Koh Tao: All three migrant workers confess to rape and murder of British tourists

[Artisi]

If these Arkanese guys are Bengali, (aka Rohingya), then this will be greeted as great news by many Myanmarese and these oppressed people can expect even more trouble.

That non-information really adds to the discussion, well done.

[6NS]

With regard to all this everyone should ask themselves a basic fundamental question:- ''Do you trust the Royal Thai Police'' ?

I really don't think we need to run a poll to know the overwhelming answer to this simple question.

It's very sad but If convicted nobody will ever truly believe that these Burmese were responsible unless the DNA results are confirmed by a third party. Since the victims were British then it is the British that would logically make the ideal candidate for such a confirmation.

If reconfirmed then the Thai police would be able to go to sleep at night knowing they had finally done a good job in the worlds eyes. The doubters such as myself would have to eat humble pie....and for an excellent reason I would be more than pleased to do so.After recent form it would be quite a dramatic turn of events for them.

Only a fool or a Thai policeman would not take this opportunity now.

Why do we not get photos of these three suspects??????????????? Maybe because they have bruises all over perhaps.

I suppose we'll see these poor patsies faces when ready for camera and bodies when healed.

[greenchair]

If they were really involved, then terrific they have been apprehended. But, unless the British (or anyone but the Thais) carry out and confirm the DNA samples really match, I am not convinced...... Also, I know allot of Burmese and Thai people. They DO NOT smoke LM cigarettes as a rule...... They are 66 baht a packet, this is 1/3rd of a days pay for the average Burmese person...... They smoke far cheaper brands usually

You have no leg to stand on in this particular case. There is a CCTV footage confirming that the suspect purchased LM cigarettes.

Unless a well off thai gave him the money to buy them. A thai that was down on the beach maybe.

[alfalfa19]

Police officers then led the two to a safe-house where they were intensively interrogated.

This is the scary bit . . . . . probably admit to anything while there.

I agree, and I was going to paste the same quote. It seems the interrogation (torture) was too heinous to be done at the cop shop, and had to be carried out at a separate house of horrors. I am not saying they are innocent, I am saying that they confessed under duress. I don't believe a goddamned thing these cops say. At this point, the evidence has been so thoroughly manipulated, twisted and destroyed, that the killers may not ever be caught, if these guys are just scapegoats. And this guy Kent seems like a real assclown to be accepting the current story, and even congratulating the scumbag police on their great job.

[robertthebruce]

I thought that there was two types of Seamen found in her ??? So how come the three confess to,rape ???

It ain't cutting it for me... It's a set up for sure....

[6NS]

I don't find it so inconceivable that these men would be capable of doing it: drunk, young, male, poor, illegally employed, drifter, sex deprived, cabin fever (island).

Do thaivisa naysayers accept that such people might commit murder?

Drunkenness does not make three people do this to others.

Revenge for serious loss of face of an untouchable has.

[WinnieTheKhwai]

I don't find it so inconceivable that these men would be capable of doing it: drunk, young, male, poor, illegally employed, drifter, sex deprived, cabin fever (island).

Do thaivisa naysayers accept that such people might commit murder?

Yes they might. Which is why buying the same common brand of cigarettes nearby is reason enough to have you taken not to a police station but to an undisclosed location and endure a "gruelling day-long interrogation".

Case closed!

[zyphodb]

Yes I'm sure it is possible Harry, but with whats gone on earlier in the "investigation" it looks far more likely to be a stitch up to protect the real killers, I hope I'm wrong but I honestly doubt it very much...

[smedly]

It isn't hard to set the scene here, we already know that there were 3 Asian men on the beach with a guitar and most likely drinking, something they likely do on a regular basis.

Along come the two victims and perhaps even joined them (maybe not the first time), David goes for a swim (as it was reported he drowned or may have been attacked in the water) we know the rest.

Remember they may have been with the men on the beach socialising before the crimes took place, it's easy to think this happened as a sudden attack while the victims were alone together - that is probably not how it happened.

If I was the Thai police chief right now I'd be calling for an independent DNA test to be performed to remove any doubt and shore up some confidence in this investigation - it certainly wouldn't do any harm

[baboon]

Mr. Kent went on to praise the Royal Thai Police in solving the case and have shown exemplary professionalism as a crime fighting unit.

People from the UK must be so proud of their ambassador to Thailand.

Another case of people believing what the media in Thailand claims to be true.

Are you really naive enough to believe that the ambassador actually said these words?

Don't believe anything that is printed by Thai media, it's all propaganda. All.

He did not state that the police had shown exemplary professionalism IN THIS CASE. Perhaps he is just handling the situation delicately.

I could well be wrong but it is just a thought.

[stevehaigh]

i don't get why there is never any talk of finger prints. surely they would have left prints everywhere at the scene and on the hoe?

[sweatalot]

The British Ambassador later said “Thailand and the UK have always mutually helped each other in the past and the cooperation has always benefitted both countries. This new development reaffirms our confidence in both our countries abilities.”

this must be cynical - or is it the famous English humour?

Edited October 3, 2014 by sweatalot

[jabis]

I thought that there was two types of Seamen found in her ??? So how come the three confess to,rape ???

It ain't cutting it for me... It's a set up for sure....

What Wally the pirate, and Popeye? You must have ment semen.

[uty6543]

After reading this and most of the other threads on this subject I have a very hard time to believe.............................that a single forum could host such a large amount of keyboard warriors unbelievers .

Only extremely guilbe people could believe this without a lot of explanations.

If there was to be a jury trial there would no chance of proving these 3 guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

[mrtoad]

Mr. Kent went on to praise the Royal Thai Police in solving the case and have shown exemplary professionalism as a crime fighting unit.

People from the UK must be so proud of their ambassador to Thailand.

No, he's a disgrace and another reason why the reputation of said Embassy is in the gutter.

[ttthailand]

Where are the photos of these guys? Perhaps after all the beating not good to show.

If the DNA matches then they should fry. If not ......

[Dararasmi]

I don't know...sounds good to me. (But then again, I just don't care at all.)

[Emster23]

Brit embassy should send staffer to collect hair samples from the suspects for DNA tests. Tell RTP want to confirm matches DNA samples they took from victims bodies. Get guy from "Lie to me" to observe their reactions when this is done. (I know that is tv, but there are those who study this. Problem with lie and evasion techniques is presumes subject feels some inner turmoil over doing wrong...). Regarding DNA of Hannah and subject sharing cigarette: could see one of them ordering her to light him one. Hands maybe too bloody to do it properly....?

[Anthony5]

I have just spoken with some BIB and it was promised that soon a detailed transcript of the investigation and interrogation will be posted on this forum.

They also promised that for any future crime Thaivisa will be consulted prior to making any steps in the investigation or media announcements.

[greenchair]

In the original story there were some guys singing english songs (Sean) I wander that they do have 1 of the culprits but not all. There are still many pieces missing. The most important question I have always said, is where did the hoe come from. I do not believe there are garden hoes that belong to no-one in particular left all over the beach at night. Which restaurant did it come from.

Edited October 3, 2014 by greenchair

[Soi Dog]

Safe house for whom?

[mongoose11]

Particularly cringeworthy about the ambassador... I know the Thais like it all to be happy an rosy an gaga an eeky boooo but cum'on

The safe house - to be a fly on the wall

DNA semen match is a must for 2 rapists..as they have 2 swabs..will only believe uk evidence I'm afraid

[thhMan]

If this is all true then it's great news for the families to these scumbags finally arrested and give at least some closure for them.

There's a lot of unsolved all around the world that will never be solved and the Thai police were under the pump from day one with such a high profile case.

Let's hope that all the authorities involved in this case will learn from this including procedures and press statements in future cases.

18 days is excellent work considering the amount of suspects they had to deal with.

Well done despite the press gaffs along the way!

Agree completely with you. As I mentioned in another thread, not exactly textbook criminal investigating, but, it now appears certain the RTP have found the culprits.

The way the families of David and Hannah have conducted themselves throughout this ordeal is a real credit to them. I am also extremely proud of the RTP for sticking to their guns and investigating they way they deemed most appropriate.

I believe this outcome will surely go some way to restoring people's faith in not only the RTP, but also in Thailand as a holiday destination.

Stay safe guys, use common sense and let's all stop with the silly conspiracy theories and get on with the healing process for all involved.

How can the healing process start, when its speculated that Thai Police are known for their lack of proper duty and care.

Since day 1, this whole fiasco is about tourism and you yourself add to that horrible practice.

Healing will start when parties outside of Thailand with no vested interest in Thailand have access to samples for testing

Should results confirm the Thai version, then so be it.... But be careful of jumping on the Police-Tourism-Incompetent bandwagon!

There is a reason why there are conspiracies... some of it boiled down to lack of trust in anything official in Thailand... You dont think the Junta took over Thailand. just for the hell of it,...... sheesh!

[mrtoad]

If this is all true then it's great news for the families to these scumbags finally arrested and give at least some closure for them.

There's a lot of unsolved all around the world that will never be solved and the Thai police were under the pump from day one with such a high profile case.

Let's hope that all the authorities involved in this case will learn from this including procedures and press statements in future cases.

18 days is excellent work considering the amount of suspects they had to deal with.

Well done despite the press gaffs along the way!

Agree completely with you. As I mentioned in another thread, not exactly textbook criminal investigating, but, it now appears certain the RTP have found the culprits.

The way the families of David and Hannah have conducted themselves throughout this ordeal is a real credit to them. I am also extremely proud of the RTP for sticking to their guns and investigating they way they deemed most appropriate.

I believe this outcome will surely go some way to restoring people's faith in not only the RTP, but also in Thailand as a holiday destination.

Stay safe guys, use common sense and let's all stop with the silly conspiracy theories and get on with the healing process for all involved.

One of the most moronic posts seen on TV in the last 10 years.

Well done.

[Fred Flinstone]

And so it goes…...

Into Oblivion with some firing squad will go these most likely innocent men.

I hope they are permitted to be questioned by agencies or officials from the west before speedy trial and execution.

It would be interesting to hear their words and see if they appear the "real deal""

Or simply avoiding going back to those interrogations .

The nazis would be my choice if given the option of Thai Cops after "an immediate confession" or them.

Human rights people should examine their bodies for signs of torture .

Its likely they were terrified and told of untold horrors ahead .

Savage tools shown and an apron welding Thai with hate in his eyes and bag of tricks.

Maybe a few demonstrations of how much fun lays ahead?

Most people would confess if a Cat mincer was your fate otherwise.

Edited October 3, 2014 by Fred Flinstone

[Oziex1]

Another crime solved with the help of Burmese fall guys.

[elektrified]

The case is almost finished. What else do you want? The suspects confessed that they killed David and Hannah, the DNA samples matched. Bear in mind that hose Burmese guys know that there is a high probability that they will be handed a death sentence. What's the point of admitting to something if you know that you might end up killed anyway? Having said that I'm all for the

independent DNA sampling carried out by the British forensic team as soon as it is practically possible.

O.K. of course I'm skeptical......but as the other poster said, who in their right mind would confess to crimes that would undoubtedly result in the death penalty if they were innocent? I may have not read the reports in Thai correctly but I believe it said the DNA is in already and it was a match. So yes, I would say - case closed at this point.

[kriswillems]

Why was DNA of Hannah found on the LM cigarette butt? Did they let her smoke a cigarette before raping and killing her?

Why was the taxi driver beaten and offered 700K for a testimony?

Why did they have to take the Burmese to a safe house for interrogation?

Why did they found a condom on the beach which had only DNA of Hannah?

Why did the police put the T-shirt with blood in the suitcase of their farang friend?

How did a group of guitar playing Burmese suddenly got access to a garden hoe?

If the 3 Burmese guys did it, why didn't they go back to their country the next day?

Why did the interrogation of the Burmese take 2 days? What did they do with them?

The police had already taken DNA samples of Burmese workers within 2 days it happened. Why was there no match at that time and there in now?

[6NS]

In the original story there were some guys singing english songs (Sean) I wander that they do have 1 of the culprits but not all. There are still many pieces missing. The most important question I have always said, is where did the hoe come from. I do not believe there are garden hoes that belong to no-one in particular left all over the beach at night. Which restaurant did it come from.

Why from a restaurant?????? Another troller.

[jomcondo]

The Burmese would have run if they did it.