Jump to content
All visa questions and fresh Immigration updates here ×

Tai Yai people ar not Thai, dont consider themselves to be Thai and are not considered Thai by Thais.

Goat

By Goat
in ASEAN NOW Community Pub

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Popular Post
Goat Gold Member

Goat

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted

Yesterday there was a story about a Swedish bloke getting thrown in a ditch by three Tai Yai kids. Some of our bar stool posters who predictably rant about Thais jumped on this and seem to be confused.

 

Tai Yai are a seperate ethnic group with no home country and as such are spread throughout Laos, Northern Thailand, Southern China and Myanmar.

They have their own cuisine, traditions, culture, language, dance, music etc.

 

They are not Thai. Even if they are born in Thailand they dont recieve a Thai ID card, but get a special one. They are also restricted like other foreigners in what jobs they are allowed to do and even travelling to other parts of Thailand is restricted.

 

They are nice people. Below I have provided an educational video for those who dont know the difference. 

 

Tai Yai women are very skilled at lovemaking from my experience with not a feminist bone in their bodies.

 

 

  • Like 4
  • Love It 1
  • Thumbs Up 2
  • Haha 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Popular Post
Mac Mickmanus Star Member

Mac Mickmanus

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted
21 minutes ago, Goat said:

They are not Thai. Even if they are born in Thailand they dont recieve a Thai ID card, but get a special one. They are also restricted like other foreigners in what jobs they are allowed to do and even travelling to other parts of Thailand is restricted.

That was the case 20 odd years ago . 

These days Tai Yai people are given Thai I.D if they were born in Thailand and been through he compulsory schooling system , 

   Even Tai Yai people who haven't been through the schooling system and cannot prove that they were born in Thailand can still get Thai I.D if they can pass a few tests 

 The Thai Government has recently rapidly been giving out Thai I.D to numerous ethnic minority kids (with no Thai I.D) even since the cave rescue when the only kid who could speak English was a kid with no Nationality to any Country and he couldn't get a passport to go abroad .

   The Thai Government has taken measures to end statelessness in Thailand and the stateless people have been and are currently being  given Thai I.D .

   

  • Like 4
  • Thumbs Up 2
  • Thanks 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jackbenimble Advanced Member

Jackbenimble

Posted
Posted (edited)

You need to change your source - this is nolonger the case and hasn't been the case for a long time. Tai Yai isn't a state so when a TaiYai is born if they want an ID card they choose to be either Thai or Burmese and make the necessary application. As it is an area right next to  both borders the residents are both Thai and Burmese. Some never bother to get an ID card but most do these days. 

Edited by Jackbenimble
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Danderman123 Star Member

Danderman123

Posted
Posted

Tai Yai does not just refer to people who speak a Thai-related language in the Shan state in Myanmar, it also refers to other Tai Yai speakers in China (Zuong).

 

There are millions of Zuong people in China, descendants of Thais who chose not to emigrate South and stayed put.

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Thumbs Up 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Goat Gold Member

Goat

Posted
  • Author
Posted
3 hours ago, Mac Mickmanus said:

That was the case 20 odd years ago . 

These days Tai Yai people are given Thai I.D if they were born in Thailand and been through he compulsory schooling system , 

   Even Tai Yai people who haven't been through the schooling system and cannot prove that they were born in Thailand can still get Thai I.D if they can pass a few tests 

 The Thai Government has recently rapidly been giving out Thai I.D to numerous ethnic minority kids (with no Thai I.D) even since the cave rescue when the only kid who could speak English was a kid with no Nationality to any Country and he couldn't get a passport to go abroad .

   The Thai Government has taken measures to end statelessness in Thailand and the stateless people have been and are currently being  given Thai I.D .

   

Thanks for that update. One of my Tai Yai lovers plied me with opium (fin) and during an extended love making session talked me into driving her to the Immigration Office, which obviously a Thai citzen would have no reason to.

She was born in Thailand. She had a pink ID card and was not allowed to travel with me to other provinces.

I am glad things have improved for them. Top people.

  • Like 1
  • Confused 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Enoon Gold Member

Enoon

Posted
Posted (edited)

????

8 hours ago, Jackbenimble said:

You need to change your source - this is nolonger the case and hasn't been the case for a long time. Tai Yai isn't a state so when a TaiYai is born if they want an ID card they choose to be either Thai or Burmese and make the necessary application. As it is an area right next to  both borders the residents are both Thai and Burmese. Some never bother to get an ID card but most do these days. 

It is not "an area right next to both borders". It is an homogenous area that the NATIONAL border bisects, that the border cuts through, that the border divides.

 

The borders are artificial, the TAI ETHNICITY is not.

 

That is the CURSE of NATIONALISM.

 

THAILAND is resultant upon a powerful TAI sub-group, who had their power base in and around the central region, imposing their ideas of a NATION STATE upon everyone else.

 

That is the cause of the Southern fight against THAI NATIONALISM.

 

That is why Isaan LAO people resent the THAI NATIONALISTS

 

That is why people from Wales and Scotland fume when a foreigner mistakenly identifies them as English, who historically imposed themselves upon their neighbouring ethnicities.

 

The resultant BRITISH state was/is as artificial as the THAI state.

 

The people of Ireland resented the English dominated state that invaded and occupied them so much that they fought a war to remove it.

 

Thailand is a NATIONALIST construct, with borders that cut through and across many homogenous ethnicities that resent it.

 

SIAM was a multi-ethnic political entity......too untidy for nationalists. It had to go.

 

That is what NATIONALISM does......it is the ambition of the few imposed on the many......historically and presently, invariably, by FORCE.

 

 

????

 

Edited by Enoon
  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Enoon Gold Member

Enoon

Posted
Posted (edited)
39 minutes ago, Enoon said:

????

It is not "an area right next to both borders". It is an homogenous area that the NATIONAL border bisects, that the border cuts through, that the border divides.

 

The borders are artificial, the TAI ETHNICITY is not.

 

That is the CURSE of NATIONALISM.

 

THAILAND is resultant upon a powerful TAI sub-group, who had their power base in and around the central region, imposing their ideas of a NATION STATE upon everyone else.

 

That is the cause of the Southern fight against THAI NATIONALISM.

 

That is why Isaan LAO people resent the THAI NATIONALISTS

 

That is why people from Wales and Scotland fume when a foreigner mistakenly identifies them as English, who historically imposed themselves upon their neighbouring ethnicities.

 

The resultant BRITISH state was/is as artificial as the THAI state.

 

The people of Ireland resented the English dominated state that invaded and occupied them so much that they fought a war to remove it.

 

Thailand is a NATIONALIST construct, with borders that cut through and across many homogenous ethnicities that resent it.

 

SIAM was a multi-ethnic political entity......too untidy for nationalists. It had to go.

 

That is what NATIONALISM does......it is the ambition of the few imposed on the many......historically and presently, invariably, by FORCE.

 

 

????

 

And next door, in Burma, the nationalists did/do the same.

 

Thai nationalists would just love to unleash that sort of horror upon their "restive"........subjects. 

 

Subjects

2.  "to bring (a person or country) under one's control or jurisdiction, typically by using force."

 

 

 

Edited by Enoon
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jackbenimble Advanced Member

Jackbenimble

Posted
Posted
15 hours ago, Enoon said:

????

It is not "an area right next to both borders". It is an homogenous area that the NATIONAL border bisects, that the border cuts through, that the border divides.

 

The borders are artificial, the TAI ETHNICITY is not.

 

That is the CURSE of NATIONALISM.

 

THAILAND is resultant upon a powerful TAI sub-group, who had their power base in and around the central region, imposing their ideas of a NATION STATE upon everyone else.

 

That is the cause of the Southern fight against THAI NATIONALISM.

 

That is why Isaan LAO people resent the THAI NATIONALISTS

 

That is why people from Wales and Scotland fume when a foreigner mistakenly identifies them as English, who historically imposed themselves upon their neighbouring ethnicities.

 

The resultant BRITISH state was/is as artificial as the THAI state.

 

The people of Ireland resented the English dominated state that invaded and occupied them so much that they fought a war to remove it.

 

Thailand is a NATIONALIST construct, with borders that cut through and across many homogenous ethnicities that resent it.

 

SIAM was a multi-ethnic political entity......too untidy for nationalists. It had to go.

 

That is what NATIONALISM does......it is the ambition of the few imposed on the many......historically and presently, invariably, by FORCE.

 

 

????

 

feel better for that?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.







×
×
  • Create New...