Passport checks at BigC Onnut

[Lorry]

As told by a local vendor:

2 farang were checked near BigC, they didn't carry their passport. The police (?) wanted 5000, after some bargaining settled for 3000 per person. 

The vendor found it too much.

[couchpotato]

  On 9/27/2023 at 5:51 PM, Lorry said:

As told by a local vendor:

2 farang were checked near BigC, they didn't carry their passport. The police (?) wanted 5000, after some bargaining settled for 3000 per person. 

The vendor found it too much.

Expand  

Hogwash..... made up story

[d4dang]

real cops or?

[Lorry]

  On 9/27/2023 at 7:05 PM, d4dang said:

real cops or?

Expand  

Good question. I don't know. 

I know only what I posted.  I posted it because it's an area where many foreigners live, and not everybody is carrying his passport when going to BigC.

 

[SuperSaiyan]

Fake.

[still kicking]

  On 9/27/2023 at 8:13 PM, SuperSaiyan said:

Fake.

Expand  

Cops or Quote?

[rwill]

I have a copy of my passport in my wallet.

[Bangkok Barry]

In the headline the poster wrote he says at Big C. He then says near Big C. There's a difference. I'm guessing this is a troll from someone who didn't even see what happened himself but was 'told' by a vendor.

 

Nothing to see here, folks.... Move on.

[Albaby]

  On 9/28/2023 at 5:45 AM, rwill said:

I have a copy of my passport in my wallet.

Expand  

I just carry my pink ID card.

[timendres]

Lived on Suk 81 for 4 years. Went to the Big-C too many times to count.

Not once, ever, did I see police anywhere near Big-C, Century, or BTS station asking anyone for ID.

[foreverlomsak]

  On 9/28/2023 at 5:45 AM, rwill said:

I have a copy of my passport in my wallet.

Expand  

Was informed by 3 armed and uniformed Immigration Officers, who had stopped me in the street, that carrying a copy of the passport was not acceptable (as it could be faked), that all foreigners must carry their passports on them when away from home, and I was only 9km away in my local town, I proffered along with the photocopy my Pink Card and Driving License they were waved away with the comment means nothing to us.

Wrong place wrong time, I think they'd just been checking a hotel for foreign residents and failed to find one, so homed in on me.

[Ben Zioner]

  On 9/28/2023 at 6:08 AM, Albaby said:

I just carry my pink ID card.

Expand  

I Just wear clean underpants..

[trainman34014]

All nonsense; it is not a lagal rquirement to carry your Passport.   Should this happen it would be advisable to insist that you be taken to the Police Station where the so called 'Cops' operate from.  Carrying a Photcopy of your Passport is a good idea but again, is not a legal requirement !

[impulse]

I've no reason to doubt the veracity or accuracy of the OP's warning.  These threads crop up occasionally, though usually it was the cops around Asoke.  I actually witnessed some shake downs around Asoke years ago where people were stopped on the sidewalk and others were pulled out of taxis at red lights for ID checks.  Got so prevalent one time that one top cop came out and stated that carrying a copy of your passport was acceptable, followed by another who said it had to be the original.

 

Given the stories about cracking down on foreign workers and increasing security in light of the new visa free policy, it wouldn't surprise me if some local cops were either being over-zealous or downright crooked at the end of the month when rent is due.  And that's assuming they were real cops.  Also had a recent story about fake cops holding a lady for ransom... 

 

 

 

[kidneyw]

I have a picture of my passport and visa on my phone just in case.

[owl sees all]

Wanted to pay two leccy bills in Big C late last month. Could not unless I showed passport or pink ID.

[Tropicalevo]

  On 9/28/2023 at 7:06 AM, trainman34014 said:

All nonsense; it is not a lagal rquirement to carry your Passport.   Should this happen it would be advisable to insist that you be taken to the Police Station where the so called 'Cops' operate from.  Carrying a Photcopy of your Passport is a good idea but again, is not a legal requirement !

Expand  

It is a legal requirement for all foreigners to carry a photo id document that is currently accepted in Thailand.

Same rule for Thais.

[ChipButty]

  On 9/28/2023 at 8:25 AM, owl sees all said:

Wanted to pay two leccy bills in Big C late last month. Could not unless I showed passport or pink ID.

Expand  

pay online like we do, 

[ChipButty]

Around Tong Lor was famous even years ago for getting pulled, I used to hear alsorts of stories, 

[impulse]

  On 9/28/2023 at 8:49 AM, ChipButty said:

Around Tong Lor was famous even years ago for getting pulled, I used to hear alsorts of stories, 

Expand  

I witnessed a few myself.  Even stopping taxis at red lights and pulling the foreigners out for ID checks.  But that was all pre-Covid.  Maybe they've started it up again now that the pickings are getting richer.  More short time tourists who wouldn't know to ask for a ride to the cop shop to straighten it out.

 

[brianthainess]

  On 9/27/2023 at 5:51 PM, Lorry said:

The police (?) wanted 5000, after some bargaining settled for 3000 per person. 

Expand  

Why would you pay them? the legal fine is about 1k TTBOMK.

[brianthainess]

If you can "Bargain'' them down, then of course its a scam.

[Lorry]

  On 9/28/2023 at 6:21 AM, timendres said:

Lived on Suk 81 for 4 years. Went to the Big-C too many times to count.

Not once, ever, did I see police anywhere near Big-C, Century, or BTS station asking anyone for ID.

Expand  

That's exactly the reason why I posted it.

 

[StayinThailand2much]

  On 9/28/2023 at 8:25 AM, owl sees all said:

Wanted to pay two leccy bills in Big C late last month. Could not unless I showed passport or pink ID.

Expand  

This is becoming quite common. Pay bills, or even into your own bank account - asked for passport...

[Lorry]

  On 9/28/2023 at 6:02 AM, Bangkok Barry said:

In the headline the poster wrote he says at Big C. He then says near Big C. There's a difference. I'm guessing this is a troll from someone who didn't even see what happened himself but was 'told' by a vendor.

 

Nothing to see here, folks.... Move on.

Expand  

Sorry for my English.

 

https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/296174/at-a-shop-or-in-a-shop

"At the shop" tells the listener you are in or close enough to the shop to be considered on the premises.

"In the shop" is more specific and tells the listener you are within the walls of the shop.

So,"in" would not have been correct.

The difference between "at" and "near" seems to depend on the definition of "premises".

Maybe you visit the place and draw a map of the premises (to scale,  please). In the meantime,  I will ask that vendor where exactly (inches, please!) this happened.

Then we can discuss whether "at" or "near" was the correct preposition 

 

[owl sees all]

  On 9/28/2023 at 8:46 AM, ChipButty said:

pay online like we do, 

Expand  

Too complicated for me to do that. Bar codes and those square dotted things give me the jips.

[Bangkok Barry]

  On 9/28/2023 at 10:35 AM, Lorry said:

Sorry for my English.

 

https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/296174/at-a-shop-or-in-a-shop

"At the shop" tells the listener you are in or close enough to the shop to be considered on the premises.

"In the shop" is more specific and tells the listener you are within the walls of the shop.

So,"in" would not have been correct.

The difference between "at" and "near" seems to depend on the definition of "premises".

Maybe you visit the place and draw a map of the premises (to scale,  please). In the meantime,  I will ask that vendor where exactly (inches, please!) this happened.

Then we can discuss whether "at" or "near" was the correct preposition 

 

Expand  

You still reported something that is hearsay, wherever what you didn't witness did or did not happen.

[Lorry]

  On 9/28/2023 at 11:36 AM, Bangkok Barry said:

You still reported something that is hearsay, wherever what you didn't witness did or did not happen.

Expand  

Correct.

BTW I heard Thailand has a new government - hearsay, I didn't witness it.

I also heard if you murder someone you might end up in prison - hearsay, has never happened to me.

Don't get me talking about the moon landing...or the discovery of America 

[JoseThailand]

On Nut has become an expat ghetto. So many foreigners and especially Russians are living there because it's cheap and convenient. I'm not surprised some unscrupulous police may target foreigners to get some easy money.

[Bangkok Barry]

  On 9/28/2023 at 11:54 AM, Lorry said:

Correct.

BTW I heard Thailand has a new government - hearsay, I didn't witness it.

I also heard if you murder someone you might end up in prison - hearsay, has never happened to me.

Don't get me talking about the moon landing...

Expand  

Sorry, your misunderstanding of English strikes again. The new Thai government is a FACT. Murderers DO end up in prison, FACT. They are not hearsay, which my dictionary describes as rumour. Neither of the two examples you give me are rumours. Fact and hearsay are very different things, which clearly you fail to understand. Just drop it before you dig another hole. You said two different things in the headline and opening post. Just accept it instead of sending me sarcastic posts.