Jump to content

Bank Staff Criticised For Rejecting Redshirts Deposits


Recommended Posts

Posted
PS if your using the likes of facebook or microsoft or apple and or many other blue chip products your supporting the Shins as they own that stock .. lots of it
So every time you use facebook your contributing to the Shin wealth while the stocks rise....

Facebook? Really??

  • Replies 121
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Posted

A bank refusing deposits?

Isn't there a law against that?

Dunno is there .. is this story reported in the same way in other papers?

This report seems to blame the BAAC branch. The video I saw looked more like someone being asked to leave because they were aggressive and disruptive.

but I could be wrong.

Sent from my XT1032 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Posted (edited)

And then this :

"

the Deputy Commerce Minister urged the Bank for Agriculture and Agricultural Cooperatives (BAAC) to open a special deposit account for the farmers who have not received payments from the rice pledging program. He noted that people who wanted to help farmers could transfer money into that account and the BAAC could pay farmers. - See more at: http://oryza.com/news/rice-news/thailand-caretaker-prime-minister-denies-corruption-charges-rice-mortgage-program#sthash.6ZEtbTdV.dpuf

"

It would seem that the government wants normal Thai people to pay the rice AGAIN!

And amazingly the deputy commerce minister is non other than

Mr.Nattawut Saikuar

UDD leader and person putting pressure on the BAAC.

Sent from my XT1032 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Edited by casualbiker
  • Like 2
Posted

Too many insults being hurled around here. Calm down please, and do not refer to people as "dogs" or your posting rights will be removed.

  • Like 1
Posted

Surely the unasked part of this story is where a local red MP got 30 million baht in readies for a publicity stunt?

Sent from my iPad using Thaivisa Connect Thailand

He closed his a/c with GSB.

Posted
This is not the PDRC's fault. This highlights this is not the PDRC's fault. To reiterate, this is not Sutheps fault.

Blame the PTP and the Red Shirts. Start to show some accountability. The whole reason the regime is in this situation is because they have never accepted blame. Never said "We made a mistake". People make mistakes. It is human nature. I can see in a way why they won't admit it though. They are not human. They are dogs.

It's NEVER the PDRC's fault. Everything is ALWAYS the government's fault. Somebody watching a bit too much BlueSky tonight?

The Puea Thai and Red Shirts not being human is going a bit too far, even for someone like you, don't you think? But then again, this is the kind of brainwashing that Suthep and the PDRC do to people. Causing divide in the nation, stirring hate and branding insults in the minds of ordinary gullible people.

djjamie is a perfect example of a brainwashed foreigner, folks.

Whereas promising ordinary gullible people that they will be rich in six months (two and a half years ago) has just worked wonders hasn't it?

The poor rice farmers (assuming you're referring to them) have made more money in the past 3 years selling their rice to the government than they would have made by selling it to the rice mills that have ripped them off for the past decades.

For normal rice, they got about 10,500 Baht per tonne at the rice mills, while the government paid them 15,000 per tonne. For Hom Mali rice, the government even pays 20,000 Baht.

They didn't get "rich", but I don't think the government promised that anywhere. They however did get more money over the past years than they would have gotten by selling the rice to the rip-off mills.

The rice scheme has worked well for them for the past 3 years. I see people screaming that the government is bankrupt due to the rice scheme and that's just not the truth. There are many reputable sources that state quite the contrary. The Thai government is far from bankrupt. What you lose with one government program, you make up for with the next.

I am not saying that the rice scheme doesn't lose money, but anyone that thinks every government program only makes money and none of them lose any clearly has no idea. There are government programs in the US and EU that also lose money, but they make up for those losses elsewhere.

Posted

This is not the PDRC's fault. This highlights this is not the PDRC's fault. To reiterate, this is not Sutheps fault.

Blame the PTP and the Red Shirts. Start to show some accountability. The whole reason the regime is in this situation is because they have never accepted blame. Never said "We made a mistake". People make mistakes. It is human nature. I can see in a way why they won't admit it though. They are not human. They are dogs.

It's NEVER the PDRC's fault. Everything is ALWAYS the government's fault. Somebody watching a bit too much BlueSky tonight?

The Puea Thai and Red Shirts not being human is going a bit too far, even for someone like you, don't you think? But then again, this is the kind of brainwashing that Suthep and the PDRC do to people. Causing divide in the nation, stirring hate and branding insults in the minds of ordinary gullible people.

djjamie is a perfect example of a brainwashed foreigner, folks.

Whereas promising ordinary gullible people that they will be rich in six months (two and a half years ago) has just worked wonders hasn't it?

The poor rice farmers (assuming you're referring to them) have made more money in the past 3 years selling their rice to the government than they would have made by selling it to the rice mills that have ripped them off for the past decades.

For normal rice, they got about 10,500 Baht per tonne at the rice mills, while the government paid them 15,000 per tonne. For Hom Mali rice, the government even pays 20,000 Baht.

They didn't get "rich", but I don't think the government promised that anywhere. They however did get more money over the past years than they would have gotten by selling the rice to the rip-off mills.

The rice scheme has worked well for them for the past 3 years. I see people screaming that the government is bankrupt due to the rice scheme and that's just not the truth. There are many reputable sources that state quite the contrary. The Thai government is far from bankrupt. What you lose with one government program, you make up for with the next.

I am not saying that the rice scheme doesn't lose money, but anyone that thinks every government program only makes money and none of them lose any clearly has no idea. There are government programs in the US and EU that also lose money, but they make up for those losses elsewhere.

And what was the world market price?

the Miller and exporter has to make money as well.

ripped them off.. right!!

Agriculture subsidies occur all over the world true. But most help rather than hinder .. Thailand has gone from number 1 rice exporter to number 3. With the reputation of Thai high quality rice shattered due in the inefficiency and corruption endemic in the scheme. .. I don't think any one has a major problem with a well thought out agriculture subsidy scheme.

Also why was it only rice farmers that got the bulk of subsidies??

Sent from my XT1032 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Posted (edited)

No joke, this photo looks like a Michelangelo painting, with the guy in a "frozen pointing pose" his arm pointed upward in that pointy-finger way that classic artists loved so much lol. Brilliant photo.

cheesy.gif

Edited by Yunla
  • Like 1
Posted
The poor rice farmers (assuming you're referring to them) have made more money in the past 3 years selling their rice to the government than they would have made by selling it to the rice mills that have ripped them off for the past decades.

For normal rice, they got about 10,500 Baht per tonne at the rice mills, while the government paid them 15,000 per tonne. For Hom Mali rice, the government even pays 20,000 Baht.

They didn't get "rich", but I don't think the government promised that anywhere. They however did get more money over the past years than they would have gotten by selling the rice to the rip-off mills.

The rice scheme has worked well for them for the past 3 years. I see people screaming that the government is bankrupt due to the rice scheme and that's just not the truth. There are many reputable sources that state quite the contrary. The Thai government is far from bankrupt. What you lose with one government program, you make up for with the next.

I am not saying that the rice scheme doesn't lose money, but anyone that thinks every government program only makes money and none of them lose any clearly has no idea. There are government programs in the US and EU that also lose money, but they make up for those losses elsewhere.

And what was the world market price?

the Miller and exporter has to make money as well.

ripped them off.. right!!

Agriculture subsidies occur all over the world true. But most help rather than hinder .. Thailand has gone from number 1 rice exporter to number 3. With the reputation of Thai high quality rice shattered due in the inefficiency and corruption endemic in the scheme. .. I don't think any one has a major problem with a well thought out agriculture subsidy scheme.

Also why was it only rice farmers that got the bulk of subsidies??

Sent from my XT1032 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Instead of complaining about what Puea Thai hasn't done for this country, you should compare them with others like the Democrats before them.

I am not saying Puea Thai is perfect, but the best of the available options. If a better party comes along, I will gladly reconsider my opinion but it just doesn't exist right now.

And I stand by my opinion that the rice millers are ripping the farmers off, but it's like that in other countries as well, not just Thailand.

Normal Thai rice sells for about $1.70 per kilo in Europe, which is $1700 per tonne. Thai farmers get about $320 per tonne.

There isn't a whole lot done to the rice from when the farmers deliver it until it lands at the grocery store. Certainly not enough to justify a 500% increase.

Of course, other people might have a different opinion, but that's just mine.

  • Like 1
Posted

Anyone else finds peculiar that all these red shirt leaders are superrich. I mean this is a country where the average salary is like what.... 30-50k per month?

Yet the last few days I have seen red shirt leaders depositing millions and millions of baht at GSB, BAAC as if they are somehow better businessmen than people like Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Warren Buffett.

Posted

Anyone else finds peculiar that all these red shirt leaders are superrich. I mean this is a country where the average salary is like what.... 30-50k per month?

Yet the last few days I have seen red shirt leaders depositing millions and millions of baht at GSB, BAAC as if they are somehow better businessmen than people like Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Warren Buffett.

Some have MP salaries. But when you look at Jatuporn who has become a millionaire working as a 'political activist' it would seem that 'mercenary' should be included in any job title.

Posted

I think a lot of people are reevaluating their loyalties right now....and many who where setting on the fence are jumping off to one side or the other.

I dont think its jumping off tje fence to one side at all since many of these people want nothing to do with Suthep. I think people have seen the light concerning this rice scheme and have decided enough is enough. When the gov started playing their games trying to borrow the peoples money the people got scared. Knowing YL and her scheme has already cleaned out the coffers they dont want their money gone also.

Cheers up for those employees who take a stand to protect he dimwitted REDS from making a mistake by taking a chance to lose more of their money on YLs scams ( i mean schemes)

Sent from my GT-S5310 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Posted (edited)

Ha,Ha, Ha...

The intelligent thing to do would have been to ask them where they got the money? that what would happen in the UK if one was to deposit large amounts of money, as banks are required to do by anti money laundering legislation.

Edited by Basil B
  • Like 1
Posted

And just where did the 30 million come from?

If I was a bank manager and someone walked in with 30 million, I would want to know where it came from

Who are these people? related to 'scareface"

Posted

Instead of complaining about what Puea Thai hasn't done for this country, you should compare them with others like the Democrats before them.

I am not saying Puea Thai is perfect, but the best of the available options. If a better party comes along, I will gladly reconsider my opinion but it just doesn't exist right now.

And I stand by my opinion that the rice millers are ripping the farmers off, but it's like that in other countries as well, not just Thailand.

Normal Thai rice sells for about $1.70 per kilo in Europe, which is $1700 per tonne. Thai farmers get about $320 per tonne.

There isn't a whole lot done to the rice from when the farmers deliver it until it lands at the grocery store. Certainly not enough to justify a 500% increase.

Of course, other people might have a different opinion, but that's just mine.

As I recall, the Dems had a scheme in which a price was set in place and if the farmers sold the rice for lower than that price, the government would pay them the difference. No muss, no fuss. No rice changing hands and rotting away in storage.

Look at this current scam. Set the prices too high and now you can't sell the rice and you can't pay the farmers. Admit it. The scheme FAILED miserably. It's amazing red idiots still have the cheek to defend it.

Why do you feel the need to insult me and call me an idiot just because we have different opinions?

  • Like 1
Posted

Instead of complaining about what Puea Thai hasn't done for this country, you should compare them with others like the Democrats before them.

I am not saying Puea Thai is perfect, but the best of the available options. If a better party comes along, I will gladly reconsider my opinion but it just doesn't exist right now.

And I stand by my opinion that the rice millers are ripping the farmers off, but it's like that in other countries as well, not just Thailand.

Normal Thai rice sells for about $1.70 per kilo in Europe, which is $1700 per tonne. Thai farmers get about $320 per tonne.

There isn't a whole lot done to the rice from when the farmers deliver it until it lands at the grocery store. Certainly not enough to justify a 500% increase.

Of course, other people might have a different opinion, but that's just mine.

As I recall, the Dems had a scheme in which a price was set in place and if the farmers sold the rice for lower than that price, the government would pay them the difference. No muss, no fuss. No rice changing hands and rotting away in storage.

Look at this current scam. Set the prices too high and now you can't sell the rice and you can't pay the farmers. Admit it. The scheme FAILED miserably. It's amazing red idiots still have the cheek to defend it.

Why do you feel the need to insult me and call me an idiot just because we have different opinions?

I wasn't calling you an idiot, I was calling the reds idiots.

Posted

As always one of issues in Thailand is that nothing is driven by ethics or law or concept. Everything is driven by clan allegiance. Does not matter what the clan leader says or believes, whatever he/she says even as it changes from day to day, the people will believe.

As far as Asian countries go, Thailand is normally top-heavy with the leaders having a very large responsibility for the downline people, but unlike better Asian countries with similar overall systems like Japan, Korea China etc Thailand's leaders are typically not very well educated and certainly not honest or ethical.

Posted

It's quite funny this - years ago when someone turned up at a bank with a big wad of cash and the bank wanted to know where it came from (which they are legally obligated to do >5k in the UK) they usually said I won it on the horses (bookies) but of course you can't really say that here lol

Posted

This is not the PDRC's fault. This highlights this is not the PDRC's fault. To reiterate, this is not Sutheps fault.

Blame the PTP and the Red Shirts. Start to show some accountability. The whole reason the regime is in this situation is because they have never accepted blame. Never said "We made a mistake". People make mistakes. It is human nature. I can see in a way why they won't admit it though. They are not human. They are dogs.

It's NEVER the PDRC's fault. Everything is ALWAYS the government's fault. Somebody watching a bit too much BlueSky tonight?

The Puea Thai and Red Shirts not being human is going a bit too far, even for someone like you, don't you think? But then again, this is the kind of brainwashing that Suthep and the PDRC do to people. Causing divide in the nation, stirring hate and branding insults in the minds of ordinary gullible people.

djjamie is a perfect example of a brainwashed foreigner, folks.

Whereas promising ordinary gullible people that they will be rich in six months (two and a half years ago) has just worked wonders hasn't it?

The poor rice farmers (assuming you're referring to them) have made more money in the past 3 years selling their rice to the government than they would have made by selling it to the rice mills that have ripped them off for the past decades.

For normal rice, they got about 10,500 Baht per tonne at the rice mills, while the government paid them 15,000 per tonne. For Hom Mali rice, the government even pays 20,000 Baht.

They didn't get "rich", but I don't think the government promised that anywhere. They however did get more money over the past years than they would have gotten by selling the rice to the rip-off mills.

The rice scheme has worked well for them for the past 3 years. I see people screaming that the government is bankrupt due to the rice scheme and that's just not the truth. There are many reputable sources that state quite the contrary. The Thai government is far from bankrupt. What you lose with one government program, you make up for with the next.

I am not saying that the rice scheme doesn't lose money, but anyone that thinks every government program only makes money and none of them lose any clearly has no idea. There are government programs in the US and EU that also lose money, but they make up for those losses elsewhere.

And what was the world market price?

the Miller and exporter has to make money as well.

ripped them off.. right!!

Agriculture subsidies occur all over the world true. But most help rather than hinder .. Thailand has gone from number 1 rice exporter to number 3. With the reputation of Thai high quality rice shattered due in the inefficiency and corruption endemic in the scheme. .. I don't think any one has a major problem with a well thought out agriculture subsidy scheme.

Also why was it only rice farmers that got the bulk of subsidies??

Sent from my XT1032 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Ah, but now there is the nub of the problem. How much does the miller deserve to make for his middle man.

I used to be one in another industry and the margins in thailand are very very handsome.

I agree with you. But this is just one Govt program which is the most obvious. There are all the other, i.e Flood prevention, etc they all need scrutiny and now this huge infrastructure proposal which you will probably admit is significantly big enough.

The growing perception (fear) is that the entire Govt is likely to be run like the rice scheme.

Posted

Like I just said in another thread, everyone hates the red shirts.....lol

What a gem of a report. I live in Korat, I will call in to that bank tomorrow and shake their hands.

The BAAC do not want these stupid stunts going on in their banks, they don't need to be pulled into the same crap that has seen the GSB have 105 billion baht of its net liquidity removed in 4 days, wonder how much after today?

These sort of stupid stunts can see a run on the BAAC as well, which only has 110 billion liquidity because the government have snatched away 180 billion liquidity already. It won't take much to break that bank either.

Well done BAAC, continue to just be a payment vehicle, but don't get dragged into sup[porting the scheme, lest you suffer the backlash from depositors.

I know some of the terrorist red supporting farang gang will try to mock my post regarding a run, but I suppose these will be the same people who mocked me when I was explaining what could happen to the GSB which I ended up being 100% correct..... By the way guys, I am still predicting the GSB going down, less than 50% liquidity remaining.

Edit: Wife just spoke to a friend on her facebook chat who works there, the girl who told them to get out, actually was praised by the manager. They want nothing to do with supporting the rice scam any more. I have told her to get a message to the girl, to meet us for a drink, I am buying.

SACK the staff that did this, You say don't get dragged into the politics of this situation, but isn't that exactly what the staff did? blink.png not to smart huh...

Staff should do their job. if you don't like the policy of the company you work for then move on,

Posted

i think very good.

we not need this people money.

REALLY, "you don't need these people money"

OK the donations that the south got from the people in the north after floods year after year, give it back,

Donations after the tsunami give it back, cause you don't need it, you should think about who grows the rice you eat the sugar you use, that also go in your beer so stop drinking that also you don't need it, also you should not use the 30 medical scheme as that would support a Thaksin policy, you can't use Swampy airport as that was a Thaksin project that finally finished it, also your kids can't borrow money from uni for their education as that also a Thaksin policy, the low interest loans to stop the loan sharking guess who YU'P Mr T, BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR YOU JUST MIGHT GET IT!!!!!w00t.gif

  • Like 1
Posted

Instead of complaining about what Puea Thai hasn't done for this country, you should compare them with others like the Democrats before them.

I am not saying Puea Thai is perfect, but the best of the available options. If a better party comes along, I will gladly reconsider my opinion but it just doesn't exist right now.

And I stand by my opinion that the rice millers are ripping the farmers off, but it's like that in other countries as well, not just Thailand.

Normal Thai rice sells for about $1.70 per kilo in Europe, which is $1700 per tonne. Thai farmers get about $320 per tonne.

There isn't a whole lot done to the rice from when the farmers deliver it until it lands at the grocery store. Certainly not enough to justify a 500% increase.

Of course, other people might have a different opinion, but that's just mine.

The rice millers that have been ripping the farmers off for decades (and are still doing it) are owned by rich locals, not by the "Bangkok elite". The farmers need to be looking a bit closer to home to see who is ripping them off.

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.




×
×
  • Create New...