ICE vs EV, the debate thread

[Yellowtail]

14 hours ago, Gweiloman said:

Sigh. Both my Ford Ranger and Isuzu imax still have an ignition slot for the key. At least the Isuzu can be push started if necessary.

Sigh. Yes, a lot of old clunkers do. 

 

My '53 Ford F100 had push-button start. 

 

I've had four Isuzus, but never an imax. I did see a sound-check sponsored by Isuzu sound-check at an imax theater though. 

[KhunLA]

Our 63 Chrysler had push button trans 

[billd766]

On 5/19/2024 at 4:32 PM, transam said:

I never hear here about EV problems, but it seems they do get problems......🤔

 

 

An interesting video.

 

It will probably be condemned as fake and untrue by the EV evangelists here.

 

Is it really fake and untrue? 

 

I have no idea, but unless it is fact checked and proven to be untrue. I personally tend to believe it. I have read reports from other sources that insurance for EVs is higher than for a similar ICE vehicle.

 

I have also read from some EV evangelists here that pro rata, EVs have a lower rate of spontaneous combustion than ICE vehicles by anywhere between 11 to 130 times. That seems to be an odd and somewhat vague figure to me.

[JBChiangRai]

31 minutes ago, billd766 said:

An interesting video.

 

It will probably be condemned as fake and untrue by the EV evangelists here.

 

Is it really fake and untrue? 

 

I have no idea, but unless it is fact checked and proven to be untrue. I personally tend to believe it. I have read reports from other sources that insurance for EVs is higher than for a similar ICE vehicle.

 

I have also read from some EV evangelists here that pro rata, EVs have a lower rate of spontaneous combustion than ICE vehicles by anywhere between 11 to 130 times. That seems to be an odd and somewhat vague figure to me.

 

I can't say if it's fake, it does sound a little hard to believe.  I am suspicious when we don't know the provenance of the video.

 

In terms of EV's having a much lower rate of combustion compared to ICE, lots of us have posted the stats and the links many. many times.  Only last week again in my case where I posted statistics from 4 different geographies.  11 to 130 times is erring on the side of caution, some countries it's up to 199 times.

[motdaeng]

3 hours ago, billd766 said:

An interesting video.

 

It will probably be condemned as fake and untrue by the EV evangelists here.

 

Is it really fake and untrue? 

 

I have no idea, but unless it is fact checked and proven to be untrue. I personally tend to believe it. I have read reports from other sources that insurance for EVs is higher than for a similar ICE vehicle.

 

I have also read from some EV evangelists here that pro rata, EVs have a lower rate of spontaneous combustion than ICE vehicles by anywhere between 11 to 130 times. That seems to be an odd and somewhat vague figure to me.

 

i asked chat gpt about this video :

 

The video "Broken EVs Head Straight to Junkyards As Repair Costs Are Unbearable!" from Chase Car highlights concerns about the high repair costs of electric vehicles (EVs) leading many to be scrapped instead of repaired. 

 

While it's true that some EVs can have expensive repairs, particularly for battery replacements, it's not universally the case. The video might be emphasizing extreme cases or specific models to make a broader point. The reality is more nuanced, with repair costs varying widely depending on the EV model and the nature of the damage.

 

For more detailed and balanced information, it's important to look at a variety of sources, including manufacturer data and independent repair cost analyses.

[KhunLA]

3 hours ago, billd766 said:

An interesting video.

 

It will probably be condemned as fake and untrue by the EV evangelists here.

 

Is it really fake and untrue? 

 

I have no idea, but unless it is fact checked and proven to be untrue. I personally tend to believe it. I have read reports from other sources that insurance for EVs is higher than for a similar ICE vehicle.

 

I have also read from some EV evangelists here that pro rata, EVs have a lower rate of spontaneous combustion than ICE vehicles by anywhere between 11 to 130 times. That seems to be an odd and somewhat vague figure to me.

I stopped early on, 15 seconds or so, when stated "EV are less reliable" ... 

Edited Tuesday at 10:22 AM by KhunLA

[Pib]

 

6 hours ago, billd766 said:

An interesting video.

 

It will probably be condemned as fake and untrue by the EV evangelists here.

 

Is it really fake and untrue? 

 

I have no idea, but unless it is fact checked and proven to be untrue. I personally tend to believe it. I have read reports from other sources that insurance for EVs is higher than for a similar ICE vehicle.

 

I have also read from some EV evangelists here that pro rata, EVs have a lower rate of spontaneous combustion than ICE vehicles by anywhere between 11 to 130 times. That seems to be an odd and somewhat vague figure to me.

 

Well, be sure to watch all the other videos on the channel...Chase Car....see their video list below...almost every one is negative on EVs.   And many of the videos---like the one we are talking about---are simply reruns with minor variations made to make it appear like late breaking news....click bait.  It just one of those youtube channels that is dedicated to negative/anti-EV videos....makes Mr Toyota grin ear to ear.

https://www.youtube.com/@the_best_car_content/videos

Edited Tuesday at 12:57 PM by Pib

[JBChiangRai]

42 minutes ago, Pib said:

 

 

Well, be sure to watch all the other videos on the channel...Chase Car....see their video list below...almost every one is negative on EVs.   And many of the videos---like the one we are talking about---are simply reruns with minor variations made to make it appear like late breaking news....click bait.  It just one of those youtube channels that is dedicated to negative/anti-EV videos....makes Mr Toyota grin ear to ear.

https://www.youtube.com/@the_best_car_content/videos

Mr.Toyota probably funds them

[KhunLA]

 

[Yellowtail]

3 minutes ago, KhunLA said:

 

Probably BYD funded 

[Pib]

While many make EV sales predictions (and rants) have been based on bad or good months/quarters (like the 1st quarter that is typically down) we should really be focusing on what the long term trend is such as year-over-year....and it's up, up, up...see the blue long term trend I drew in....I'm such an artist.  

 

 

[Yellowtail]

Toyota Land Cruiser is sold out for 4 years | Fox Business

[Pib]

15 minutes ago, Yellowtail said:

Toyota Land Cruiser is sold out for 4 years | Fox Business

That's a two and half years old article from Jan 2022

[Yellowtail]

15 minutes ago, Pib said:

That's a two and half years old article from Jan 2022

And? 

[Yellowtail]

It's down to 12-24 months. 

 

How long does it take to get a new Seal or MG? 

[Pib]

26 minutes ago, Yellowtail said:

And? 

Why reference such an old article that didn't even talk how many had been reserved/sold.   1 million, 10,000, or maybe just 1,000, 100, etc..   When I started googling on the subject I found numerous articles talking about the Land Cruiser over the last several years like below Dec 2023 article talking it selling out in Germany....but it was only 1000 Land Crusiers.  Kinda sounds like Toyota gives individual countries a low allotment just so they can say they sold out in country XYZ in 30 minutes....sounds more like an Toyota sponsored advertising technique/media release.

 

https://www.carscoops.com/2023/12/first-1000-2024-toyota-land-cruisers-in-germany-sold-out-in-just-30-minutes/

 

[KhunLA]

4 hours ago, Yellowtail said:

Toyota Land Cruiser is sold out for 4 years | Fox Business

You can't fix stupid ... 

 

"It’s not such good news for Land Rover owners, whose cars rank the lowest of any passenger vehicle in the United States. Though its standing improved somewhat from 2022’s ranking of 284 PP100, Land Rover ranks as the least reliable badge at 273 PP100 for 2023."

source

 

With a few recalls

Edited 13 hours ago by KhunLA

[JetsetBkk]

On 7/2/2024 at 7:46 AM, JBChiangRai said:

 

I bought a Mini Cooper S Convertible for my office manager as a company car, he left shortly afterwards so I drove it for a couple of weeks.  I couldn't get comfortable in it, the car gave me backache so had to sell it.  It's the most uncomfortable car I have ever driven.

I've been in it only once and it sure was small inside. But it was very quick and cornered well - it had to, as he was driving it like a boy racer. 🙄