Jump to content

Canadian Sisters Died In Thailand From Drinking Cocktail That Contained Insect Repellent


webfact

Recommended Posts

People drink insect repellent and munched up mozzie coils?

By God, what a sheltered existence I've been living. I suppose the question then is did these ladies know what they were drinking?

I have to confess it's a new one on me as well. Then again I'm 58 I've never smoked or taken illegal drugs apart from one time without my knowledge and I don't drink much alcohol . Although I would have said that I was unadventurous with food I do now try things in Thailand which I wouldn't have been certain were edible before. I rely on my girlfriend's advice on this and whether she eats it as well. I don't always know for certain all the ingredients in the food and drink I consume.

I'm puzzled by the use of the word "overdose" in the article. Is there a recommended dosage for DEET taken internally? Should it be taken internally at all?

RIP to the girls and condolences to their family and friends.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 399
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

After reading through these 50 posts. It seems to me this the Thai authorities reported theory achieved what they wanted. A majority of these posts accept the these girls died by accidental overdose of deet. In my opinion, even though tragic, makes everybody feel better about what the cause of these deaths. Basically it puts the blame on an activity that many youth do in Thailand, and even though these girls did not do this intentional, and was an accident. (BS)

To me this stinks more of a cover up than before. What about all the other mysterious, unexplained deaths in Chaing Mai? The Canadian sisters deaths where of identical symptoms of these other deaths.

Or did all the people in Chaing Mai die of this cocktail? I suppose it possible an elderly couple in their 70's was out on the town ripping ass and got ahold of one of these deadly cocktails. But not likely.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

who the hell is writing these reports,police hunt for 2 portuguese who where drinking with the sisters,now they say it was 2 brazilians.

An honest error of Judgement the National language of Brazil is Portuguese.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Results of the autopsy at a Bangkok hospital have not been publicly released, but they were shown to reporters for CBC's French-language news network.

I guess it's public now, yes?

According to the report, 20-year-old Audrey and Noémi Bélanger, 25, had DEET in their bodies that they had ingested.

Only DEET?

Though the chemical is a potentially neurotoxic mosquito repellent, it is used as an ingredient in a euphoria-inducing cocktail that is popular among youth in Thailand. The drink contains cough syrup, Coke, DEET and ground up kratom leaves, which are a mild narcotic indigenous to Thailand.

So this is implying that these girls were hanging out with youth in Thailand?

It is thought that an overdose of DEET was accidentally mixed into the young women's drinks.

How the <deleted> is it an accident to mix poison into a drink? Is the "thinker" following the lines that these two were hanging out with Thailand's youth?

They had just arrived on the Thai island of Phi Phi and were last seen partying with two Brazilian friends in the early morning of June 13.

And we are now suggesting that "partying" foreigners, who hang out with Brazilians, mix DEET in their drinks, or that bartenders regularly keep DEET in their inventory, stored in sleek looking decanters?

Forty-eight hours later, when staff at their hotel hadn't seen them emerge from their room, a receptionist called police.

Yeah right. I am sure that hotel staff regularly contact the police when they do not see a farang emerge from anything I'll try contacting the police the next time I do not see a Thai emerge from a room to see what happens.

More idiotic reporting using information gathered from Thais who "think". As this is not the norm, I suspect foul play and possibly homicide, but we'll never know if we ask what the Thais "think", will we?

Rest in peace to Audrey and Noémi

Edited by cup-O-coffee
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

After reading through these 50 posts. It seems to me this the Thai authorities reported theory achieved what they wanted. A majority of these posts accept the these girls died by accidental overdose of deet. In my opinion, even though tragic, makes everybody feel better about what the cause of these deaths. Basically it puts the blame on an activity that many youth do in Thailand, and even though these girls did not do this intentional, and was an accident. (BS)

To me this stinks more of a cover up than before. What about all the other mysterious, unexplained deaths in Chaing Mai? The Canadian sisters deaths where of identical symptoms of these other deaths.

Or did all the people in Chaing Mai die of this cocktail? I suppose it possible an elderly couple in their 70's was out on the town ripping ass and got ahold of one of these deadly cocktails. But not likely.

The final Canadian autopsy report has not yet been released, has it? Perhaps we are all hoping for closure, but it is still too soon. Afaik, this news report only relates to the Bangkok autopsy. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

so I guess the tales that some posted on the other page about mozzie repellents being put into drinks weren't to far off then. The worldly and wise branded them as loonies running around in tin foil hats with conspiricy theories. I guess there is something to be learnt here, next time before some attack others with insults, stop for a moment and consider the possibility they may actually be more intelligent than yourselves and not escapees from the loony farm. I am refering to minority, those that think they have thier doctorates in everything known to mankind.

how can one escape from a place that is everywhere

Link to comment
Share on other sites

After reading through these 50 posts. It seems to me this the Thai authorities reported theory achieved what they wanted. A majority of these posts accept the these girls died by accidental overdose of deet. In my opinion, even though tragic, makes everybody feel better about what the cause of these deaths. Basically it puts the blame on an activity that many youth do in Thailand, and even though these girls did not do this intentional, and was an accident. (BS)

To me this stinks more of a cover up than before. What about all the other mysterious, unexplained deaths in Chaing Mai? The Canadian sisters deaths where of identical symptoms of these other deaths.

Or did all the people in Chaing Mai die of this cocktail? I suppose it possible an elderly couple in their 70's was out on the town ripping ass and got ahold of one of these deadly cocktails. But not likely.

The final Canadian autopsy report has not yet been released, has it? Perhaps we are all hoping for closure, but it is still too soon. Afaik, this news report only relates to the Bangkok autopsy. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

I was thinking the same thing.

Whilst we are all (or nearly all) very concerned about this, we need to wait for the Canadian autopsy results.

I'm suprised at how long its taking though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

After reading through these 50 posts. It seems to me this the Thai authorities reported theory achieved what they wanted. A majority of these posts accept the these girls died by accidental overdose of deet. In my opinion, even though tragic, makes everybody feel better about what the cause of these deaths. Basically it puts the blame on an activity that many youth do in Thailand, and even though these girls did not do this intentional, and was an accident. (BS)

To me this stinks more of a cover up than before. What about all the other mysterious, unexplained deaths in Chaing Mai? The Canadian sisters deaths where of identical symptoms of these other deaths.

Or did all the people in Chaing Mai die of this cocktail? I suppose it possible an elderly couple in their 70's was out on the town ripping ass and got ahold of one of these deadly cocktails. But not likely.

The final Canadian autopsy report has not yet been released, has it? Perhaps we are all hoping for closure, but it is still too soon. Afaik, this news report only relates to the Bangkok autopsy. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

I was thinking the same thing.

Whilst we are all (or nearly all) very concerned about this, we need to wait for the Canadian autopsy results.

I'm suprised at how long its taking though.

They did say somewhere it could take months.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Have the Canadians confirmed this toxicology report? They were provided with tissue samples early in the investigation, I am interested to know if their procedures confirm the presence of DEET.

I am also surprised that the Scottish woman who was with these ladies on the night of their demise was allowed to leave Thailand without a proper grilling. She was working for a bar, most likely as a tout. I suspect she knew more than she told, she was also very ill after their night out. It is quite possible they all knowingly drank this tox-tail (my new word for toxic cocktail) but something went wrong. I await comment from Canada .....

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is a lot of shouting that it's terrible the autopsy reports have yet to be released and it's all because of a Thai coverup. It's about time that people note that the Thai test results have not officially been released at the request of the parents. Who knows, but the Canadian autopsy results may come to a different conclusion and also not be released at the parents request.

The reporters should be ashamed of themselves.

Edited by simple1
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is a lot of shouting that it's terrible the autopsy reports have yet to be released and it's all because of a Thai coverup. It's about time that people note that the Thai test results have not officially been released at the request of the parents. Who knows, but the Canadian autopsy results may come to a different conclusion and also not be released at the parents request.

The reporters should be ashamed of themselves.

Why would their parents not want the inquest and toxicology results released?

I can understand that they would want (and deserve) to know the results first - but why would they not want them released?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would these young ladies have known what they were drinking?............

It's one thing to be struck down by your own foolishness........but another thing to be unknowingly poisoned.

Somewhere in the World today some other youngster, possibly many, are going to lose their lives due to recreational drugs.

Obviously this question will be impossible to answer in this particular case as we don't know what these unfortunate young ladies thought they were drinking............but for people with knowledge of these matters.........would you have known what was in the cocktail?

What people knowingly put into their bodies these days to get a High is quite frankly beyond belief.

I'm going to chose to believe that these young ladies weren't aware of what was going on..........maybe that's me just being soft hearted. There can be no solace to anyone knowing what has happened here, as it will no doubt just leave even more unanswered questions, however it's now up to the tourist industry and foreign governments to put serious pressure on the Thai authorities to put an end to this constant abuse of tourists travelling through Thailand.

Who in the right mind put DEET in a cocktail?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel very sad for these girls and their family and friends. DEET is a common additive to a cocktail sold in Thailand called 1-2-Call, which is a variation of 1x100. It is popular with Thais but nearly always found where ever mushroom shakes are found, aimed at the foreign back packer market for a cheap buzz. It is very popular in the South of Thailand by local communities.

Today the Canadian Government updated their travel advisory for Thailand saying,Some media reports indicate that there have been recent cases of poisoning allegedly linked to the consumption of a Thai beverage containing DEET.”

Canadian Sisters Poisoned by a DEET Overdose in a Kratom Cocktail in Thailand

"In Thailand where it has been a forbidden substance for some 70 years it has risen to popularity again. It is particularly popular in the south of Thailand, consumed orally as a drink known as “4x100”. It is typically a mixture of ice, cough syrup cola soft drink and kratom leaf extract. Another variation of this drink is also mix in ground-up mosquito coils as a cheap substitute for hallucination mushrooms, in English this drink is nicknamed “1-2-Call” after the very popular Thai cell phone provider.

This drink has proved to be popular to young foreigners to us at the famous full moon party, unfortunately a toxic reaction to the mosquito coils is not uncommon. This was highlighted in May 2007 where five people died after drinking the mosquito coil drinks at the full moon party. Sometimes liquefied DEET that is common in mosquito repellents is also used in the cocktail. This practice is expected to continue as tourist areas are prone to large commissions without receipts with figures of authority. "

Edited by jcw
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is a lot of shouting that it's terrible the autopsy reports have yet to be released and it's all because of a Thai coverup. It's about time that people note that the Thai test results have not officially been released at the request of the parents. Who knows, but the Canadian autopsy results may come to a different conclusion and also not be released at the parents request.

The reporters should be ashamed of themselves.

Why would their parents not want the inquest and toxicology results released?

I can understand that they would want (and deserve) to know the results first - but why would they not want them released?

Maybe they will when the Canadian results are in as a warning to other people; if death was caused by a poisonous substance or drugs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would these young ladies have known what they were drinking?............

It's one thing to be struck down by your own foolishness........but another thing to be unknowingly poisoned.

Somewhere in the World today some other youngster, possibly many, are going to lose their lives due to recreational drugs.

Obviously this question will be impossible to answer in this particular case as we don't know what these unfortunate young ladies thought they were drinking............but for people with knowledge of these matters.........would you have known what was in the cocktail?

What people knowingly put into their bodies these days to get a High is quite frankly beyond belief.

I'm going to chose to believe that these young ladies weren't aware of what was going on..........maybe that's me just being soft hearted. There can be no solace to anyone knowing what has happened here, as it will no doubt just leave even more unanswered questions, however it's now up to the tourist industry and foreign governments to put serious pressure on the Thai authorities to put an end to this constant abuse of tourists travelling through Thailand.

Who in the right mind put DEET in a cocktail?

Which is why I asked (but never received a reply) as to whether Deet had drug-like qualities or, was cheaper than alcohol.

Habitual drug takers know what they are putting in their body, but I haven't yet heard of any youngster taking Deet as their drug of choice.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So many foreigners in this country (not just here) die because of drug abuse. Full moon parties,with all sorts of drugs in the south, more heroin related deaths in the north, etc....

But would the TAT be interested in any investigation? Sad that the two girls had to die such a terrible death and it seems that there won't me much more information available.

People in heroin business mix strychnine into some bad quality stuff. It could make them high, or they could die.

Seems that too much of DEET came into their bodies. If they wanted to get high or not, shouldn't be the question.

Was it a "bar mixer" accident? Let's at least hope that some people have learned through such a tragedy.

I remember that the major's son of a bigger city in the UK died overdosed on Ko Panghan not too many moons ago.

English authorities took the dead body home and nothing has changed since then.

Did they really take that stuff, without knowing what was inside? Without the intention of trying to hurt anybody, but I've seen so many foreigners leaving their brains back home when heading to Thailand.

Edited by sirchai
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So many foreigners in this country (not just here) die because of drug abuse. Full moon parties,with all sorts of drugs in the south, more heroin related deaths in the north, etc....

But would the TAT be interested in any investigation? Sad that the two girls had to die such a terrible death and it seems that there won't me much more information available.

People in heroin business mix strychnine into some bad quality stuff. It could make them high, or they could die.

Seems that too much of DEET came into their bodies. If they wanted to get high or not, shouldn't be the question.

Was it a "bar mixer" accident? Let's at least hope that some people have learned through such a tragedy.

I remember that the major's son of a bigger city in the UK died overdosed on Ko Panghan not too many moons ago.

English authorities took the dead body home and nothing has changed since then.

Did they really take that stuff, without knowing what was inside? Without the intention of trying to hurt anybody, but I've seen so many foreigners leaving their brains back home when heading to Thailand.

I'm still struggling to understand why any bar would put Deet into drinks?

Personally, I find it impossible to believe they knew that the drink contained Deet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just find it so difficult to accept that yet again we are never going to know the truth in this matter. As so often these last twenty years in Thailand police make initial speculative statement of what might have happened to the victims. Such statements are inappropriate and are usually most improbable scenarios. Why don't they keep their mouths shut and preserve the forensic integrity of the crime scene and the deceased so a rational explanation can be reached.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks to all who gave links and the video.

This is very important to me because insects come from far and wide to bite me and I had no idea what so ever that there were risks with mozzy sprays.

I have been using local repellents containing 12 or 13% DEET.

The links say the risks are acceptable compared to catching mosquito-born diseases such as malaria, dengue fever, and West Nile virus.

However, it seems that the risks increase dramatically if I am also in contact with pesticides.

If hotels generally spray pesticides and I apply DEET topically, could the combination be problematic?

or does it need much larger concentrations of DEET?

There was a suggestion that these combinations caused Gulf War Syndrome - scary.

Thank goodness I do not have small children, their small bodies makes them more vulnerable.

What a crazy world we live in.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just from memory:

One of the farang ( Portuguese) guys who helped the girls to their room left a note stating, "Sorry..." Why?

The girls exhibited discolored fingernails, rash-like lesions on their bodies and bleeding from the gums and within the eyes. None of which seems to be a symptom exclusively to DEET ingestion.

They were unable to call for help or exit their room before they expired. Paralysis, unconsciousness or both?

If there were excessive amounts of DEET ingested and they had vomited profusely as reported why wasn't the chemical initially discovered in samples of the vomit taken months ago?

Still more questions than answers.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

After the break, how a Swedish man shot 27 bullets into his body with a 6 shooter by reloading 3 times.

Quite a trick. Think you will find (or maybe not) that he would have to reload FOUR times: first load, 6 rounds, three reloads, 18 rounds = 24 total. Need one more reload (or 3 rounds) to get 27.

Jeez...

And I thought he was being sarcastic--stupid me!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So many foreigners in this country (not just here) die because of drug abuse. Full moon parties,with all sorts of drugs in the south, more heroin related deaths in the north, etc....

But would the TAT be interested in any investigation? Sad that the two girls had to die such a terrible death and it seems that there won't me much more information available.

People in heroin business mix strychnine into some bad quality stuff. It could make them high, or they could die.

Seems that too much of DEET came into their bodies. If they wanted to get high or not, shouldn't be the question.

Was it a "bar mixer" accident? Let's at least hope that some people have learned through such a tragedy.

I remember that the major's son of a bigger city in the UK died overdosed on Ko Panghan not too many moons ago.

English authorities took the dead body home and nothing has changed since then.

Did they really take that stuff, without knowing what was inside? Without the intention of trying to hurt anybody, but I've seen so many foreigners leaving their brains back home when heading to Thailand.

That's it - they leave their brains behind.

That is the case for most folks - the wear their "Holiday Head" and then do things the would never normally do.

Alcohol is usually involved - never again - till the next time.

Many years ago at a beach party in Spain, folk were drinking a cocktail which contained cannabis, I tried it - seemed a good idea at the time as everyone was doing it and I didn't want to feel left out.

Good old peer pressure.

At the end of the day, people have the choice - take part or not.

I would hate to live in a nanny world where all risks are removed from me!

I'd have to try sky diving!

Tragic though this is, let's hope it spreads the word and then people can make informed choices.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm still struggling to understand why any bar would put Deet into drinks?

Personally, I find it impossible to believe they knew that the drink contained Deet.

Maybe you've been living in the falkland islands but I thought it was quite common knowledge that in some Muslim communities around the world, where alcohol is forbidden, there are people who regularly brew up kratom, cough syrup, coca cola occasionally with DEET and mosquito coils. I've been in the south of thailand on and off for four years and witness quite often (i.e. nearly a daily occurrence) the energy concoction being taken and I've tried myself just to see what all the 'buzz' was about (hasten to say sans any form of mozzy repelent!) and didn't quite see what the attraction was; surprisingly it tastes okay...

The number of 'farang' I've seen pass through willing to try the brew doesn't surprise me given the number of cheap chinese 'plant food' ecstasy and cocaine powder substitutes on the market in europe/us that people are willing to snort up.

I can honestly say I've yet to witness any bar publicly advertising this stuff for sale, usually taken amongst a small group of friends away from the limelight, so they must have known or been aware to some degree that this wasn't a readily available over-the-counter drink.

Oh and one last thing - Kratom is for sale on amazon.

Edited by delphiboy
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm still struggling to understand why any bar would put Deet into drinks?

Personally, I find it impossible to believe they knew that the drink contained Deet.

Maybe you've been living in the falkland islands but I thought it was quite common knowledge that in some Muslim communities around the world, where alcohol is forbidden, there are people who regularly brew up kratom, cough syrup, coca cola occasionally with DEET and mosquito coils. I've been in the south of thailand on and off for four years and witness quite often (i.e. nearly a daily occurrence) the energy concoction being taken and I've tried myself just to see what all the 'buzz' was about (hasten to say sans any form of mozzy repelent!) and didn't quite see what the attraction was; surprisingly it tastes okay...

The number of 'farang' I've seen pass through willing to try the brew doesn't surprise me given the number of cheap chinese 'plant food' ecstasy and cocaine powder substitutes on the market in europe/us that people are willing to snort up.

I can honestly say I've yet to witness any bar publicly advertising this stuff for sale, usually taken amongst a small group of friends away from the limelight, so they must have known or been aware to some degree that this wasn't a readily available over-the-counter drink.

Oh and one last thing - Kratom is for sale on amazon.

Perhaps you should read my earlier posts asking whether Deet has drug-like qualities or is cheaper than alcohol.

Cough syrup etc. in drinks doesn't suprise me in the slightest - Deet on the other hand, does.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm still struggling to understand why any bar would put Deet into drinks?

Personally, I find it impossible to believe they knew that the drink contained Deet.

Maybe you've been living in the falkland islands but I thought it was quite common knowledge that in some Muslim communities around the world, where alcohol is forbidden, there are people who regularly brew up kratom, cough syrup, coca cola occasionally with DEET and mosquito coils. I've been in the south of thailand on and off for four years and witness quite often (i.e. nearly a daily occurrence) the energy concoction being taken and I've tried myself just to see what all the 'buzz' was about (hasten to say sans any form of mozzy repelent!) and didn't quite see what the attraction was; surprisingly it tastes okay...

The number of 'farang' I've seen pass through willing to try the brew doesn't surprise me given the number of cheap chinese 'plant food' ecstasy and cocaine powder substitutes on the market in europe/us that people are willing to snort up.

I can honestly say I've yet to witness any bar publicly advertising this stuff for sale, usually taken amongst a small group of friends away from the limelight, so they must have known or been aware to some degree that this wasn't a readily available over-the-counter drink.

Oh and one last thing - Kratom is for sale on amazon.

in the 70s I can remember quite a few boys who were addicted to cough medicine, in the days it contained codiene and they used to let it settle then drink the separated level on the top. i think its banned nowadays.

Yabba makers have an odd trick, they mix the powder with pesticide as it help them form a tablet easily.. crazy or what?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks to all who gave links and the video.

This is very important to me because insects come from far and wide to bite me and I had no idea what so ever that there were risks with mozzy sprays.

I have been using local repellents containing 12 or 13% DEET.

The links say the risks are acceptable compared to catching mosquito-born diseases such as malaria, dengue fever, and West Nile virus.

However, it seems that the risks increase dramatically if I am also in contact with pesticides.

If hotels generally spray pesticides and I apply DEET topically, could the combination be problematic?

or does it need much larger concentrations of DEET?

There was a suggestion that these combinations caused Gulf War Syndrome - scary.

Thank goodness I do not have small children, their small bodies makes them more vulnerable.

What a crazy world we live in.....

Please @laislica don't start listening to these scare mongers, I have been using DEET products for years and regularly spray my house with mozzie killers and, I confess, am now in the middle age group. I just had a check up at my doctors and she proclaimed me fit as a 20 year old, she didn't have to amputate any additional heads or limbs that I'd grown. DEET is safe if used as directed. I go out into really mosquito infested places and by dressing sensibly and applying DEET sparingly in exposed places I seldom get bitten.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.







×
×
  • Create New...