Thailand’s Digital Minister Seeking Court Order to Shut Down Facebook over Fake Ads and Scams

[ravip]

I can never understand the mentality of politicians... globally. 

[hotchilli]

9 hours ago, snoop1130 said:

The Minister stated that the Digital Ministry has tried numerous times to work with Facebook on removing and taking action against scammers using its platform but claimed the company had not taken any meaningful action.

Almost every school in Thailand uses FB as a communication platform... what would they do?

[2baht]

15 minutes ago, klauskunkel said:

A big part of the scams is Thais using the culturally and educationally ingrained behaviors like blind, unquestioning obedience to perceived authority to take advantage of other Thais. Yet the government has not taken action on their end to foster critical thinking in society...

Greed also comes in to play, scammers love the greedy! Have I got a deal for you! 

[2baht]

Just now, hotchilli said:

Almost every school in Thailand uses FB as a communication platform... what would they do?

Regardless, they don't absorb too much!

[MadMac]

FB thrives on censorship and does not give a damn on their users. So let them take some of their own medicine. Well deserved.

[Bangkok Barry]

For a Minister supposedly in charge of IT things, no matter how temporarily, he is appallingly ignorant about how the digital world works. Everyone knows there are ways around 'blocking' a site, even in China. Everyone except him, that is.

 

What he says about Facebook is true, we all know that. It is full of scams and fake ads, so many with its billions of users around the world that it is impossible to keep tabs on it all. As I wrote in another thread yesterday, all they can do is put a plaster on a gaping wound to try and limit the damage. Worse than scams and fake ads though are the hate messages sent usually via Twitter/X. Why not block that too. Maybe even prioritise it.

[dinsdale]

This aint about FB. This is about information control. As for it being a caretaker govt the next govt will be pretty much the same. A junta govt. PT are not seperate from the junta. They are now part of it.

[MadMac]

6 minutes ago, hotchilli said:

Almost every school in Thailand uses FB as a communication platform... what would they do?

I believe they left for Line and Tiktok a few years ago. Facebook is for old people and scamming them.

Edited August 21, 2023 by MadMac

[Moti24]

1 hour ago, ChipButty said:

Imagine that no Facebook? what would thai people do? the country would grind to a halt, 

There'd still be Line.  That keeps Thais glued to there phones all day.

[Moti24]

The fake adds and scams are directed towards the gullible.

 

If offers are too good to be true, don't even think about it; it's not rocket science.

[Bangkok Barry]

Just now, MadMac said:

FB thrives on censorship and does not give a damn on their users. So let them take some of their own medicine. Well deserved.

What a bizarre comment, based on your opinion. Which is, of course, your right to offer. Thrives on censorship? How? Doesn't give a damn on (sic) their users? When they employ thousands around the world trying to limit the damage caused by those who misuse it. The misuse has nothing at all to do with Facebook. Invent anything and people will find a way to corrupt it. It's what people do. People are the problem, not Facebook. Facebook is the messenger which then has to spend huge sums trying to limit the damage that people misuse it for.

[Spock]

1 hour ago, pepi2005 said:

Fartbook is very quick and effective in automatically detecting, filtering and censoring content questioning climate and corona propaganda (for example), yet for some reason, detecting scams, spam and left-wing extremism seems an unsolvable problem for this (and many other Silicon Valley) corporations.

I wonder why that is? Maybe the planet just hasn't enough computer power for that, dunno.

Getting them to take down any of the many gratuitous animal cruelty videos is an exercise in futility. Nothing you report seems to infringe their guidelines or is considered unacceptable. Not that I want to see Facebook banned but I would like to see the owners display some moral fibre. Get sick of seeing Chinese people dragging dogs destined for the dinner table behind their bikes and cars or videos of large animals and snakes throttling domestic animals to death etc. 

[hotchilli]

9 hours ago, snoop1130 said:

Chaiwat said complaints against users being scammed on Facebook to police were regular and that as Facebook was not taking action on their end, according to him, Thailand planned to seek a court order to legally shutter the service, joining countries like China and North Korea.

And there you have it folks...  

[zyphodb]

20 minutes ago, hotchilli said:

Almost every school in Thailand uses FB as a communication platform... what would they do?

I think you'll find that they use line to contact everyone with anything important, but you do have a point...

[PeterA]

He failed to mention (for obvious reasons) that the Thai police departments also failed any action to prosecute  perps in Thailand that commit the fraud.

So blame Facebook, not the local thieves.

[Dukeleto]

Faecebook has really no value except to highlight mankind's general population's general innate stupidity. I for one would have zero problem if it disappeared overnight.

[Ben Zioner]

Next they're gonna go after Virtual Private Porn.

[2baht]

22 minutes ago, MadMac said:

FB thrives on censorship

Ahh I thought they excelled in data "collection and storage"! ???? ????

[Expat68]

Although I use Facebook, I would not care in the slightest 

[Polaky]

Sais the king of scammers, everyone who has been here has been scammed, imagine if they shut down Line,  all the girls would not be buried in their phones, that would be a welcome change.

[dinsdale]

37 minutes ago, MadMac said:

I believe they left for Line and Tiktok a few years ago. Facebook is for old people and scamming them.

Thais buy lots of stuff off of FB.

Edited August 22, 2023 by dinsdale

[crazykopite]

????????????????Amazing Thailand ????????????????

[herfiehandbag]

2 hours ago, BarraMarra said:

next they will be wanting to go back into the 1900s and revert back to Siam.

Some may recall a drama series set amongst the court and Royal household of Siam in the 17 Century, which was aired back at the beginning of Prayut's time in government. It depicted life as a feudal idyll, remarkably clean well fed peasants looked after by a benign aristocracy.

 

One of the characters was a European (Portuguese I think) member of the court. He was always up to something devious, and at the end of most episodes got a good kicking from the stalwart handsome heroes.

 

The whole fandangle was enthusiastically pushed by Prayut and his bunch as the sort of society to aspire towards. There were whole ranges of knock off clothing and products; I remember how children (my daughter and her friends, then entering their teens), were encouraged to dress up on Fridays in "traditional" (polyester made in China) Siamese costumes. Of course they looked jolly pretty, and enjoyed it immensely, but I was always slightly disturbed by how enthusiastically the, umh, more conservative members of staff at my school embraced it.

 

Exactly the sort of society ,authority in the hands of the "good people" and the proles in their place, that these sort of people aspire to. 

 

You can expect, if Facebook is closed off, Tic Toc, Instagram and others to follow. The friends to the Nort East will be only too happy to supply the knowhow! Of course a replacement service " designed for Thailand's needs" will be introduced. Perhaps a project for the next four years once the new government is installed?

 

Putting these sort of politicians in charge of digital economy and communications is a bit like making Garry Glitter a trustee of a Children's home!

Edited August 22, 2023 by herfiehandbag

[MrJ2U]

1 hour ago, MangoKorat said:

I know exactly how things work in Thailand.

I don't think so. 

[kennw]

9 hours ago, TallGuyJohninBKK said:

Obviously this guy and his cohorts have no clue of what it means to be a "caretaker" official, especially when it comes to this kind of a major, controversial move.

 

You wanna see a rebellion in Thailand, just try taking away their Facebook. ????

 

Yes expect thousand of phone addicts to have breakdowns, how will I know what my friend is having for breakfast? what about the gossip? Oh wo is me. 555555555

[brianthainess]

Please, Can they wait a bit till I've sold my bridge, and my African princess has sent my gifts.

[neeray]

2 hours ago, fdimike said:

Facebook is a useless gossip platform that provides no redeeming value.  Ban it now!

Exactly why I never got involved.

[Hakuna Matata]

I will be more than happy if they shut down Facebook!

[Hakuna Matata]

Facebook is very addictive and toxic, especially for young people.

Once you develop this addiction, you cannot stop.

Like heroin ????

[Snig27]

3 hours ago, jippytum said:

Its true many people sre conned with fake ads and facebook do nothing to correct the problem. 

If they are can't protect the subscribers then a ban would be in order until facebook take some action to protect people from the hundreds of scammers currently  on facebook. 

And hundreds of 1000s of businesses that rely on it would grind to a halt. Good to think about these things before posting.