God doesn't care about your 'good heart', although your divorcing 3 mentally ill women seems to suggest not that good, remember your oath before God .... sickness and health, etc.
God cares about you following his rules, although I'm hoping for a bit of wiggle room on my divorce as I opposed it and was divorced against my consent.
Anyway back on topic,
Jesus seemed OK with having a hooker as a bestie.
If that was good enough for Jesus, why not marry a bar girl.