Young Doctors Slam Supreme Court's Definition of Woman as "Biologically Nonsensical"

[Luuk Chaai]

12 hours ago, Tug said:

Here we go with our weekly dose of attack the gays sad 😞 

being gay has absolutely nothing to do with being a total idiot

[richard_smith237]

4 hours ago, Huayyai said:

KhunLA: Never heard of Klinefelter Syndrome (XXY)?

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/klinefelter-syndrome/symptoms-causes/syc-20353949

4 hours ago, Huayyai said:

KhunLA: Never heard of Klinefelter Syndrome (XXY)?

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/klinefelter-syndrome/symptoms-causes/syc-20353949

 

There exists an exceptionally small minority whose genetics and biological reality place them genuinely between the traditional sexes - and they deserve understanding, compassion, and respectful treatment.

 

But, let’s be honest: the loud, performative trans activists dominating the conversation seem entirely detached from these rare, legitimate cases....   If anything, they undermine genuine issues and do more harm than good to the cause they claim to represent.

 

[connda]

16 hours ago, Social Media said:

The British Medical Association’s resident doctors have strongly criticised a recent Supreme Court ruling that defines a woman strictly by biological sex, labelling the decision “scientifically illiterate” and “biologically nonsensical.”

So today's Millennial and Gen-X doctors in the UK all failed Biology.  No wonder the NHS is self-imploding.

[connda]

This is a horse.  You don't believe me?  Well, if you don't believe this is a horse then you're “scientifically illiterate” and “biologically nonsensical".  If I say this is a horse, then goddamnit, it's a horse!


Now let me show you a cow.  Check out the udders on this one.


Let's try a pit of vipers.

 

In that case, I guess this is a woman.

[Paradise Pete]

14 hours ago, Gsxrnz said:

The leftist radicals deny religion in favor of science being the arbiter of life, the universe, and everything.

 

You say that as if it's a bad thing.

 

Quote

And then deny science when it doesn't agree with their ideology.

 

Completely backwards. That's exactly what she's talking about.

[StandardIssue]

14 hours ago, KhunLA said:

Agree, life long visits and meds, instead of a couple days talking to a shrink, and realizing, they are not a women, and just gay, bi, and or cross-dresser.

 

Cured  

Wow, you and Archie Bunker would make a great pair. How completely short sided and sophomoric can one be? How can you even think that your experience could even come close to someone else's?

 

While biologically a man is a man and a woman is a woman, their mental state and why they identify as opposite their biological gender is something nobody but that person can experience. How completely un-empathetic and ill informed to think that a couple days of "talking to a shrink" would somehow make it all better or change them.

 

Have you finally found a place where people understand just how important you think you are?

[Tug]

10 hours ago, Luuk Chaai said:

being gay has absolutely nothing to do with being a total idiot

I agree we all know the difference it’s on the face of it a rediclous subject but it does feed the angst of the rabble.

[Bkk Brian]

13 minutes ago, Tug said:

I agree we all know the difference it’s on the face of it a rediclous subject but it does feed the angst of the rabble.

It's the doctors complaing at the Supreme court decision they are indeed rabble

[mikeymike100]

17 hours ago, klauskunkel said:

The union’s resident doctors have now collectively identified as Idiots, and I doubt that the Supreme Court will intervene with the doctors' definition of themselves.

Absolutely, so the phrase....'trust me I'm a doctor' ....is a big fat lie!

[seajae]

1 hour ago, Tug said:

I agree we all know the difference it’s on the face of it a rediclous subject but it does feed the angst of the rabble.

most of the rabble realizes that this has nothing to do with being gay, it is a mental condition and the trans community have ruined what the LGB community has been doing for many years. There is nothing wrong with being gay, I have had many gay friends over many years and they have all been great people, there is also nothing wrong with those that want to be more feminine and do so without involving others. The problem is with the trans people that expect to be able to get all the same privileges as real women, be able to use female bathrooms etc and enter female sports etc, they are making a mockery of real women/girls as they are MEN and refuse to accept they are mentally damaged while running down the actual females. Anyone that supports men being called women are also mentally damaged as it is physically impossible for them to actually be a female.

[WDSmart]

15 hours ago, Eloquent pilgrim said:

16 hours ago, WDSmart said:

I agree. The demand that gender be only male and female is not biologically sound

 

Really; then please tell me what other biological genders there are apart from male and female …. many thanks

"Male" and "female" are the two polar ends of the gender spectrum, which is biologically defined using physical traits, chromosomes, and hormones. All of us, including you and me, are somewhere in between the "perfect" extremes of male and female. I admit that most of us are very close to one of the extremes, but there are a significant number that are closer to one of the extremes, and a few that are closer to the middle. "Male" and "female" biologically, are to gender as "tall" and "short" are to height. There are a lot of people in between.  

[WDSmart]

16 hours ago, Jimjim1 said:

Well I disagree, those who as you say are somewhere in between are actually people with an identity crisis who’s mentality precludes them from identifying within themselves who they really are and therefore fall victim to a mummy syndrome wherein they hide behind the easy strategy of believing they are woman the softer more gentle sex as we are led to believe by woke exponents who would whole heartedly believe that there really is a man in the moon if it fulfilled their particular agenda.

I disagree with you. I believe the people who say they are somewhere in between have different physical, chromosomal, and/or hormonal levels than those who claim to be one or the other.  

[Eloquent pilgrim]

5 minutes ago, WDSmart said:

"Male" and "female" are the two polar ends of the gender spectrum, which is biologically defined using physical traits, chromosomes, and hormones. All of us, including you and me, are somewhere in between the "perfect" extremes of male and female. I admit that most of us are very close to one of the extremes, but there are a significant number that are closer to one of the extremes, and a few that are closer to the middle. "Male" and "female" biologically, are to gender as "tall" and "short" are to height. There are a lot of people in between.  

 

 

I asked you to tell me another gender, apart from male and female, that is biologically defined; this, despite your waffling and obfuscation, you have completely failed to do.

 

 

 

 

[WDSmart]

14 hours ago, Sierra Tango said:

Absolute nonsense. Biology, science equates to proven fact. Until proven otherwise, fairy land illusions about some other mystical genders existing are exactly that, fairy land illusions.

You obviously know nothing about biology. It is not a digital-either/or approach. It is an analog/curved line approach.  

[WDSmart]

14 hours ago, BangkokReady said:

 

So, because there is a very small number of people who are intersex, and are labelled as intersex, men should be able to say they are women and for it to be considered medically true?

Men (or women) should not be able to just "say" they are women (men) to make it medically true. They would have to undergo a medical diagnosis on their physical attributes, chromosomes, and/or hormone levels, to make their claim medically true. 

The real problem is not whether their claims are medically true. The real problem is can they just "say" they are women or men to make that SOCIALLY true.

[WDSmart]

11 minutes ago, Eloquent pilgrim said:

 

 

I asked you to tell me another gender, apart from male and female, that is biologically defined; this, despite your waffling and obfuscation, you have completely failed to do.

 

 

 

 

Androgyny is the term used for people who are a mix of male/female. 

[KhunLA]

On 4/30/2025 at 8:25 AM, Tug said:

Here we go with our weekly dose of attack the gays sad 😞 

Didn't read any attacks on gays.   

 

If you're  bi or gay man and enjoy having sex with men, then enjoy.  Just don't try to tell me you enjoy men, because you're a women.  You're simply gay or bi.  If you enjoy acting and dressing like a women, you're still not a woman or transitioning into one.  You're just a bit different.   Enjoy your uniqueness 

[Jimjim1]

3 hours ago, WDSmart said:

I disagree with you. I believe the people who say they are somewhere in between have different physical, chromosomal, and/or hormonal levels than those who claim to be one or the other.  

You are entitled to agree or disagree at will as am I, but as I see it the only spanner in the works is the person born with both parts, the Hermaphrodite who were usually defined at birth by the medical profession and the parents and decisions made upon what that person will be brought up to be, male or female and medical intervention ensued, However these days those decisions will be delayed so that the person can decide to keep or lose the bits and therein lies the possible third gender.

Perhaps the saddest happening in recent times is the report in the press of the biologically born woman transitioned to boob removal and male hormone treatment grew a beard but did not go the whole hog and who produced a child.

Mentally mixed up ? You decide

[pacovl46]

On 4/30/2025 at 10:54 AM, LukKrueng said:

There are many people on the world that don't like the way they look, don't like their bodies for many different reasons. But as much as I don't like Trump, he's absolutely correct by saying there are only 2 sexes. Male and female. When a person starts barking it doesn't mean he's a dog. When a man dress up and behave as a woman, it doesn't make him a woman. Cutting of some parts of the body for no other reason but just to play a role - that's insane in my opinion.

Well, you are just not capable of getting it then and that’s on you! It doesn’t change the fact, though, that some people are transgender. Although, I agree when it comes to sex, there’s only two genders, but this is about gender identity and not biological sex. 

[pacovl46]

23 hours ago, KhunLA said:

Really ... don't think so.  'trans'  .... Please tell me what they are transitioning to.  

 

You are born male or female, you are male or female, you will die male or female.

 

You can not transition to a different sex.  You can take drugs, lop things off & add fake things, to look differently, but your sex will never change.  You will always be either XX or XY.

 

Your sexual preferences and or attire is you personal choice, but you don't get to choose you sex.  If you think you can ... you may want to seek professional help.

 

Subject is not debatable.  

 

HAVE A NICE DAY

Well, you’re confusing biological sex with gender identity and that’s the problem. And you’re right, it’s not debatable, transgender people exist, and whether you can get your head around that doesn’t change the fact! 

[pacovl46]

21 hours ago, Eloquent pilgrim said:

 

Utter nonsense; there are only two biological sexes, and sex is decided at conception and recognised at birth, or sometimes before; this is immutable.

 

It is patently absurd to claim that anyone is born transgender; it is an illness that people develop later, often in their formative years. This is why it is vitally important that any literature or paraphernalia about transgenderism is kept well away from developing children, and banned from all schools. Societies have more than enough cases of mental illness, without giving children literature to encourage more.

 

 

 

Oh, I just love it when people who know nothing about a subject matter think they’re the authority on said subject matter. 
 

You’re confusing biological sex with gender identity. Yes, biologically speaking there are only two genders, and while you can get a sex change, biologically speaking you’re still the sex you were born with. No one is disputing that. But this is about gender identity and they absolutely identify as the opposite sex they were born with and that’s a fact. And that’s exactly what you don’t get/don’t want to get! 

[pacovl46]

19 hours ago, BangkokReady said:

 

They cannot opt to be biological the other sex.  That's the point.

 

 

They're real people, they just remain "trans X".

 

 

Because they want to do things that will cause danger or harm to others.

 

 

Because they generally don't want to do things that will cause danger or harm to others.

Well, I haven’t done a deep dive as to why they came to the conclusion that they might be biological women. 
 

They want to do things that will cause danger or harm to others?! Please elaborate on that. Can’t wait to hear this! 

[KhunLA]

20 minutes ago, pacovl46 said:

Well, you’re confusing biological sex with gender identity and that’s the problem. And you’re right, it’s not debatable, transgender people exist, and whether you can get your head around that doesn’t change the fact! 

Not confusing, just simply not accepting 'gender identity', as no such thing in my world.  And not debatable.  In my world there's 2 sex M & F, and 3 sexual preferences, straight, bi, gay.

 

The 72 gender BS, that's some serious mentally illness stuff.  

 

Have a nice day

[LukKrueng]

17 minutes ago, pacovl46 said:

Well, I haven’t done a deep dive as to why they came to the conclusion that they might be biological women. 
 

They want to do things that will cause danger or harm to others?! Please elaborate on that. Can’t wait to hear this! 

 

23 minutes ago, pacovl46 said:

Oh, I just love it when people who know nothing about a subject matter think they’re the authority on said subject matter. 
 

You’re confusing biological sex with gender identity. Yes, biologically speaking there are only two genders, and while you can get a sex change, biologically speaking you’re still the sex you were born with. No one is disputing that. But this is about gender identity and they absolutely identify as the opposite sex they were born with and that’s a fact. And that’s exactly what you don’t get/don’t want to get! 

 

28 minutes ago, pacovl46 said:

Well, you’re confusing biological sex with gender identity and that’s the problem. And you’re right, it’s not debatable, transgender people exist, and whether you can get your head around that doesn’t change the fact! 

 

33 minutes ago, pacovl46 said:

Well, you are just not capable of getting it then and that’s on you! It doesn’t change the fact, though, that some people are transgender. Although, I agree when it comes to sex, there’s only two genders, but this is about gender identity and not biological sex. 

Wow. So many confused people on AN. So good you're here to show us the way....

[BangkokReady]

2 hours ago, pacovl46 said:

They want to do things that will cause danger or harm to others?! Please elaborate on that. Can’t wait to hear this! 

 

This is ridiculous.  You cannot possibly be this dense.  There have been many examples of this.  Not only that, but you really only need to use your imagination to think about all the different situations that a woman might find herself in where having a male present might cause harm or put them into danger.

 

It's so disingenuous.  "Can't wait to hear this!"  Like you really don't know...  🤦‍♂️

[BangkokReady]

8 hours ago, WDSmart said:

The real problem is can they just "say" they are women or men to make that SOCIALLY true.

 

No.

[riclag]

On 4/30/2025 at 8:23 AM, JonnyF said:

 

Sounds like they need to raise the score required to pass the MLA exams. 

Brilliant 

[nick supreme]

Everyone knows that gender if fluid. 

[KhaoHom]

The law of the land was argued before the highest court.

 

The ridiculous notion men can be women (v versa) was dismissed.

 

For the sane - it was always done, but now it's clear as crystal.

 

Men don't get ovarian cancer. Men cannot have babies (unless you entertain the folly transmen are men). Women don't get testicular and prostrate cancer.

 

Why do we use the prefix.. trans?

 

Thai ladyboys quite openly acknowledge they are men. They show up to draft lottery as men

 

Not many transmen that are sanitation workers, rail workers, welders, construction housing, electrician, work a fishing boat, elite fighting corps...😉

 

The entire thing is just subterfuge.