I agree that such an initiative would go some way to breaking the party system in the Lords, but such a system presents major problems in its' own right. Firstly, there is obviously the question of getting individuals to stand for election. Secondly, there is the problem of getting the public to vote in such elections, especially if they are held at a different time to a GE. Thirdly, how are people expected to be able to make an informed choice, especially if they are voting for a large number of candidates? I wouldn't have known anything about Martin Rees or Sue Black (two cross bench peers) until 10 minutes ago, and personally, I would find it very difficult to choose between the two in any election. Imo the existing overly partisan system needs reform. However, perhaps a non-partisan Upper House, voted for by an engaged electorate, is a pipe dream of mine. If so, then an alternative based on the one used to appoint Supreme Court judges might be employed.
