labeling Pretti’s shooting as "murder" or justified!

• Training gaps and coordination failures spotlighted in federal actions!

• Calls grow for thorough investigation and reform in enforcement tactics!

  

Adapted by ASEAN Now from Source 2026-01-26

 

 

View full article

We need leadership and all we get are TACOS

ICE is essentially Trump's armed thuds whose orders are to eliminate any "foreigners" (including Native Americans, from recent reports), non-heterosexuals, non-Christians, etc. and anyone who challenges Trump and his henchmen/women.

Fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, Stalinist Russia, Mao's Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution, Pol Pot's Year Zero, etc., which resulted in the deaths of many hundreds of millions of people, all come to mind as examples of Trump's MAGA purges.

That video gave a very clear reconstruction of what happened.

Meanwhile, ICE is investigating itself!

One further point, if one of the shooters was a highly trained firearms instructor, and having watched how 10 rounds were loosed in quick succession into a body in a melée - don't go anywhere near a range he is running!

The news item hits on a critical point about inadequate training and systemic failures, but it stops at the symptom.

As I see it, the root cause of the confrontations, like those involving Renée Good and Alex Pretti isn't just how enforcement is carried out, but what is being enforced.

The protestors aren't "urban terrorists"; they're ordinary citizens driven to desperation by inhumane federal policies.

The Trump administration's blanket approach that labels all undocumented individuals as vicious criminals (and prioritizing mass, forcible removals), creates a tinderbox. It forces law enforcement into impossible, adversarial situations and demonizes entire communities.

Also, when state investigators with a warrant are barred from a scene by federal actors, it shows this isn't just about procedure. It's about a policy that operates in the shadows, resistant to oversight and divorced from local realities.

The real reform needed isn't just better de-escalation training (though that's vital). It's a complete rethink of a racist and counterproductive immigration policy.

The US should consider a balanced, skill-based system that makes allowances. Who's beng deporting? A potential nurse, a future engineer, a contributor to US society? A more humane policy that assesses individuals on their skills and potential to contribute to the US.

Paradoxically, if Trump moved to such a balanced approach, he would likely expand his support base. It would show pragmatic leadership, separate him from the hardline fringe, and address a major source of division in the US today.

The tragedy highlighted in Minnesota is a direct result of a failed policy. You can't train our way out of a problem created by poor choices. You need to change the choice!

The Trump adminstration officials and employees are temporarily barred from destroying or altering evidence relating to the fatal shooting of Alex Pretti by federal agents by order from a Trump appointed judge. Shocking that a judge will issue such order which is more often relates to a criminal organization.

5 hours ago, JimHuaHin said:

ICE is essentially Trump's armed thuds whose orders are to eliminate any "foreigners" (including Native Americans, from recent reports), non-heterosexuals, non-Christians, etc. and anyone who challenges Trump and his henchmen/women.

Fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, Stalinist Russia, Mao's Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution, Pol Pot's Year Zero, etc., which resulted in the deaths of many hundreds of millions of people, all come to mind as examples of Trump's MAGA purges.

Actually, the underlying strategy is less to do with the removal of millions of foreign 'criminals' than it is to terrorize the rest of the population and anyone who rejects Trump.

Cops murder USA citizens all the time.

~500/yr.

nuttin' gnu.

22 hours ago, Jim Waldron said:

The real reform needed isn't just better de-escalation training (though that's vital). It's a complete rethink of a racist and counterproductive immigration policy.

The US should consider a balanced, skill-based system that makes allowances. Who's beng deporting? A potential nurse, a future engineer, a contributor to US society? A more humane policy that assesses individuals on their skills and potential to contribute to the US.

Paradoxically, if Trump moved to such a balanced approach, he would likely expand his support base. It would show pragmatic leadership, separate him from the hardline fringe, and address a major source of division in the US today.

I reckon this is spot on. Successive governments of both colours have "allowed" (through inaction) illegal migrant workers to be employed on farms during the harvest (just one example). This is a massive failure, one of many by parties of both colours. This isn't just a US thing it must be said. The US is perfectly capable of stopping illegals coming into the country (well done Mr Trump). But why is it incapable of having a reasonable visa system that attracts migrant temporary staff when it is needed, and when the local population can't support the need? I can make similar comment on nurses, mechanics and any other trade or industry where the US population can't or won't provide suitable resource.

Dear USA this is fixable. Dear Europe; you are useless too!

as they say in Thailand, if FARANG would have stayed at home (or in his lane, in the ER)

instead of being an agitator, bringing a gun to a protest

he would still be alive

I read that the gun of the dead dude went off by itself, sig p320 or something, famous to go off by itself, known as a bad weapon

FAFO and darwin award recipient, many more will follow before

the paid protesters interfering with officers doing their job, might learn their lesson

but these are brainless zombies

imagine a police officer coming to interfere when Alex was doing his ER work, where he should have remained

19 hours ago, papa al said:

Cops murder USA citizens all the time.

~500/yr.

nuttin' gnu.

Nothing to do with this case.........

On 1/28/2026 at 3:43 AM, Jimbolkb said:

the paid protesters

Surely there must be a money trail?

President Donald Trump's immigration forces stunned observers on Wednesday after they drew their weapons on an elderly couple in a church parking lot in Minneapolis.

The retired couple spoke with journalists outside the church on Wednesday, where Trump's immigration agents were trying to catch members of the congregation as they left the building. The operation happened just days after the federal government arrested protesters who attended a church service in St. Paul and questioned one of the pastors over his ties to the local Immigration and Customs Enforcement field office.

Federal agents stand, following an incident where a civilian's car was hit by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, after an ICE agent fatally shot Renee Nicole Good, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S., January 12, 2026. REUTERS/Tim Evans

"ICE agents who had the audacity to come and try to arrest and kidnap people leaving church on a Sunday morning," the man remembered. "We turned into a parking lot and were greeted by approximately four unmarked ice vehicles with agents who immediately stopped us and pointed semi-automatic weapons in our face, asked us to roll down the windows, threatened us multiple times with arrest."

"They had the professional demeanor of criminals," the man added.

Trump's ICE shocks observers by drawing guns on retired couple

His gun was first removed and then he was shot 10 times. That's life in prison, even the death penalty.

3 minutes ago, Purdey said:

His gun was first removed and then he was shot 10 times. That's life in prison, even the death penalty.

DHS director revealed that the nurse was a dangerous armed terrorist.

So no prob executing him..