Pure Android OS

[daocat555]

People have commented on the desirability of a phone with a "pure" Android OS in the Affordable Topic, the Mid-range Topic, the High End Topic, and here and there in other phone threads.  So I thought I would make a topic for pure Android discussions.  

 

I thought of this when I read the announcement by Umidigi of it's new phone with pure Android OS.  I have no idea if Umidigi's claim is accurate or not.  But it seems like there are not many phones running pure Android; the Google phones and exactly one line of Xiaomi phones, the Mi A1 and the Mi A2.  Google phones are expensive.  Xiaomi phones tend not to be expensive except that doesn't apply to the Xiaomi Mi line, which seem more expensive than any other Xiaomi phone for the hardware that you get.  The Nokia Sirocco claims to run pure Android; also an expensive phone with some hardware flaws.  The HTC U11 life runs pure Android, but with a 5.2 in screen and 68.6 % screen-to-body ratio, who would want one of them, and they are not inexpensive.

 

Some of the upcoming phones from Motorola and Nokia may run pure Android; but they have yet to be announced.  So I think the Umidigi One Pro is an interesting phone.  Here it is compared to the Xiaomi Mi A2 on devicespecifications.

 

Comparison between: UMIDIGI One Pro, Xiaomi Mi A2

 

The Umidigi has better body dimensions, stereo speakers, wireless charging supported, and a bigger battery; scoring over the Xiaomi in those categories.  The Xiaomi has a better chipset and a far better Antutu score, apparently better cameras, and a more established reputation for quality.

[mtls2005]

1 hour ago, daocat555 said:

Some of the upcoming phones from Motorola and Nokia may run pure Android; but they have yet to be announced.

 

Motorola has had a few Android One ones (Moto X4 most recently), and the Motorola One Power expected soon. They also manufactured the Nexus 6 for Google. They also have "Stock-ish" new devices like the G6 family - but these are not Android One.

 

I think a lot of the new Nokia phones are Android One.

 

I can't figure out if the Umidigi One and One Pro are actually Android One? They do mention "Stock Android", which is not exactly the same as "Android One".

 

The Mi A2 is a Mi 6X as an Android One device; no clue when that might be available? It's rumored to have a 5.99" screen.

 

I have a Nexus 6, a Mi A1 and a Nokia 7 Plus. IME, Xiaomi is a bit lame in providing updates - it took them ages to come out with 8.1, while Nokia is quite quick.

 

 

1 hour ago, daocat555 said:

Comparison between: UMIDIGI One Pro, Xiaomi Mi A2

 

Note the frequencies supported, just make sure you purchase a device which will work where you need it to.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Farangwithaplan]

There is something else to add into the mix and it is called Android Treble. That will be more important moving forward as it will allow phone manufacturers to add their "skins" over a pure android operating system - if they so choose. It should mean faster updates from all manufacturers as there won't be the need to be checking their code additions to new security updates of Android as thoroughly.

 

Should and will are not necessarily interchangeable in the last sentence.

[daocat555]

Yeah, I don't know what "stock" Android means with respect to the Umidigi One Pro.  The Cubot P20 claims ""Pure Android 8.0 system".  Elsewhere Cubot calls the OS "Android 8.0 Original".  Hm, why not Android 8.1 on a new phone?  Anyway here are the Cubot P20, Umidigi One Pro, and the soon to be released Xiaomi Mi A2 compared on device specifications.

 

Comparison between: Cubot P20, UMIDIGI One Pro, Xiaomi Mi A2

 

Yes, the Xiaomi Mi A2 is reported to have a 5.99 in screen. rumors say that the phone will be announced on July 25'th and will be available for sale on August 8'th with a price of 11,251 baht.

 

The Umidigi One Pro is listed for pre sale at GearBest for 16,889; the stereo speakers and wireless charging option might not be worth 5,648 baht extra over the Xiaomi Mi A2 with it's more powerful chipset and reputation for quality.  

 

However the Cubot P20 is reported to be priced at 4,329 baht!  That's less than half the price of the Xiaomi Mi A2, well, almost a third of the price actually.  And it stands up to the Xiaomi Mi A2 very well as long as you are not a power user requiring a powerful chipset.

 

The Cubot P20 has similar body weight and dimensions as the Xiaomi Mi A2, yet it has a bigger 6.18 in screen and a 4000 mAh battery compared to the 3030 mAh battery of the Xiaomi Mi A2.  The Xiaomi camera is the only one with optical zoom, and would appear to easily beat out the cameras of the other two models.

 

The Xiaomi Mi A2 has pure Android for sure, the Cubot P20 would appear to have pure Android, and the Umidigi One Pro has stock Android; whatever that means.  If you don't need stereo speakers the Xiaomi Mi A1 (in terms of history) has a single down firing speaker which was measured at 74 dB for voice and 90 dB for ringing phone by gsmarena (excellent score), with gsmarena subjectively reporting the sound quality "is rich and crisp, with good bass and clean high notes", so the Xiaomi Mi brand has a reputation for quality audio.  That seems to point to the Xiaomi Mi A2 as being the best of the three phones, with the Cubot P20 being the most affordable by a wide margin and spec wise holding up pretty well vs the other two phones.  The Umidigi appears to be the odd man out, oh well, it's tough being an off brand, but they do keep improving so I'm happy to give them a shout out.

[thedemon]

Oneplus' OxygenOS would deserve a mention. Though not quite pure Android, it's pretty close. Certainly no bloatware.

 

The Oneplus 6 is one of the handful of supported devices in the Android P beta program.

 

https://developer.android.com/preview/devices/

 

[mtls2005]

6 hours ago, thedemon said:

Oneplus' OxygenOS would deserve a mention. Though not quite pure Android, it's pretty close

 

While OnePlus has made some commitments re: Android support (for the -6 this includes P and O releases), they still struggle to pump out security patches. The OnePlus 6 got its first update, which includeded the May security patch.

 

Meanwhile, I received the July security patch yesterday on my Nokia 7 Plus (Android One).

 

I wouldn't necessarily rely on Xiaomi or Umidigi for reliable/timely releases. OnePlus seems a bit more "committed"?

[daocat555]

Thank you thedemon for your post.  I followed your link and was glad to see the Vivo X21 UD on the list.  Lazada has that phone for a reasonable price and it seems to be a very nice phone with good online reviews.

[Farangwithaplan]

2 hours ago, mtls2005 said:

 

I wouldn't necessarily rely on Xiaomi or Umidigi for reliable/timely releases.

Hi, not trying to contradict you, but just for clarity Xiaomi have been good up to this point on security updates on the MI A1. I think I bought it in September and have received every monthly security update so far, from Memory. I stayed on the May update but the June update offers 8.1 so I will hang back and wait to see if there is any adverse affect... There is naff all change from 8 to 8.1. A1 users have also been assured of support for Android P.

[mtls2005]

25 minutes ago, Farangwithaplan said:

but just for clarity Xiaomi have been good up to this point on security updates on the MI A1.

 

Meh.

 

The initial 8.1 drop on the A1 was a disaster, and they had to pull it back. I finally got 8.1 (w/June 5 security patch) last week, a full three months after I got it (8.1) on my Nokia 7 Plus (Android One).

 

Look, I'm not expecting much from Xiaomi as it takes some effort to pump out these releases in a timely and reliable fashion. I'll be pleasantly surprised if we get Android P much before January 2019, if at all.

 

Do you have VoLTE support on your Mi A1?

 

[Farangwithaplan]

1 hour ago, mtls2005 said:

 

Meh.

 

The initial 8.1 drop on the A1 was a disaster, and they had to pull it back. I finally got 8.1 (w/June 5 security patch) last week, a full three months after I got it (8.1) on my Nokia 7 Plus (Android One).

 

Look, I'm not expecting much from Xiaomi as it takes some effort to pump out these releases in a timely and reliable fashion. I'll be pleasantly surprised if we get Android P much before January 2019, if at all.

 

Do you have VoLTE support on your Mi A1?

 

What does 8.1 have to do with my points about regular security updates? If you are unhappy with the 8.1 roll out that is a completely different thing and not what I mentioned. So I think my point stands that up until now the security updates have been regular and monthly.

 

So what made the 8.1 update a disaster? Some people losing their SMS messages? Certainly not all. Samsung have have had their share of bugs in roll outs, too as have One + and Motorola from experience in the past. But I fail to see how bugs are a disaster. I feel that word is a dramatic overstatement and not helpful when having discussions on the pros and cons of things like software.

 

What is the benefit of 8.1 really.. I see very little in the upgrade useful for me. Also, if you are unhappy with the phone, didn't your research pick up that people have not been excited about the speed in updates in the past? When I bought the phone in September, it was reported that version 8 would be released before start of 2018 and from memory they met that target, or were a few days off. I see no repaort anywhere on a release date on 8.1 or version 9.0 P.

 

I just did some seaching online and find that Xiaomi is not alone in losing VoLTE settings in the Oreo upgrade. Some Motorola lost it, as did some Samsung, One + and Lenovo so I am guessing this issue is more about implimentation from the source code rather than a Xiaomi issue directly.

 

I don't have a need for VoLTE as I find standard VOIP working fine for me. I do see on the AIS web site that you need to apply for the service on your account. I wonder if you need to do it with True and DTAC. Have you turned it on with your supplier?

 

I'm not trying to Make Xiaomi out to be something they are not, but I personally don't expect much from a 7000 baht phone. I bought it because I am able to unlock the bootloader without wiping my data. That allows me to do complete backups which I need. And I find it punches well above its weight for the price. The only thing I would find useful is NFC but I can live without it.

 

 

[mtls2005]

45 minutes ago, Farangwithaplan said:

I'm not trying to Make Xiaomi out to be something they are not, but I personally don't expect much from a 7000 baht phone.

 

I think we agree that Xiaomi is not particularly adept at Android One, and that we don't expect much - we've both written as much a few times in this thread.

 

I paid 4,990 for my Mi A1 and I am relatively happy with it - the fact that it works on Band 4 LTE is a bonus for me as I need that with T-Mo in the U.S.A. 

 

Having, then losing VoLTE (and VoWiFi) was/is a PITA, and just points to the level of competency at Xiaomi. My Nokia 7 Plus retained full functionality (incl VoLTE and VoWiFi) through the 8.1 update and all subsequent security patches including July. 

 

I was simply cautioning others that Xiaomi is a bit behind the curve in rolling out Android updates - maybe 3-6 months on a major update (like P), and ~ 3 months on a point release, and 30-60 days on a security patch. Not quite up to Android One "expectations" but again, not exactly a sharp stick in the eye either.

 

 

 

 

[Farangwithaplan]

Great.. if you want to have VoLTE then you might want to look for a generic fix that also seems to work for the Samsung Motorola, One +  and other phones.

 

As I said, from the limited info I just read on the issue that it is specifically  an Xiaomi created bug, but an android os bug.

 

Good luck with it.

 

I still curious about what is the importance for 8.1? Not just you but so many people are getting very flustered about having it on every phone.

 

An old saying in software development is "be careful what you wish for. You might just get it."

 

Companies that bend to consumer pressure often end up releasing unpolished software and the result is often mob mentality hate by the same people screaming for the software to be released.

 

And the majority of companies, at some stage, have been guilty of bending to calls for release of software.

 

Software is so hard to define a completion date when there are variables as vast as you would find on a phone.

 

Take for example, the SMS issue in the Mi 8.1 update. Apparently triggered by specific setting when using specific countries when initially setting up the phone. That is a fairly obscure bug.

 

Again, I'm not taking a shot at you, but more putting some thoughts down for discussion.. for me, these things are as much a psychological interest on how people react to software not being released or being released in an imperfect state as much a a pure software interest.

[daocat555]

The Xiaomi Mi A2 Lite is expected to be announced and released along with the Mi A2 in a week.  The Lite being a very different phone in that it has a 4000 mAh battery and a sleeker body to boot.  Interestingly, it would appear that the Mi A2 Lite is the exact same phone as the Xiaomi Redmi 6 Pro; the only exceptions being that the Redmi 6 Pro will run MIUI 9 Android and the Mi A2 Lite will run pure Android.  Aliexpress has gone ahead and listed the Mi A2 Lite for sale at 5,921 baht in the Global version, and Aliexpress sells the Redmi 6 Pro for 5,417 baht in the Chinese version as the Global version is not yet available.

 

So for the apparently exact same hardware, it's a 504 baht fee to free yourself from the MIUI; a pretty good deal.

 

The Mi A2 is expected to have a 5.99 in screen compare to 5.84 in for the Lite. The Mi A2 has a 3030 mAh battery which has fast charging; the 4000 mAh battery of the Lite doesn't support fast charging; it charges at 5 V/2 A. 

 

The Mi A2 will have dual 12 MP/20 MP rear cameras while the Lite will have dual 12 MP/5 MP cameras.  The selfie on the Mi A2 is 20 MP and only 5 MP on the Lite.

 

The Mi A2 will have more memory and a better chipset vs the Lite.

 

Just to chime in on my personal view on a phone, which I know other people may not share, the width and length of the Mi A2 (75.4 x 158.7 mm) makes the Mi A2 Lite (71.68 x 149.33 mm) the more interesting model amongst the pure Android Mi A2's.

[mtls2005]

On 7/13/2018 at 12:09 PM, mtls2005 said:

I think we agree that Xiaomi is not particularly adept at Android One, and that we don't expect much - we've both written as much a few times in this thread.

 

Never one to fail to admit when I am wrong...

 

Got the July 1 security patch today for my Mi A1. So other than the stumble with 8.1 I have to say that I'm impressed that Xiaomi is able to crank out the updates in a timely fashion. Well done.

 

And also discovered the keycode to enable VoLTE: *#*#86583#*#* re-enables VoLTE.

 

Still trying to figure out how to get VoWiFi working; seems like it's doable.

 

 

 

 

[guzzi850m2]

I had an UMI Super and the Android op was very nice, no bloatware or Chinese apps installed. I actually loved that phone but it was heavy.

[Farangwithaplan]

mtls2005,

 

What carrier are you using? I have voLTE enabled and checked it in the diagnosis and confirmed it with *#*#86583#*#* yet when I turn on voLTE on AIS I get a warning from AIS that voLTE is not supported.

 

What carrier are you using to get voLTE working in Thailand?

 

[mtls2005]

6 minutes ago, Farangwithaplan said:

What carrier are you using to get voLTE working in Thailand?

 

DTAC.

 

AIS doesn't recognize the Mi A1, bummer. Enter *412*1# send. They check the IMEI number against their DB, and their VoLTE website says they only support the Redmi S2. Obviously no reason for this restriction, someone just needs to ask them to add the Mi A1, or open it up to everyone. 

 

http://www.ais.co.th/4g/volte/en/

 

Maybe drop an email to [email protected], reference your AIS phone number and your desire for VoLTE on your Mi A1. Based on some posts on Thai social media it seems like they want to test each handset and approve them, but maybe they do one-offs for individual customers?

 

 

[Farangwithaplan]

Thanks, it was just a curiosity for me. I really don't need the feature. Most times my VOIP is done when connected to wifi. But your info on Dtac may help someone else reading this.

 

[mtls2005]

VoIP and VoLTE are quite different, address totally different applications and are not really related per se. VoWiFi is different as well, although it does use VoIP as a transport. DTAC supports VoWiFi, as do many, many, many other service providers.

 

The benefits (for the consumer) of VoLTE are fast call set-up (no need for both devices to back down to 3G) and higher voice quality.

 

AFAIK, all three providers here support VoLTE here in Thailand.

[Farangwithaplan]

You're correct and sorry I just reread my post. I rarely use tradition phone dialing. I usually use voIP so voLTE is not important to me.

 

 

[Farangwithaplan]

Well to just check I emailed AIS yesterday about voLTE and received an email 24 hours later asking me to check if voLTE was working for me. I now see the HD symbol on the phone and a test call to an airline was very quick in connection. It seemed clear.

 

So if anyone is looking for voLTE on this phone and they are with AIS, follow the advice of mtls2005 and you might get the result you want.

[daocat555]

The Xiaomi Mi A2 Lite is now available at Lazada with a very good price.  The Cubot P20 is on sale at Gear Best for one more day.

 

Xiaomi Mi A2 Lite (3GB 32GB / 4GB 64GB) Smartphone | Lazada.co.th

 

Best 2018 Android Phone Cubot P20 4G Phablet Flash Sale from $129.99

 

Here are their specifications per Kimovil and devicespecification.

 

https://www.kimovil.com/en/compare/cubot-p20,xiaomi-mi-a2-lite

 

https://www.devicespecifications.com/en/comparison/8960113230

[daocat555]

The last time I posted about the Umidigi one Pro it was listed at GearBest for 16,889 baht.  So it's current price on Aliexpress of 6,110 baht which includes a wireless charger makes it a lot more desirable.  That's less expensive than the Xiaomi Mi A2 Lite, which has made it to Lazada.

[mtls2005]

AIS is promoting the Mi A2 Lite quite aggressively...6,290 sale, and as low as 2,290 with a plan.

 

I'm not sure if any of those other phones are pure Android, certainly not Android One.  https://www.android.com/one/

 

The mid-tier Chinese brands offer significant price/performance advantages and can be ordered quite easily online from places like GearBest. Not sure how they are to deal with returns/warranty? 

 

I bought an Elephone S8 from GearBest for 7,500 THB (at the time), and it was/is a decent phone. It just never, ever got an update, and the potential spy-/bloat-ware was annoying.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[daocat555]

Mtis2005; I went to Facebook for Umidigi Thailand and asked the question in a post, "Are the Umidigi One and One Pro part of the Android One program?"  Certainly they are not listed on the Android One site with the Link you gave, as the Xiaomi Mi A2 and Mi A2 Lite are.  I wonder the same thing about the Cubot's, but, for me, the new Umidigi models are more interesting.  I have also asked that question on the Umidigi forum in the Umidigi Official site.

 

Mtis 2005; you are a knowledgeable guy, and I'm really not trying to troll you here but imo you buy the darndest phones.  I just checked the specifications on the Elephone S8.  Run, don't walk, to a favorite food vender, masseuse, or acquaintance and give that phone away, hehe.

 

Thank you for posting, I will post again if I get an answer.

[mtls2005]

51 minutes ago, daocat555 said:

Run, don't walk, to a favorite food vender, masseuse, or acquaintance and give that phone away, hehe.

 

It's kept on hand as a loaner for colleagues visiting who need a phone when visiting. Everyone who's used it has loved it.

 

It was/is actually quite a decent phone, but then I'm just not a "spec guy".  I needed a phone ASAP, it got good reviews, decided to take a flyer, replaced it with a Nokia 7 Plus.

 

My daily driver is a Nokia 7 Plus, with Mi A1 and Nexus 6 as back-ups, and for use in the U.S. All three are pure/stock Android obviously. My previous phones were Nexus 5 and Nexus 4. 

 

I think the Android One page is accurate.  With the introduction of "Project Treble", it is a bit easier for vendors to offer more stock-ish Android phones, and updates. 

 

 

[daocat555]

Well the Pocphone F1 has great value at Lazada for 10,990 baht.  It has a new MIUI which is "lighter, faster, smoother" but definitely un-pure.  The Xiaomi Official Store at Lazada after teasing a good price on the Mi A2 Lite for a few days does not now offer a good price for it.  

 

LazMall at Lazada sells for Mi A2 Lite 3/32 for 5,990 baht and includes a free Xiaomi Mi Band 2 (a digital watch/pedometer), which is a tad higher than Aliexpress but quick and reliable.

 

I believe the Mi A2 Lite OS is pure as the driven snow; correct me if I'm wrong.

 

Nokia is due to announce the Nokia 9 (long overdue actually) and a Nokia phone with 5 rear cameras is making the rumor mill rounds; maybe the Nokia 10, possibly, but not likely, the 9.

 

I'm looking forward to some substantial announcement from Nokia some time soon.  If the 9 is announced but doesn't have 5 rear phones, well, maybe the announcement for the Nokia 10 will not be as delayed as the 9.

[mtls2005]

Motorola (Lenovo) announced two new Android One phones at IFA 2018: Motorola One and Motorola One Power. The latter looks pretty good but is destined for India only.

 

LG also announced an Android One device at IFA 2018, the LG G7 One.

 

 

 

 

[guzzi850m2]

I also prefer android one OP system but not many phones have them.

 

Yes Poco F1 uses Xiaomi skin which is not too bad but not pure android one.

[mtls2005]

If you're comfortable flashing ROMs there are usually a decent choice of pure-ish custom ROMs, with GAPPS, that offer amazing functionality. This is of course based on developer support for particular models, voids your warranty and admittedly not for everyone. The xdadevelopers site/forum may be a good jumping off point, along with Youtube tutorials?  

 

I recently flashed Lineage OS 14.1 (Android 7.1.2) on my ancient Samsung Tab 3 10.1 (GT-P5210) and it's like having a new tablet, considering replacing the battery instead of giving it away.

 

 

I'm expecting the Android 9.0 (Pie) update on my Nokia 7 Plus this month; and hopefully by year's end on my Mi A1.